Monday 4 December 2023

Union leaders warn of illegal strikes over Higgs's pension bill

 

Union leaders warn of illegal strikes over Higgs's pension bill

CUPE officials say members could ‘match’ government legislation with job action

Public-sector union officials have raised the possibility of illegal strikes by their members over a Higgs government bill that would force them into a new pension plan.

The province introduced the legislation last week, which affects five different employee groups, and it could pass and become law by Friday.

Leaders of the Canadian Union of Public Employees were coy during a news conference Monday about whether they would encourage or approve of wildcat walkouts.

"I'm sure you can appreciate that as union leaders, we're not going to encourage our members to do illegal action," said Sandy Harding, the union's regional director.

"Now what our members decide to do on their own — our very angry members — we're going to have to listen to what they're saying," said Harding, who acknowledged no workers are in a legal strike position.

"They believe what the government is doing is illegal. We believe it as well. … Our members will decide what they're going to do to match that illegal action." 

A woman in white louse with blond hair speaks into a microphone. Sandy Harding, regional director for the Canadian Union of Public Employees, warned MLAs to 'think about their political future' if they want to get re-elected. (Radio-Canada)

CUPE New Brunswick president Stephen Drost said he would not put himself "and the members at risk by divulging what we may or may not do. We are looking at any and all possible action, up to and including job action."

No one from the Higgs government was immediately available to respond to the threat.

The Pension Plan Sustainability and Transfer Act would force two CUPE locals in the education sector and three groups in the New Brunswick Council of Nursing Home Unions into a process to determine the future of their pension plans.

It requires them to choose one of three different shared-risk pension plans and for the transition to begin by Feb. 1.

A man wears a dark jacket and light blue shirt. He has a mustache and silver hair. Stephen Drost, president of the Canadian Union of Public Employees in New Brunswick, says some PC MLAs have told CUPE they were surprised by the legislation. (Jacques Poitras/CBC)

The two CUPE locals, representing school custodians, maintenance workers, bus drivers and administrative staff, signed a side agreement on pensions with the province in 2021 at the end of a 16-day strike.

It set up a separate process to resolve the issue.

Last week, Premier Blaine Higgs accused the union of dragging its feet and declared it was time to legislate a solution.

CUPE says the contract it signed in 2021 does not allow the province to do that, making the legislation a violation of the agreement and of collective bargaining rights.

A man in a blue suit and white shirt stands in hallway talking to reporters. The Higgs government has said it will extend the session past the scheduled Friday adjournment if that's what is needed to pass the bill. (Ed Hunter/CBC)

Drost and Harding said CUPE local presidents and other union leaders from around the province would meet Tuesday to discuss how to respond.

"We have every option on the table at this point," Drost said.

"We certainly are looking at every action, and this is not just going to be symbolic."

The CUPE leaders also had a warning for Progressive Conservative MLAs who will be campaigning for re-election in 2024.

"All MLAs had better think about their political future in this," Harding said.

"If they want to get elected again, they better understand how this touches all New Brunswickers. It touches all labour workers, in this province and nationally, when you bring in a law that breaks signed collective agreements." 

Drost said some PC MLAs have told CUPE they were "extremely surprised" by the legislation and he encouraged them to speak up and encourage Higgs to withdraw the bill.

The opposition Liberals have vowed to debate the bill at length, while the Green Party says it will use all the procedural tools it has in the legislature to block it altogether.

The government said last week it will extend the session past the scheduled Friday adjournment for Christmas if that's what is needed to pass the bill.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR


Jacques Poitras

Provincial Affairs reporter

Jacques Poitras has been CBC's provincial affairs reporter in New Brunswick since 2000. He grew up in Moncton and covered Parliament in Ottawa for the New Brunswick Telegraph-Journal. He has reported on every New Brunswick election since 1995 and won awards from the Radio Television Digital News Association, the National Newspaper Awards and Amnesty International. He is also the author of five non-fiction books about New Brunswick politics and history.

CBC's Journalistic Standards and Practices
 
 
 
218 Comments 
 
 
 
David Amos 
Higgs legislation would force 5 public-sector unions into new pension plan

Workers say premier’s bill breaks contract by forcing them into shared-risk system

Jacques Poitras · CBC News · Posted: Nov 29, 2023 4:53 PM AST

"The legal expert hired by the province to oversee this move says the shared-risk model has performed well for the employees who joined it almost a decade ago.

"The results have been very good for the members and we anticipate the results to be very good for these members as well," said Halifax lawyer Hugh The legal expert hired by the province to oversee this move says the shared-risk model has performed well for the employees who joined it almost a decade ago.

"The results have been very good for the members and we anticipate the results to be very good for these members as well," said Halifax lawyer Hugh Wright.The legal expert hired by the province to oversee this move says the shared-risk model has performed well for the employees who joined it almost a decade ago.

"The results have been very good for the members and we anticipate the results to be very good for these members as well," said Halifax lawyer Hugh Wright.."

I wonder if Higgy told Mr Wright what I thought of actuaries back in 2013

 
 
 
David Amos
Deja Vu Anyone?

Higgs legislation would force 5 public-sector unions into new pension plan

Workers say premier’s bill breaks contract by forcing them into shared-risk system

Jacques Poitras · CBC News · Posted: Nov 29, 2023 4:53 PM AST 

 

 
David Amos  
"Sandy Harding, regional director for the Canadian Union of Public Employees, warned MLAs to 'think about their political future' if they want to get re-elected."

Too Too Funny

 
Don Corey   
Reply to David Wilson
Well put Mr. Amos. Most of what comes out of these high profile CUPE reps confirms that they think they're still back in the 1970's and 80's. 
 
 
Rosco holt
Reply to Don Corey
The issue is government can't replace these workers easily has before.  

 

 

Phil Nadeau 
I blame both parties (union and GNB) for this situation. Both parties were supposed to come to a solution before the end of the contract or before it end. Why did no one moved on this? I know that it's not right what the GNB is doing to this contract but hey the rest of GNB are on shared risk, why are they so special? 
 
 
Barbara Canuski 
Reply to Phil Nadeau 
Not everyone in GNB is on shared risk. Provincial government deputy ministers still are on the defined benefit plan. That would be a good story for Poitras to pursue.
 
 
David Amos 
Reply to Barbara Canuski 
Dream on  
 
 
Donald LeBlanc
Reply to Phil Nadeau
Well Nurses never had a Union at the time who would stand up for their people, even as a Justice wrote a decision that said already vested Pensioners should not have their pensions changed. Higgs under Alward put through Legislation that circumvented the Justice’s Decision, much as we are seeing occur today. 
 
 
 
Barbara Canuski 
Funny how the Premier wants everyone on shared risk pension plan but did you know his deputy ministers pension plan still remains defined benefit with no talk of changing it to shared risk. 
 
 
Bobby Richards
Reply to Barbara Canuski  
Not everyone in GNB is on shared risk. Provincial government deputy ministers still are on the defined benefit plan. That would be a good story for Poitras to pursue. 
 
 
Geordan Mann  
Reply to Barbara Canuski
But not work for the underlings. They were switched to transferred-risk as soon as the legislation was changed.  
 
 
Barbara Canuski 
Reply to Geordan Mann   
Correct!
 
 
Bobby Richards 
Reply to Geordan Mann 
Isn't this legislation going switch the entire pension to shared risk? 
 
 
Geordan Mann  
Reply to Barbara Canuski
Probably but I have no idea, don't care, does not apply to me. I do know how it was implemented during the first kick at this can though. I don't like hypocrites and I don't like fund managers who are rewarded for sub-par performance. Especially when they are really paid by taxes.  
 
 
Barbara Canuski  
Reply to Bobby Richards
Nope. No talk of MLAs or deputy ministers switching from their defined benefit plan to shared risk.
 
 
Bobby Richards
Reply to Barbara Canuski  
I realize they wont. lol 

 
Barbara Canuski 
Reply to Geordan Mann
Maybe visit the lobby of Vescor in downtown Fredericton and you will be appalled by the marble and floor to ceiling glass. Most luxurious office space in Fredericton bar none! 
 
 
David Amos 

Reply to Bobby Richards
"Higgs' MLA pension from pre-shared risk plan (2013?) still stays as defined."

Higgy and I had a very public argument about that right after a debate in Hampton in 2015 on the very night Trudeau was in the area

 
 
 
Ronald Miller 
 
Would you expect less from a group whose symbol is a closed fist. Get to work, do your job, and stop wasting everyone's time because you don't get everything your way. Your current pension system is unsustainable, fact, and taxpayers will not tolerate being held hostage by you and on the hook for shortcomings.  
 
 
David Amos 
 
Reply to Ronald Miller 
Its a small wonder to me why you use other people's names to post your nasty comments  
 
 
SW Home
Reply to Ronald Miller
"taxpayers will not tolerate being held hostage by you and on the hook for shortcomings." The same thing could be said to Higgs 
 
 
 
 

No comments:

Post a Comment