https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/carney-new-york-speech-9.7214907
A strong Canada 'will help make America great again,' Carney tells New York business leaders
Carney says Canada and U.S. need a 'new partnership'
Prime Minister Mark Carney told a crowd of New York industry titans and financiers on Thursday that Canada and the U.S. need to pursue a new partnership — a bilateral relationship premised not on how things were done in the past but one where a stronger, more independent Canada can selectively help "make America great again."
Carney said as U.S. President Donald Trump prompts "tectonic shifts" in trade, and as the world becomes "more divided and dangerous," Canada must focus more on "taking care of ourselves" and building up at home by embracing its status as an energy superpower.
But that doesn't mean Canada wants to close itself off from the U.S., Carney said in lunchtime remarks to about 200 attendees at the city's Yale Club.
Rather, he said the government wants the two sides to pursue a "true partnership" and better co-operate on some strategic sectors, notably those hammered by Trump's sectoral tariffs.
Nodding to the "Fortress North America" concept floated by Ontario Premier Doug Ford and some U.S. interests, which prioritizes continental co-operation in the face of Chinese economic threats, Carney said this new relationship would "re-imagine co-operation in specific sectors deeply challenged by global competition."
Carney said the U.S. is dependent on Canadian oil, natural gas, electricity, aluminum, potash, nickel, copper and industrial components, and the two sides should do more business together in these sectors, not less.
"That is mutual strength. Canada Strong will help make America great again. The examples are legion where we should work together and compete with the world together," he said.
Carney said his government has pitched "specific, practical proposals," on autos, aluminum, energy and minerals to the Americans to move on from this period of trade antagonism.
Carney didn't say what the reception has been to those ideas. But there have been no formal trade talks in months, and there are no apparent signs a breakthrough is imminent.
Carney signalled that the old relationship where a subservient Canada essentially falls in line with what the U.S. wants is over.
What should replace it is a bilateral relationship featuring "a different Canada, a stronger Canada, a more confident Canada" that can deliver what the U.S needs on more equitable terms, he said.
Those ideas drew applause from the crowd, which included U.S.-based staff of Canadian banks and prominent businesspeople like billionaire real estate and grocery magnate John Catsimatidis.
Speaking later during a fireside chat with the Economic Club of New York, Carney projected some confidence that there will be a resolution to the irritants that plague the Canada-U.S. trading relationship.
"We'll work our way through it," Carney said.
Carney said Canada is leaning into its strengths, developing energy and investing in the defence and space sectors — creating "huge opportunities" for the U.S. because the economy at home is getting bigger and richer.
On energy in particular, Carney said, Canada sits on an abundance of oil and gas and generates clean electricity that can help power the economic revolution that's underway stateside as artificial intelligence-related development explodes.
There will be an "acute" energy shortage in the U.S. as AI takes off, Carney said, and Canada "can be part of the solution."
Carney raised the government's recent decision to fast-track a major graphite mine in Quebec and help negotiate a major B.C. LNG purchase agreement with Germany, as examples of Ottawa moving quickly to stand up industries that make lucrative products the world needs.
Developing those resources, sometimes in partnership with American interests, "is a structural solution to a new partnership with the U.S.," he said.
Carney's call for a better and reworked partnership follows a recent shift in tone on the U.S. issue.
While still stressing there's been a "rupture" in the Canada-U.S. relationship amid Trump's protectionist push, this is the second high-profile speech in as many weeks where he has called for a peaceful resolution to trade issues as the CUSMA review date of July 1 looms.
In a recent address to progressive activists in Toronto, Carney said Canada "remains open to deeper integration" with the U.S. in certain sectors.
"And to be clear, those offers are on the table," he said.
U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer has insisted that some tariffs will remain on Canadian goods. (Aurelien Morissard/The Associated Press)Carney's remarks come at a time when U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer insists there will be tariffs on some Canadian goods, something Carney's negotiators are actively trying to avoid.
"We have to have some degree of tariff to deal with the giant deficit," Greer said this week during a speech at the Council on Foreign Relations in Washington.
"Most countries said, 'We understand and we will remove some non-tariff barriers.' Canada's approach has been different," he said.
Greer's office announced Wednesday a series of dates over the summer when the U.S. and Mexico will sit down to negotiate the upcoming CUSMA review. No dates were set for talks with Canada.
However, a spokesperson for Canada-U.S. Trade Minister Dominic LeBlanc told CBC News that "planning is underway" for a trip to Washington sometime soon.
Like Carney on Thursday, Greer said there are areas where there is "common economic benefit," like energy, critical minerals and fertilizer.
But "when it comes to some economic goods, we have a different view," he said, pointing to autos as an area where the U.S. wants to dominate and, in turn, suppress Canadian manufacturing through the aggressive use of tariffs.
"I think on some of these issues it will be a challenging negotiation but on some issues it will be fine," he said.
Steve Verheul, Canada's former top trade negotiator who helped broker CUSMA, said Canada is in a difficult position.
The Americans are demanding important concessions — scrapping the Online Streaming Act, reworking dairy import quotas and dropping the provincial ban on U.S. liquor — while offering seemingly no tariff relief in return.
"I think we're we're pretty firmly stuck," he said. "There's a negotiating table that isn't lining up very well in terms of even having a conversation.
"I think we really are in a position where we could be stuck for a considerable period of time."
Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre, meanwhile, criticized what he described as Carney's "buzzword-laden" speech, saying it's not clear where the prime minister stands on the U.S. relationship.
"On the one hand he says that we are in the middle of a rupture with the United States. While on the other he says he wants to make America, in his words, 'great again.' He can't seem to decide if integration with the U.S. is a strength or a weakness," Poilievre said.
Separatists are working to convince Albertans to vote for separation and the UCP is taking a stand for staying in Canada. Duane Bratt, a political scientist, and John Santos, a political analyst, discuss these topics and more on the Politics Panel.

'Canada Strong will help make America great again': Carney pitches new partnership with U.S.
The
Brotman Generating Station in Rosharon, Texas, has similar components
and layout as the proposed project that ProEnergy will build in
Tantramar. (ProEnergy)
The
New Brunswick Energy and Utilities Board panel that approved the
Tantramar gas plant proposal, from left to right, Kenneth McCullogh,
chair Christopher Stewart and John Logan. (New Brunswick Energy and Utilities Board livestream)
Tantramar gas plant greenlit by Energy and Utilities Board
Atlantic Wildlife Institute director Barry Rothfuss was disappointed but not surprised by the EUB decision. (Chad Ingraham / CBC)
Université
de Moncton professor of engineering Yves Gagnon says the plant's
technology will allow for better integration of renewable energy. (Erica Butler/CBC)
ProEnergy
plans to build a 10-turbine gas plant in a rural area near Centre
Village, at the intersection of the Maritimes and Northeast natural gas
pipeline and N.B. Power's transmission line. (Roger Cosman/CBC)
Early praise for Liberal bill to beef up energy advocate’s role
Randy Hatfield, executive director of the Human Development Council, also supported the development. (Graham Thompson/CBC)
Progressive Conservative Energy Critic Kris Austin said the bill was an empty gesture. (Chad Ingraham/CBC)

N.B. Power proposal has solar industry seeing dark clouds ahead
(CBC)
Chris Meechan is a member of Solar NB Solaire and national solar director for Greenfoot Energy Solutions, based in Moncton. (CBC)
Brad Coady, N.B. Power's chief commercial officer, said the utility's current net metering program is not sustainable. (CBC)

Holt Liberals delay some major N.B. Power decisions
Energy Minister René Legacy said none of the review panel's recommendations made have been rejected. (Tara King-Stewart/CBC)
Splitting
the Point Lepreau nuclear generating station into its own separate
business is another suggestion the government will analyze further. (Shane Fowler/CBC)
New Brunswick petroleum prices jumped five cents Friday after an Energy and Utilities Board decision. (Axel Tardieu/Radio-Canada)
Why New Brunswickers are paying more for gas, despite government promise of action
Petroleum
retailers applied to the Energy and Utilities Board last fall to retain
charges that allowed them to pass oil company environmental costs
through to consumers. (Roger Cosman/CBC)
Premier
Susan Holt said, when she was opposition leader, that allowing federal
environmental costs on refineries to pass through to consumers was the
'wrong decision.' (Mikael Mayer/CBC)
New
Brunswick Finance and Energy Minister René Legacy told reporters
Thursday the EUB decision that raised charges on motorists for oil
company environmental costs showed 'very good work.' (Jacques Poitras/CBC)
John
Stillwell, manager of Johnny’s Gas Bar in Douglas and Island View, said
customers are having trouble affording the rising cost of fuel. (Shane Fowler/CBC)
New Brunswickers react to news of price reduction at pumps
Ingrid O’Donnell said the federal tax suspension will help her family afford summer road trips. (Shane Fowler/CBC)
Francis Morissette, right, drives a pickup truck for work and said it costs him around $250 to $300 to fill his tank. (Shane Fowler/CBC)
405 Comments