Thursday 25 April 2024

Higgs defends hiring of Conservative consultants at taxpayer expense

 

Higgs defends hiring of Conservative consultants at taxpayer expense

Premier admits their views are ‘in line with our party’ but says it ensures ‘a diversity of opinion’

Higgs defends hiring of Conservative consultants at taxpayer expense

Duration 1:38
Premier Blaine Higgs faces questions from opposition MLAs about contracts with advisers whose views are ‘in line with our party.’

Premier Blaine Higgs has defended his government's hiring of two well-known Conservative campaign consultants at taxpayer expense as he prepares for an election campaign this fall.

Higgs told opposition MLAs on a legislative committee that the two consultants, Derek Robinson and Steve Outhouse, would not be doing any partisan work at taxpayer expense.

Robinson is the founder of Mash Strategy, a Calgary-based consulting firm that has done work for various conservative parties and leaders. 

Outhouse is the campaign manager for Higgs's Progressive Conservative re-election bid this year, but is also working in the premier's office as principal secretary, a taxpayer-funded position.

"There are no taxpayer dollars used for the political role in any of this," Higgs said, arguing that Outhouse would be doing campaign work on his own time.

"The separation between the night duties and the day duties would be very clear," he told the committee during its study of the budget estimates for his office and the executive council office that he heads.

A group of men stand in a group at a conference. Two face the camera. Steve Outhouse with Blaine Higgs at a Canada Strong and Free Network conference in Ottawa. Earlier this spring, he confirmed Outhouse would join his staff in the premier's office on a $125,000 contract that runs until the election. (Kate McKenna/CBC)

Higgs offered a similar guarantee that Mash Strategy's work for the government would not cross over into the election campaign.

Green Leader David Coon questioned the hiring of Mash, which says on its website that its mantra is "think politically, act creatively" and claims it has gained experience "in political war rooms."

"It's not just 'thinking politically,' it's thinking politically in a certain ideological direction that's clear, that's being brought to bear on their work," Coon said.

The $72,000 paid to Mash is "a very small portion" of what the government spends on more than 80 firms providing communications services, Higgs said.

'A look from outside,' premier says

Liberal MLA René Legacy said the hiring of the Calgary-based consulting firm contradicted the government's frequent rhetoric about a "New Brunswick-first" approach to contracting.

Higgs responded that he wanted to incorporate "a look from outside" into efforts to promote New Brunswick's successes across Canada. 

"I want to be sure our perspective is not limited to one region, one province," he said.

A man is standing in the legislature gesturing with his hands, another man sits beside him smiling. The premier speaks in the legislature Thursday, with Steve Outhouse sitting on the right. (Legislative Assembly of New Brunswick)

The premier said the government must communicate on issues that "seem to be rather straightforward issues to some and very controversial issues to others."

He didn't dispute that Robinson and Mash have a conservative viewpoint "more in line with our party" but said that ensures "a diversity of opinion" among consultants advising the government.

"We deal with companies that have views in all directions," he said.

But he acknowledged that the advice would shape "a message coming from the premier's office and everybody knows I'm a Conservative." 

Higgs announced last fall that Outhouse, who ran Alberta Premier Danielle Smith's re-election campaign last year, would be the campaign manager for the New Brunswick PC party this year.

Earlier this spring he confirmed Outhouse would join his staff in the premier's office on a $125,000 contract that runs until the election.

Calculated relative to an annual salary, Coon said that compensation exceeds the normal range of $150,000 to $175,000 for a principal secretary.

Higgs justified the money by reading extensively from Outhouse's resumé, listing several positions he held with the federal government, including as a staffer to cabinet ministers in the Harper government.

"All of that is to say that Mr. Outhouse comes with an extensive degree of credentials and relevant experience to what we experience as a government." 

A bald man in a suit and tie is standing and speaking.Green Leader David Coon says Outhouse's public salary works out to more than the normal range of $150,000 to $175,000 for a principal secretary. (The Legislative Assembly of New Brunswick)

The questioning about Outhouse was short-lived because of how the opposition Liberals used the time allocated to them during the estimates process.

Opposition parties get a total of 80 hours to examine estimates from all government departments and offices, and they decide for themselves how to divide up that time.

Higgs's office told them the premier would be available all day Wednesday, giving them about eight hours with him.

But the Liberals and Greens chose to use most of Wednesday's time on other departments and on Higgs's other responsibilities, leaving the Liberals with no remaining time to devote to the premier's office and Coon with only 20 minutes. 

"The Premier made himself available for eight hours of questioning [Wednesday]," Higgs's director of communications Nicolle Carlin said via text message.

"This was well-known by the Opposition that this was the period of time the Premier was available, and would give them time to ask all their questions."

ABOUT THE AUTHOR


Jacques Poitras

Provincial Affairs reporter

Jacques Poitras has been CBC's provincial affairs reporter in New Brunswick since 2000. He grew up in Moncton and covered Parliament in Ottawa for the New Brunswick Telegraph-Journal. He has reported on every New Brunswick election since 1995 and won awards from the Radio Television Digital News Association, the National Newspaper Awards and Amnesty International. He is also the author of five non-fiction books about New Brunswick politics and history.

 

16 Comments   
 
 
 
David Amos   
Methinks Higgy's key words today were "seem to be" Nesy Pas?

"The premier said the government must communicate on issues that "seem to be rather straightforward issues to some and very controversial issues to others."

 
 
 
Le Wier
Is Outhouse’s main job Higgs’ campaign Manage, and his position as secretary to the Premier Higgs is his side hustle? .
 

David Amos
Reply to Le Wier
Yup 


Le Wier
Reply to David Amos 
Wow a hundred thousand dollar side hustle. Most NBers can’t get one job that pays that, and they often have 2 university degrees. I know these are inflationary times, but come on. 
 
 
David Amos
Reply to Le Wier
Outhouse doesn't hold a candle to his buddy Jenni
 
 
Le Wier
Reply to David Amos 
I wonder if Outhouse got his moving expenses, and realty fees paid for by GNB or PCNB? 
 
 
David Amos
Reply to Le Wier
Outhouse aint that dumb 
 
 
 
 
Benny Swim
Higgs is this government. Why in heaven's name would Holt and Coon not choose to take the 8 hours to ask only him questions about how he runs this government. Several cabinet minister's have quit, publicly stating that Higgs' does not consult anyone before making decisions (well, at least if you are not from Alberta) so why would the opposition parties choose to question other ministers and even more weirdly public servants about minatuea of government operations in department blah, blah?

We are badly served in this province by our elected representatives.

Notice how Higgs identifies himself as a conservative. The problem is that he leads the Progressive Conservative Party of NB.

And the credentials of his imported advisors are for working for those in this country who can only be described as being on the far right.


David Amos
Reply to Benny Swim
"The problem is that he leads the Progressive Conservative Party of NB"

Amen

 
Al Clark
Reply to Benny Swim  
In name only. He is finally the defacto leader of the party he has pined for for nearly half a century - cor
 
 
 

Dave Kovic 
  
 
 
Daniel Henwell
Reply to Dave Kovic
 
 
Dave Kovic 
Reply to Daniel Henwell 
It's in keeping with the 'something is only bad when the other guys do it' mindset.
 
 
MR Cain 
Reply to Dave Kovic 
These consultants are intended for campaigning and are paid by taxpayers; big difference.
 
 
Eddy Geek 
Reply to Dave Kovic

Are the Federal Liberals hiring purely partisan based campaigning personel at taxpayers expense???

No??

then what is your misguided point?

Dave Kovic 
Reply to Eddy Geek
In other words: Something is only bad when the other guys do it.

Thank you for proving my point.


David Amos
Reply to Dave Kovic
Well put
 
Lou Bell
Funny , I copied this one too .
 
 
David Amos
Reply to Lou Bell
I blogged it
 
 
 
 
Alison Jackson 
" I do what I want! Whatever!"

Eric Cartman

  
David Amos
Reply to Alison Jackson
Who said they were entitled to their entitlements? 
 
 
 
Brian Robertson
It was always fine when the Liberals did it.

Why the big fuss now?

 
 
MR Cain
Reply to Brian Robertson
Why the need to make up stories? This is all new stuff of the Cor party.
 
 
David Amos
Reply to Brian Robertson
Why not?
 
 
Benny Swim
Reply to Brian Robertson
I'm no Grit but during what time did the Liberals have their election campaign manager (for an election 6 months away) working as staff in the premier's office?
 
 
 
 
 

Margaret Melanson confirmed as permanent Horizon CEO

 
 

Margaret Melanson confirmed as permanent Horizon CEO

Melanson declines to be interviewed after province announces her appointment

After two years as interim CEO, Margaret Melanson has been confirmed as the new permanent president and CEO of one of New Brunswick's two health authorities.

Melanson declined an interview request from CBC News after the announcement about what she's accomplished in the past two years ​and what she plans to do as Horizon addresses continuing health-care challenges in New Brunswick.

She was appointed CEO after Premier Blaine Higgs fired Dr. John Dornan in 2022. She was Horizon's vice-president clinical services at the time.

The premier fired Dornan and dropped his health minister after a man died while awaiting care in an emergency department's waiting room. The province was later ordered to pay out $2 million to Dornan for unjust dismissal.

A news release from Horizon said Melanson has worked to address health care challenges by focusing on four priorities: "access to services, patient flow, recruitment and retention, and patient experience." The release does not provide further information.

Liberal health critic Rob McKee said he's glad to see the interim tag removed from the CEO position, because it means more stability for the health network.

"I feel like it's been holding things back. They've been moving at a snail's pace in terms of addressing some of the major health-care issues that we're seeing, and hopefully removing the interim tag will allow her to fulfil her obligations," he said.

Hired by a board fully appointed by minister

The CEO is hired by the Horizon board. Since her appointment, the government passed legislation that removed the elected members of the board. The remaining seven members are all appointed by the minister of health.

Stephanie Collin, professor of health management at the Université de Moncton, said it's a typical to see interim CEOs become permanent in New Brunswick, even before the Higgs government, so this decision is not surprising.

She said it's difficult to tell how much politics played a role in choosing the CEO.

"It brings questions, I think, in people minds," she said. "What is the the real power of the board? But what is also the real hand ... of the CEO, if there's a direct link here with the government?"

Melanson was at the centre of controversy when leaked audio revealed that she asked an Ambulance New Brunswick dispatcher to break the service's own policy by transporting a patient from his home in Fredericton to the Saint John Regional Hospital. In the audio, she said, "This is a political issue," and that Premier Blaine Higgs was "upset."

Long-term care patients and hospital beds

The last time Melanson spoke to media, it was in response to complaints of filthy and overflowing ERs over the holidays and diverted ambulances.

In January, Melanson said the health authority was making progress in improving wait times at emergency departments, but there's much work yet to be done when it comes to people waiting in hospital for long-term care.

As of January there were a total of 542 people waiting in Horizon hospitals for nursing home or special care home beds, Melanson previously said, representing 33 per cent of Horizon's total inpatient beds.

Horizon's four regional hospitals have an average overall occupancy level of 106 per cent, she said at the time, while the national benchmark is 85 per cent.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Hadeel Ibrahim is a reporter with CBC New Brunswick based in Saint John. She reports in English and Arabic. Email: hadeel.ibrahim@cbc.ca.

CBC's Journalistic Standards and Practices
 
 
10 Comments   
 
 
David Amos  
Content Deactivated
I bet she is praying that Higgy will fire her so she can make the big score just like her predecessor did.
 
 
 
Dave Kliveland 
Permanent…..if she is the one responsible for the mess Horizon Health has been in the last two she should be shown the exit.  
 
 
 
Doug kirby 
She obviously passed the higgs test  
 
 
  
Samual Johnston
Present all the facts....

"The province was later ordered to pay out $2 million to Dornan for unjust dismissal."

This is true but then the Province appealed and then they settled.

.
 
Kyle Woodman  
Ronald thinks he's pretty clever.
 
 
 
 
Margaret Flowers
Two years and nothing to show for it? Nice gig. .
 
 
Kyle Woodman
Content Deactivated
Reply to Margaret Flowers
 
 
Kyle Woodman  
Reply to Kyle Woodman 
Having fun impersonating me Ronald? 
 
 
Cindy Sheppard 
Reply to Margaret Flowers 
In the past two years, even as an interim CEO, should your role not have included working on the four identified priorities of "access to services, patient flow, recruitment and retention, and patient experience." And, if that has been the work you've been doing for the past two year, it would be awesome to see the workplan, KPI's, inputs/outputs etc. If not, what has the last two years work resulted in? It would be good to know how that time was used to improve the system.
 
 
Margaret Flowers 
Reply to Margaret Flowers
@Cindy Sheppard… exactly. No time for an interview, but she did mange to update her LinkIn page this morning with the announcement of her permanent appointment, and probably spent time reading through the ensuing accolades and congratulatory messages.
 
 
Benoit Boudreau
Reply to Margaret Flowers 
You are probably correct and that is just gross. We all know Higgs doesn't like data unless it suits his narrative.
 
 
MR Cain
Reply to Kyle Woodman  
This is a far cry from sarcasm. It is a feeble attempt at distraction by making up stories to compensate for the lack of knowledge on any subject.
 
 
 
 
 
 

 

Vitalité seeks partner for daycare pilot for health-care workers in Restigouche

 

Vitalité seeks partner for daycare pilot for health-care workers in Restigouche

Request for proposals to be issued in weeks after regional leaders call delay 'unacceptable'

The Restigouche region could be a step closer to getting a daycare pilot for health-care workers, according to the head of Vitalité Health Network.

The regional health authority plans to issue a request for proposals for a partner to run such a daycare "in the next few weeks," president and CEO Dr. France Desrosiers told CBC News.

It would be Vitalité's first in New Brunswick.

Desrosiers made the comments following Vitalité's public board meeting in Campbellton on Tuesday, where several regional leaders used the question period to reiterate the urgent need for a designated daycare that would operate seven days a week and at least 12 hours a day, if not 24.

"For almost two years now, we've been discussing the need for a daycare for healthcare workers," said Brad Mann, president and chair of the Restigouche Regional Service Commission, which encompasses the municipalities, communities and local service districts from Durham Parish (excluding Belledune) in the East to the Kedgwick rural community in the West.

A portrait of a man with dark hair, wearing a red collared shirt and blue blazer.     A daycare is one of the top priorities for the Restigouche Regional Service Commission, said president and chair Brad Mann. (Submitted by Brad Mann)

"Some existing employees are unable to return from maternity [and] other leaves because they cannot find a daycare," he said. "Others do not accept positions here because they have no daycare."

"[In] March 2023, we were assured the daycare would be in place by September. We're now April 2024 and it is still in development."

It's "unacceptable," said Mann, who called for a "commitment and a timeline" for a daycare to be established.

Could reduce need for travel nurses

Normand Pelletier, mayor of Heron Bay, said a daycare is needed, not only to help nurses get back to work, but also to attract young professionals to the region.

"We spoke with the premier and his departments [last year] and they support us completely in this process," Pelletier said in French.

"Now we have several travelling nurses. And they're very expensive for the province," he said, after the meeting heard Vitalité is nearly $98 million over budget for the first 11 months of the 2023–2024 fiscal year, $94.2 million of which is because of expenses related to travel nurses.

"We're certain that [a daycare] can help solve the issues at the Campbellton Hospital in terms of staffing."

'A cry from the heart'

Campbellton Mayor Jean-Guy Levesque told the board "aggressive solutions" are needed and described a daycare as a "concrete solution that should already have been implemented."

He noted the municipality recently secured $4.5 million from the federal government and plans to build at least 200 housing units, which should help with recruitment.

But when health-care professionals move to the area, they bring their families with them, he said.

"We [will] take care of their housing, but if we don't take care of the daycare problem, people will not come to Restigouche."

A portrait of a man with glasses, wearing a white collared shirt with thin blue stripes and a blue blazer, with other people standing around, talking in the background. Campbellton Mayor Jean-Guy Levesque said the municipality and regional service commission could help Vitalité find a partner for the daycare. (Serge Bouchard/Radio-Canada)

Levesque, a public servant for 35 years, urged the board to "pay attention."

"This is a cry from the heart," he said. "We really need this daycare — and quickly."

'Can't do it on our own'

Desrosiers said during the meeting that a daycare has "always been part of [Vitalité's] vision."

But "we can't do it on our own," she said. "We need support."

Later, she told CBC Vitalité's mandate is to deliver health care, not run a daycare.

"So we are looking for partnership in the community," she said, adding another holdup has been getting enough funded spaces, because that's what employees are looking for.

 A portrait of a woman with long, wavy hair and glasses, wearing a red top, speaking.  Dr. France Desrosiers, president and CEO of Vitalité Health Network, said Restigouche is the right place for a daycare pilot because that's where the biggest recruitment challenge is. (Gilles Boudreau/Radio-Canada)

Initially, Vitalité got fewer than 20 spaces, Desrosiers said. The situation is "better now," but she could not provide a number.

The Department of Education and Early Childhood Development did not respond to a request for comment Wednesday.

Pursuing daycares for Saint John, Fredericton 

"Horizon is actively working toward providing daycare services in Saint John and Fredericton, in collaboration with our hospital foundations," said president and CEO Margaret Melanson.

"We have made very good progress to date, and we hope to have further announcements later this spring."

She said Horizon already has a daycare at the Moncton Hospital, which is used by staff as well as members of the community.

In early 2022, Horizon conducted a survey about the possibility of creating a daycare program either onsite or near the Saint John Regional Hospital and the Dr. Everett Chalmers Regional Hospital in Fredericton. It's conducting another survey to better understand how many children and what age groups would potentially use the program, according to its website.

Neighbouring Nova Scotia has a round-the-clock daycare pilot underway in Sydney; the Health Park Early Learning Centre. The province covers the wages when extra staff are required, food for the evening program, and a quarter of the operating costs of the daycare, such as heat and electricity. It also subsidizes half the daycare fees for parents. 

In Newfoundland and Labrador, four daycare sites with a combined 180 spaces and hours that are suitable for health-care workers are expected to be open by the end of the year.

Best location in dispute

Vitalité has identified a location for the Restigouche daycare "five minutes" away from the hospital, said Desrosiers.

She declined to say exactly where, because some health-care professionals work there now and have not yet been informed that they may need to move.

The former addiction services building on Gallant Dr. had been flagged by the regional services commission as an ideal location, because it's between the Campbellton Regional Hospital and Restigouche Hospital Centre, and near the new detox centre — roughly 1,300 health-care workers, according to Mann.

But that site was deemed "not appropriate" because of its proximity to the highway and certain services, such as detox, which Desrosiers said raised concerns about safety for the children.

The other proposed location, in hospital, was quickly ruled out too because the renovation costs would be "three times" as high, and the space is needed for beds, she added.

Desrosiers could not say how quickly a daycare could be up and running, but did say she is "optimistic" about the request for proposals process, as some private contractors have already expressed interest.

Support from health professionals

The New Brunswick Nurses Union supports calls by the Restigouche Regional Service Commission to establish a daycare program for health-care workers, said president Paula Doucet.

"It's one piece of a very large puzzle," she said, referring to recruitment and retention.

A portrait of a woman with shoulder-length brown hair, wearing a grey blouse and royal blue jacket. Just finding a daycare spot can be difficult, but it's even more challenging for nurses when many daycares only operate between 8 a.m. and 5 p.m., and they often work 7 a.m. until 7 p.m., said Paula Doucet, president of the New Brunswick Nurses Union. (Daniel St Louis/New Brunswick Nurses Union)

The need for convenient daycare hours is one of the big issues the union has heard from members through various surveys over the years, said Doucet.

She noted many daycares only open at 8 a.m. and close at 5 p.m., while many nurses start their shift around 7 a.m. and work for 12 hours.

Some nurses have had to reduce their full-time hours to part-time or casual because of daycare hour conflicts, she said.

A smiling woman with dark hair and a short bob hairstyle.    Dr. Paula Keating, president of the New Brunswick Medical Society, said childcare is a 'major concern' for many physicians. (Submited by N.B. Medical Society)

The New Brunswick Medical Society also supports the need for a daycare in Restigouche, said president Dr. Paula Keating.

"Access to childcare has repeatedly been identified as a primary factor in the ability of health professionals to keep working," she said in an emailed statement.

"Many physicians, especially those newer to practice, have young families and childcare is major concern. For that reason, the NBMS has long advocated for childcare programs, supported by government, to be made available for health-care workers," Keating said.

"This would not only allow physicians currently practising in New Brunswick to return to work sooner or more completely, but would also serve as a legitimate incentive in recruiting new physicians to the province."

CBC's Journalistic Standards and Practices|
 
 
 
16 Comments   
 
 
 
David Amos  
I wonder if Higgy has ordered Dr. Desrosiers to ignore my concerns
 
 
Don Corey
Reply to David Amos
Perhaps the good doctor will ignore Higgs and do the right thing. 
 
 
 
 
Lou Bell
Quite obvious , blank cheques should never be written for Vitalite' of any kind .
 

David Amos
Reply to Lou Bell
Imagine us agreeing on something? 
 
 
Don Corey
Reply to David Amos
Perhaps the good doctor will ignore Higgs and do the right thing.  
 
 
 
 
Lou Bell
Anyone surprised at the uncontrolled spending of Vitalite' ? They really need to be watched on any spending .
 

David Amos
Content Deactivated
Reply to Lou Bell
Trust that I am not surprised
 
 
 
Lou Bell
Many in the area appear to want the minmal seasonal work and EI , courtesy of the Fed Liberals
 
 
Deborah Reddon
Reply to Lou Bell  
EI is a program which provides a basic maintenance income if the applicant has worked and paid into the program for the required time. It has nothing to do with the Liberals, stay informed.
 
 
David Amos
Reply to Lou Bell
Methinks you will never be out of work baking butter tarts for Higgy et al N'esy Pas?
 
 
 
 
MR Cain  
Large progressive companies who value their employees provide a number of services, such as day care, gyms, rest rooms, employee assistance, social work, and even living accommodations.
 
 
Kyle Woodman  
Reply to MR Cain
Exactly, of course those are private companies and not using taxpayer's money to support these services. But we should compare them anyways even though it makes little sense. Taxpayers should all foot the bill for those who did not plan properly or think things through, this way they can keep making the same mistakes and the rest of us can keep paying for them, it just makes good common sense.

If we don't have enough money to pay for all these services, just raise our taxes so we have less, what is wrong with that, taxes good, having money in our pocket, bad.

 
Deborah Reddon
Reply to Kyle Woodman  
The shortage of nurses may be due to the fact their wages are too low. NB pays about $10/hour less for a nurse with 5 years experience than other Provinces. That has cost NB millions in hiring temporary ones. In addition, not all nurses have children who would require daycare service. Waiting until the proposal is tested would be a good idea.
 
 
MR Cain
Reply to Kyle Woodman  
As usual, another uninformed post by Ronald, aka Simon et al. Some federal government departments offer similar benefits; the expense is compensated by improved productivity and less sick time.
 
 
David Amos
Content Deactivated 
Reply to Kyle Woodman  
Welcome back to the you know what 
 
 
 
 
Don Corey
$10/day daycare for all......another failure of the Trudeau government.
 
 
David Amos
Content Deactivated
Reply to Don Corey
I wonder the Trudeau government will offer support for dog walkers I know my best buddy Beaureguard could certainly use one
 
 
 
 
Daniel Henwell
Likely a good idea to attract health care workers. Good luck!
 
 
David Amos
Reply to Daniel Henwell 
Surely you jest
 
 
 
 

Travel nurse costs help push Vitalité nearly $98M over budget

Discussions underway to have province foot the bill for private agency nurse contracts, says CEO

Vitalité Health Network says it's nearly $98 million over budget for the first 11 months of the 2023–2024 fiscal year, mainly because of expenses related to travel nurses.

Hiring the 190 full-time equivalent private agency staff accounted for $94.2 million of the cost overrun between April 1, 2023 and Feb. 29, 2024, according to vice-chair Réjean Després.

That's about 12 per cent of Vitalité's budget.

"These costs do not have to do with luxury expenses," said Després, who presented the figures as part of Vitalité's quarterly report at the board's public meeting in Campbellton Tuesday.

The travel nurses were needed to maintain patient services while supporting health professionals during the COVID-19 pandemic, he said.

Seeks to have province foot bill

Dr. France Desrosiers, president and CEO of Vitalité, said discussions are underway to have the province foot the bill.

"According to the latest news, the money must come from the Department of Health," she told reporters in French, following Tuesday's meeting.

The department did not respond to a request for comment about this.

A portrait of a woman with long, wavy hair and glasses, wearing a red top, speaking.   Dr. France Desrosiers, president and CEO of Vitalité, has said only a very limited number of agencies were able to provide the necessary French-speaking or bilingual resources in a timely manner. (Gilles Boudreau/Radio-Canada)

But a Vitalité spokesperson told CBC News Wednesday the department "has been funding these costs overrun since fiscal year 2022-23."

The contracts Vitalité had between July 2022 and March 2023 were with four agencies — Canadian Health Labs, People2.0 Workforce Services Canada, Goodwill Staffing & Recruitment and Agence SPI.

The cost of those contracts totalled more than $19 million, according to figures provided by the regional health authority.

Horizon did not respond to a request for information about its travel nursing cost overruns or any discussions with the department to absorb those costs.

Audit underway

Nursing unions and opposition parties have criticized the use of travel nurses in New Brunswick, which is costing taxpayers millions of dollars. A Globe and Mail investigation found agencies such as Toronto-based Canadian Health Labs have charged rates of more than $300 an hour — roughly six times what a local staff nurse earns.

Deputy health minister Eric Beaulieu told a legislative committee in February that the government was aware of Vitalité's first contract, which was worth up to $20 million. It was informed of the other two after the fact, late in the 2022-23 fiscal year, he said.

Last month, Auditor General Paul Martin announced he has launched an investigation of travel nurse contracts with Vitalité and Horizon health networks and the departments of health and social development.

'Still using them as if it was Day 1'

Paula Doucet, president of the New Brunswick Nurses Union, doesn't believe the province should pay for any cost overruns because of travel nurses.

While the need might have been urgent at the peak of the pandemic, "here we are two years after the fact that they're still using them as if it was Day 1," she said.

A portrait of a woman with shoulder-length brown hair, wearing a grey blouse and royal blue jacket. Paula Doucet, president of the New Brunswick Nurses Union, described travel nurses as a 'Band-Aid solution,' and said the regional health authorities need to have 'robust plans' to retain the staff they have and to recruit. (Daniel St Louis/New Brunswick Nurses Union)

Doucet blames a lack of planning and many years of not listening to the union warning about a nursing shortage on the horizon.

"And now find ourselves using taxpayer dollars over the last two years to use private for-profit companies to supply registered nurses and licensed practical nurses to keep our health-care system afloat."

Reduction in need expected by September

Vitalité plans to phase out the use of travel nurses by the winter of 2026, when the last and largest of its current contracts, with Canadian Health Labs at a cap of $93 million, expires.

It has six private agency contracts for 2023-24, with the same agencies as 2022-23, according to the spokesperson.

"The number of nurses to be provided varies by contract and is based on our needs to maintain hospital services. The cost is based on the number of travel nurse personnel provided."

Some of the strategies Vitalité has implemented should start producing results by this September, Desrosiers told CBC News. These include changes around models of care — introducing new types of professions to teams so fewer nurses are required, and recruitment and retention initiatives.

Man with glasses standing in front of a yellow and red flag. Health Minister Bruce Fitch said his department is working with Vitalité to 'figure out a way forward.' (Roger Cosman//CBC)

Health Minister Bruce Fitch said his department is working with Vitalité to try to find ways to alleviate its need for travel nurses and to increase recruitment.

"There's a number of missions that have occurred over the last little while to find people to replace those travel nurses," particularly in places where French is more prevalent, such as France, Morocco, Belgium, he said.

While Horizon expects to stop using travel nurses "in the very not too distant future," according to Fitch, it can be more challenging for Vitalité because there are fewer francophone nurses available, he said.

Vitalité also has vacancies in northern communities, which "are a little bit harder to recruit," he said.

"We're working together. We're trying to figure out a way forward. There's still some work to do, but we're moving forward on that."

The union president contends if Vitalité is at a disadvantage in recruiting because of language, it should invest in helping local anglophone nurses become bilingual.

When Doucet started her career many years ago at Chaleur Regional Hospital, French language training was offered in the hospital, she said. "It worked," but "they did away with that."

Vitalité does offer "over the phone" French language training, but it's "not the same," she said.

Minister looks forward to first-quarter results

It would be "impossible to do without [travel nurses] completely right now," Desrosiers said in a recent statement, "given the immediate needs that are still as great as they were in 2022," when Vitalité started to use them.

The staffing situation was "critical" because of the departures and early retirements during the COVID-19 pandemic — "to the point where we were facing imminent emergency department and even facility closures," she has said.

"This temporary but necessary measure allowed us to save lives, relieve our staff by reducing team exhaustion and turnover."

The province has allocated an extra $70 million for the regional health authorities in the 2024-25 budget to "help stabilize and ease pressures."

Fitch said he's "looking forward to first-quarter, second-quarter results, just to see if there's any way we can come in on budget without negatively affecting the clinical aspect of it."

Vitalité's remaining $3.6 million operating deficit for the first 11 months of 2023-24 is mainly due to expenses related to small equipment and professional services in laboratory, pharmacy and infrastructure, Després told the board meeting.

"These were unplanned but urgent spending," he said. No other details were provided.

With files from Radio-Canada and Shane Fowler

CBC's Journalistic Standards and Practices
 
 
 
19 Comments   
 
 
 
David Amos  
Content Deactivated
Discussions are underway to have Dr. France Desrosiers, president and CEO of Vitalité foot the bill for my Health Care instead of the province 
 
 
 
 
MR Cain
The way it was:

Why is government changing legislation to enable board members to be elected?

In an effort to bring more accountability and transparency to the management of health authorities, government has recently amended the Regional Health Authorities Act to enable the election of members to regional health authority boards.

Why is it important to elect board members?

The election of board members will strengthen regional representation, and help our health care system to be more integrated, efficient, and run for the benefit of all New Brunswickers.

The election of board members provides an opportunity for local communities to have input into health care management and puts the onus on communities to take an active interest in ensuring that their representatives are active, informed and qualified to undertake their duties as board members.

The way it is: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/new-brunswick/new-regional-health-authority-boards-2023-1.6894593

Gerry Wootton
Privatization that's the ticket: ask any conservative politician and they'll tell you that. Ask any conservative voter and they'll tell you that; after all, 12% budget overrun is the same as a balanced budget - it's not a problem if a conservative does it.   
 
 
 
 
Wilbur Ross 
This is the Tories' preferred 'free-market solution'. Higgs and Doug Ford hate public health-care and will pay any price to turn health-care into big business. 
 
 
Kyle Woodman
Content Deactivated
Reply to Wilbur Ross  
 
 
Wilbur Ross
Reply to Kyle Woodman  
Yes the old way is much much cheaper. Jog on. 
 
 
Graham McCormack
Reply to Kyle Woodman 
Still wouldn't come close to the cost of travel nurses Ron.  
 
 
 
 
Kyle Woodman 
Let's pretend this is actually still a story, that it just happens in NB, and that us Liberal supporters will now do a 180 and say saving money is more important than people getting proper care, another failure of the Higgs government.
 
 
Kyle Woodman
Reply to Kyle Woodman  
Good one Ronald 
 
 
MR Cain
Reply to Kyle Woodman  
$94M over budget? Charged rates of more than $300 an hour — roughly six times what a local staff nurse earns? Where does the health authority get the money? Who approves these contracts? How can we have surpluses? Definitely another failure of the Higgs government; a forensic audit needs to be done. 
 

Kyle Woodman  
Reply to MR Cain
Hey, I'm with you, we are the only province in Canada using travel nurses and spending a lot for them. Every other province has an over abundance of local nurses and turns many away. We have many here in NB but they are all hiding in Holt's basement ready to be deployed if she is elected. And even though the department is run by those in the department we should still blame Higgs, I think he is running a travel nursing company and making money without us knowing, I would not put it past him, another failure of the Higgs government.
 
 
MR Cain
Reply to Kyle Woodman  
Definitely another failure of the Higgs; no idea the rest of your nonsense 
 
 
MR Cain
Reply to Kyle Woodman  
u still wannabe what everyone has 
 
 
David Webb
Reply to Kyle Woodman  
Some won't see the sarcasm. Good job!
 
 
MR Cain
Reply to David Webb  
another wannabe what everyone has.  
 
 
David Amos
Content Deactivated 
Reply to Kyle Woodman  
Welcome back to the circus
 
 
 
 
 

Tuesday 9 April 2024

On-site massage chairs available for New Brunswick health-care workers

 

On-site massage chairs available for New Brunswick health-care workers

 

19 RecharjMe cabins, distributed between Vitalité and Horizon Health hospitals and Ambulance N.B. locations

Would this recharge you?

Duration 1:04
Health networks launch 'RecharjMe rest cabins’ to give health workers a space to ‘recharge their batteries’ in the workplace.

During a long day at work, Justin Surette decided to get a massage, with some relaxing music and heat, at Vitalité Health Network's new relaxation booth.

"When I came out, I was feeling like a new person," said Surette.

"It is kind of like waking up in the morning."

Surette, the health and safety adviser at the Vitalité Health Network, is one of the many health-care workers who can now book a 25-minute session at the RecharjMe cabins installed at health centres across the province. 

Two cabins with black doors and a punch code entry system. The cabins were placed at the Dumont hospital's cafeteria earlier this year and have been available for staff use since January. (Rhythm Rathi/CBC)

The relaxation cabins were officially launched on Tuesday at Moncton's Dr. Georges-L.-Dumont University Hospital Centre's cafeteria as a partnership between the Vitalité and Horizon health networks and Ambulance New Brunswick.

The modern-looking, closet-like cabins have just enough space for one occupant to lie down on the reclining massage chair. The reservations are made through an app, which generates a code for the user to begin their session.

The cabins are dark, soundproof and have a wall-mounted touch screen, along with a remote control to change the settings. They offer a vibrating heated massage therapy along with a meditation playlist or relaxing music.

Surette said the cabins were placed at the Dumont hospital's cafeteria earlier this year and have been available for staff use since January. 

"I would say I probably use them at least twice a week, give or take, if not more — depending," he said.

He said some days at work can get hectic and it helps to have this service available to relax and start fresh. Surette said the cabins are popular among the night-shift workers.

"I see a lot of employees using them."

A man touching a screen, while holding a remote control. The cabin offers a vibrating heated massage along with a meditation playlist or relaxing music, which can be controlled and adjusted according to the user's preference. (Rhythm Rathi/CBC)

Pilot project

Brittany Stein, Horizon Health's regional director of employee health, wellness and safety, said a total of 19 RecharjMe cabins are available at various health locations in the province.

She said any health-care employee can access them at any location at no cost, but the access is limited to one session every 24 hours. 

As it gets more popular, the challenge of finding an available spot will increase, but she said that is a positive indication of the service being used well.

"I think we all know health care is really incredibly challenging right now, especially in the province of New Brunswick ... so we want to provide a menu of offerings for health-care workers," she said.

Stein said the cabins are one of a number of initiatives, such as flexible scheduling, to make the experience better for those working in the health-care industry. 

This is a one-year pilot project that will later be assessed to determine its future, she said. 

A white lady with curly blonde hair, speaking at a podium. Brittany Stein, Horizon Health's regional director of employee health, wellness and safety, says the cabins are a one-year pilot project. (Rhythm Rathi/CBC)

The cabins have been successful in many hospital locations in Quebec and are built by a Quebec start-up company, Stein said.

"The project is an extension of the provincial health plan's strategy to increase employee satisfaction, reduce absenteeism brought on by injury or illness and reduce attrition," according to a media release.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR


Rhythm Rathi

Reporter, CBC New Brunswick

Rhythm Rathi is a reporter with CBC New Brunswick in Moncton. He was born and raised in India and attended journalism school in Ontario. Send him your story tips at rhythm.rathi@cbc.ca

 
 
 
17 Comments
 
 
 
David Amos
Welcome to the circus
 
 
 
 
Marc Bourque  
they need it,they are overworked at the moment.Thanks to the traveling nurses who is picking up the slack...
 
 
David Amos
Reply to Marc Bourque
Well put  
 
 
MR Cain
Reply to Marc Bourque  
Traveling nurses are also soaking the health system for big bucks. 
 
 
Pat Holland 
Reply to MR Cain 
You can’t just make nurses appear out of thin air travel nurses are only meant to help temporarily 
 
 
MR Cain
Reply to Pat Holland 
Temporarily is not a 3 year contract.  
 
 
Benny Swim 
Reply to Pat Holland  
And what was the cost? $160 million? Higg's private sector managerial experience was supposed to make government more efficient. Some efficiency.
 
 
 
 
Jim Lake  
I’m all for supporting and improving the wellness of our very valuable healthcare workers … but this is the ONLY piece of the provincial health plan strategy that has been revealed to New Brunswickers … after how long???

Surely the Higgs government has more than this in their “strategy” for fixing the dire healthcare crisis we are facing in this province … please, someone in government, assure the rest of us that there is more to the “provincial health plan strategy” … please …

 
Lou Bell
Reply to Jim Lake 
Actually they do . Liberals think there are hundreds of family physicians laying around , just waiting to be hired . There has been a shortage of Healthcare workers here in NB for decades , and the liberals hired virtually none their last 4 years in office . They paid for many , we just didn't get any . 
 
 
MR Cain
Reply to Jim Lake  
Doubt if this was part of Higgs plan; he doesn't have one. 
 
 
Pat Holland 
Reply to MR Cain 
I haven’t seen much of a plan come from the liberals side of the bench. 
 
 
MR Cain
Reply to Pat Holland 
Since when have they been required to provide one? We have yet to see Higgs' plan. 

 
Benny Swim 
Reply to Pat Holland  
The Liberals not having a plan justifies Higg's spending much needed funds on massage chairs for staff when patients in the emergency room are not seen by medical staff for hours, and consequently die in THEIR chair?

Also, who ever is in charge of communications in the department of health should be fired. Making the massage chair announcement on the day the inquest releases its recommendation seems designed to give a finger to NB citizens.

  


G. Timothy Walton 
This actually looks like a good idea.

I wonder which friend of Higgs owns a franchise.

 
 
 
Benny Swim 
Another story on this site is about a patient dying in the emergency room after having not been seen by medical staff for 2.5 hours. Yet the health authorities have funds to spend thousands on massage chairs for staff.

Very clear illustrations of a health care system that is completely and utterly rudderless. The Higg's Age in NB health care; an upside down system that makes no sense.

 
 
 
Jake Quinlan
Governments like to spend on one-time costs..shiny toys that are part of one year's budgets and not beyond.....nothing committed to long-term, like hmmm staffing. 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Wednesday 6 March 2024

Auditor general announces probe of travel nurse contracts in N.B.

 
 

Auditor general announces probe of travel nurse contracts in N.B.

Vitalité, Horizon and departments of Health and Social Development will be audited, says Paul Martin

Auditor General Paul Martin will conduct a review of New Brunswick's controversial use of private agency nurses, known as travel nurses, which is costing taxpayers hundreds of millions of dollars.

His office announced the independent audit of "the management of contracts pertaining to travel nurses" Wednesday in a news release.

The Vitalité and Horizon health networks, the Department of Health and the Department of Social Development will all be audited.

"This work is very important in keeping government departments and agencies accountable for the spending of New Brunswick tax dollars," Martin said in a statement.

Asked what prompted him to undertake the audit, Martin told CBC News his office is "interested in ensuring value for money as it relates to government spending."

"We have been considering an audit of the travel nurse contracts for some time." he said in an emailed statement. "The timing is right given the noted interest to the public and the availability of our resources to complete the audit."

Premier, union called for investigation

Last week, Premier Blaine Higgs called for the auditor general to investigate Vitalité and Horizon's spending on travel nurses, saying the government needs to be prudent in spending to get the best value for taxpayers.

"And this is a situation where it seems like we could have got better value," he said.

The New Brunswick Nurses Union and the Canadian Federation of Nurses Unions have sent three joint requests for an audit since last April. The most recent request was submitted last week, after a Globe and Mail investigation found agencies such as Toronto-based Canadian Health Labs have charged rates of more than $300 an hour — roughly six times what a local staff nurse earns.

Vitalité alone spent about $158 million to hire out-of-province nurses in 2022-23, contracts obtained by the national newspaper revealed.

 A young Black nurse in scrubs smiles for the camera.Vitalité's third contract with Canadian Health Labs, which continues until February 2026, with a cap of $93 million, effectively charges the regional health authority $306.70 an hour per travel nurse, according to the Globe and Mail. (Pixel-Shot/Shutterstock)

Deputy health minister Eric Beaulieu told a legislative committee the government was aware of Vitalité's first contract, which was worth up to $20 million. It was informed of the other two after the fact, late in the 2022-23 fiscal year, he said.

Vitalité CEO Dr. France Desrosiers has defended the spending, saying the staffing situation was "critical" because of the departures and early retirements during the COVID-19 pandemic — "to the point where we were facing imminent emergency department and even facility closures."

The regional health authority had no choice but to resort to travel nurses, she said.

The audit will consider issues related to procurement, oversight, internal controls and overall value for money, according to the news release.

About transparency, accountability

Paula Doucet, president of the New Brunswick Nurses Union, who learned of the audit through the news release, said she's "happy to hear [Martin] is acting upon our request."

It's about transparency and accountability for New Brunswickers, she said.

"I think with what the Globe and Mail has uncovered in relation to the actual costs and the expenditures of taxpayer dollars, particularly what Vitalité has signed on with Canadian Health Labs, has really brought to the surface just how much is unknown about these private, for-profit nurse agencies and where our tax dollars are going," she said.

"So I think the important thing for the auditor general to do is to find out, you know, exactly where the money's going, how much of it is going there."

A portrait of a woman with shoulder-length brown hair, wearing a grey blouse and royal blue jacket. The New Brunswick Nurses Union has sent three requests for an audit in recent months, said president Paula Doucet. (Daniel St Louis/New Brunswick Nurses Union)

Doucet hopes the audit will open a broader discussion about where taxpayer dollars are being spent and invested in health care.

"We for a long time have said they need to be here in New Brunswick — invested in New Brunswick workers, invested in New Brunswick infrastructure. And right now there's millions and millions of dollars that are going outside of this province.

"That is not for an economic spinoff for us. And when we have a premier that often talks about return for investment — he's getting no return on this investment, currently."

No timeline

Martin told CBC on Wednesday afternoon that his audit work has already begun. He did not say when.

The audit may involve interviews, review of documents, and various forms of data collection and analysis, according to the release.

"I look forward to reporting on our findings and recommendations upon completion of our audit," Martin said.

He did not respond to questions about how long the audit is expected to take.

Must not exceed mandate, powers, says Vitalité

Vitalité will offer its collaboration on the audit, an unidentified spokesperson said in an emailed statement.

"However, this collaboration must take place within a framework that does not exceed the mandate and powers of the auditor.

"It must ensure compliance with fundamental legal principles, relevant legislative provisions, legal privileges of the network essential to the exercise of its functions, and not harm the organization's ability to provide essential health services to the population."

Horizon and the Department of Health and social development did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

CBC's Journalistic Standards and Practices
 
 

102 Comments

 

David Amos
Perhaps he can find my money while he is checking their work
 
 
Don Corey
Reply to David Amos
It would be the appropriate, morally correct and legal action (currently lacking) that needs to be taken in order to fully reimburse you and bring closure to what we are all entitled to as a Canadian citizens. 
 
 
David Amos

Reply to Don Corey
At least I won't have to pay for my first visit with my new doctor from Kars  
 
 
David Amos 
Reply to Don Corey
Thanks for your support  
 
 
Don Corey
Reply to David Amos
Maybe someone, someday, will actually pay attention and do the right thing.
 
 
 
 
Wilbur Ross  
Capitalism and healthcare don't mix. Higgs couldn't give a damn about the cost, he's proving a point. He no different than another GOP Republican when it comes to healthcare and education. Smaller government with a bigger bill for taxpayers, that's the new 'conservative' movement. But we all know Tory math never really adds up. 
 
 
David Amos 
Reply to Wilbur Ross
Never forget New Brunswickers elected Higgy and are about to do so again obviously because the red coat math is no better   
 
 
Wilbur Ross 
Reply to David Amos 
I'm no fan of either. But one lot never spend anything at all. That's our money he's hoarding and then wasting on frivolous things like travel nurses and corporate welfare projects. Higgs, Ford, Moe and Smith are burning through healthcare money because they can't admit they are getting screwed by these capitalists gouging away at people in their time of need. If this was wartime they'd be on trial for profiteering. NS has a much more sensible approach, but Higgs has to model the Republicans and their asinine healthcare solutions; and the taxpayers are getting screwed every which way as a result. 
 
 
Wilbur Ross 
Reply to David Amos 
Also are tax supposed to go up and up under a PC government? I'm confused what they Tory voters see in him. Its all about owning the Libs with this lot. No substance, just a bigger bill. 
 
 


Bill Hanson 
seems there are three choices

pay the travel nurses

pay your regular nurses overtime

or reallocate the work so that nurses are only working on those tasks that are defined under the health professions act

 
Don Corey
Reply to Bill Hanson  
Your third choice is the obvious answer, but I'm sure the nurse's union will be the first to disagree. Therein lies one significant obstacle that nobody wants to talk about. 
 
 
MR Cain
Reply to Bill Hanson  
Overtime is not an answer; that is the reason for burn out. More nurses as the demand has increased with the growth in population. Adopt BCs nurse to patient ratios. 
 
 
David Amos 
Reply to Don Corey
Ditto





Murray Brown 
A day late and taxpayers hundreds of millions of dollars short. The time for investigating has long since passed. The question is... Who in the government benefited from these contracts, and how much did they make? And here's another question... Why is the RCMP not investigating government corruption? Canada apparently has no recourse or concrete solutions to the rampant government corruption that occurs yearly, and there are never any charges or investigations being carried out.  
 
 
Don Corey
Reply to Murray Brown 
The RCMP is too busy investigating all the corruption in Ottawa. 
 
 
David Amos 
Reply to Don Corey
Surely you jest The RCMP has not done a tap in over 50 years 
 
 
Don Corey
Reply to David Amos 
Yeah, but I can always hope.
 
 
 
 
Frederick Graham 
Typical short-term strategy employed by this provincial government awash in surplus federal funds. Instead of buying a permanent fix they rented a temporary result for election result purposes only. 
 
 
Ralph Skavinsky
Reply to Frederick Graham  
I believe they had no choice given the lack of nurses available and of course the Hyprocratic Oath is thrown out the window when they see how much they go for the greed factor. 
 
 
SarahRose Werner 
Nurses don't take the Hippocratic Oath, only doctors do. And when you're working a job where forced overtime and abuse by patients and their families are everyday occurrences, it's not "greed" to prefer to work for the wages suitable to these horrible conditions. Reply to Frederick Graham  
 
 
Lou Bell
Reply to Frederick Graham
If one is paying attention at all they'd realize there's a Nursing shortage all across Canada . And it takes up to 4 years to train Nurses . " buying a permanent fix " ?? You'd think there were thousands of Nurses just sitting around waiting or a job . Not happening . And not only has this government paid doen our debt by billions , saving the province hundreds of millions in interst payments and avoiding a drop in it's credit rating , but it has spent more money in the past year than any other NB government in the provinces history . Unfortunately the left has no idea of fiscal responsibility at all .  
 
 
Lou Bell
Reply to SarahRose Werner
No one had " forced overtime " . These are unionized employees and would never allow " forced overtime ". And if they were , then the union has failed their members miserably .  
 
 
David Webb
Reply to Frederick Graham
Where are there a surplus of nurses, doctors, plumbers, electricians, teachers, judges, police officers, canadian forces members, to name a few? You can't hire what doesn't exist. Governments don't think long term because voters don't either. 
 
 
Don Corey
Reply to Frederick Graham
The pandemic is over. There are no more "surplus federal funds". 
 
 
David Amos 
Reply to Don Corey
There never was any "surplus federal funds".
 
 
Don Corey
Reply to David Amos 
I'm referring to all the borrowed pandemic money that the feds threw recklessly at everything for more than 2 years, including transfers to the provinces.



 
  
Allan Marven 
Nothing smells funny about a company founded in 2020 at the behest of GOC
 
 
David Amos

Reply to Allan Marven
It stinks
 
 
David Amos
Reply to Allan Marven
Too Too Funny
 
  
 
Kyle Woodman
What a mess. It starts at the top. Another failure by the Higgs government.  
 
 
Allan Marven 
Reply to Kyle Woodman 
A long and convoluted trail when you start researching. Main lesson learned for business and gov't, never pass up a good pandemic. 
 
 
Lou Bell
Reply to Kyle Woodman 
Naw , it started when the Liberals paid 2 NB Universities millions for eXTRA Nursing seats , and due to a complete lack of due dilligence we got not even one . Not one !! 
 
 
David Amos
Reply to Allan Marven
"Speaking of mimicked phrases, how many times have you seen Winston Churchill quoted in the past year? Churchill is quoted as saying, "Never let a good crisis go to waste," in the middle of World War II (although the origin of the phrase is still subject to debate). The phrase has been trotted out repeatedly in the past year, as it has been seemingly every time the world has been turned upside down since the middle of the 20th century."  
 

Don Corey
Reply to David Amos
Yep, very true for sure.
 
 
 
 

Wednesday 6 December 2023

N.B. nurses union seeks end of use of travel nurses, cites 'astounding' $57M cost

 

N.B. nurses union seeks end of use of travel nurses, cites 'astounding' $57M cost

Horizon will stop using temporary agency nurses by end of March, Vitalité plans phase out by winter 2026

The New Brunswick Nurses Union is calling on the provincial government to commit to ending the use of travel nurses by the end of 2025, describing the nearly $57 million spent on the private agency nurses in five months as "astounding."

Instead, the government should invest in the retention of New Brunswick nurses and the recruitment of nurses who will work and live in the province, said president Paula Doucet.

"Invest in New Brunswick, invest in New Brunswickers, and invest in New Brunswick nurses. And then maybe we would have a better health-care system for all," she said.

Horizon Health Network will stop using the temporary nurses from private agencies before the union's deadline, according to Greg Doiron, vice-president of clinical services.

"The majority of these contracts will expire at the end of [this month], while critical areas such as [emergency departments, intensive care units] and surgical units will continue through to the end of March 2024 to ensure the continued stability of these vital services," he said in an emailed statement.

Meanwhile Vitalité Health Network is "well positioned to phase out the use of agencies by winter 2026," said spokesperson Anthony Doiron.

"A gradual reduction in agency services is planned, but it would be irresponsible as a health-care organization to phase them out completely at this time, given the immediate needs to be met," he said in an emailed statement.

Paula Docuet poses for a photo Doucet said ending the use of travel nurses should be a priority to ensure New Brunswick has 'safe, quality health care delivered by nurses who are well oriented [and] well supported.' (CBC)

Doucet described Horizon's goal as "lofty" and worries about the feasibility of Vitalité's target, given its heavy reliance on travel nurses in some regions. She cited as an example the Campbellton Regional Hospital, where agency nurses logged more than 68,000 hours between April and August.

Department of Health spokesperson Sean Hatchard noted travel nurses are contracted by the regional health authorities (RHAs), not the province, and said they're only used when no other nurses are available.

But he said the department will review Nova Scotia's decision this week to limit its use of travel nurses and discuss the issue with the RHAs.

The department is working with the health authorities, the Nurses Association of New Brunswick and other recruitment partners to fill nursing positions as quickly as possible, and has seen some progress, with a net increase of 113 registered nurses in the past seven months, said Hatchard.

He did not clarify whether those are full-time, part-time or temporary positions. Nor did he say how many positions remain vacant.

The government has also taken steps to train more nurses in the province, with the number of students jumping to nearly 1,300 last year, from 888 in 2018, Hatchard said.

Horizon spending jumps fourfold

Between April 1 and Aug. 31, 2023, Horizon spent nearly $23 million on contracts with private companies that supply temporary travel nurses, according to figures obtained by CBC and separately by the union through a Right to Information request.

That's up from about $5 million in 2022-23, the figures show.

Vitalité spent about $34 million between April and August, plus just over $19 million during the previous eight months.

Paid three times or more the N.B. hourly wage

Union leaders say they're appalled by the ballooning expenditures.

It works out to an average cost of $142 per hour, according to Doucet. When expenses such as travel, accommodations and registration fees are included, it jumps to around $300 per hour, she said, but could not immediately detail the formula used.

By comparison, an average hourly wage for a "mid-career" New Brunswick nurse, working six years at "top salary," is $45.67 per hour — one of the lowest paid in the country, after Quebec, she said.

"For a government that is focused on 'value for money,' paying travel nurses three times what a salaried New Brunswick nurse earns makes no sense," said Doucet.

It also makes New Brunswick nurses feel disrespected and devalued, she said.

"The use of travel nurse agencies has to stop."

The provincial government is spending millions on travel nurses to cover a shortage of nurses here at home. Jeanne Armstrong spoke to Paula Doucet, the president of the New Brunswick Nurses Union.

Doucet noted Finance Minister Ernie Steeves recently announced the $199.6-million budget surplus he was projecting just a couple of months ago has mostly evaporated, largely because health spending is now projected to reach $3.75 billion by the end of March, $162 million over its original allotment.

"Why is it over budget? Here's your data and your proof that they're spending hand-over-fist money, taking out of this province," she said, referring to many of the private, for-profit travel nurse companies being in Ontario or out West.

The union submitted the data request, she said, after hearing from members at its annual general meeting in October that increasing numbers of travel nurses were coming into hospitals across the province.

'Far from ideal,' says Horizon official

Horizon began using travel nurses in October 2022 "as an essential means to ensure continued delivery of safe care," said Greg Doiron, vice-president of clinical services.

He noted health-care organizations across Canada are using them to maintain critical nursing services.

"Although far from ideal, the use of private agency nurses has saved lives and their efforts have helped our health-care system to get through an unprecedented time," he said.

The costs, which include salary, registration and expenses, have escalated significantly, Doiron acknowledged.

"This is mostly due to critical nursing shortages in areas like our emergency departments, ICUs and surgical units," he said, without defining "critical," or providing the number of vacant positions.

A portrait of a man sitting in an office. Greg Doiron, vice-president of clinical services for Horizon, said the use of travel nurses has been 'a necessary measure.' (Government of New Brunswick/Zoom)

Doiron did say Horizon has undertaken "aggressive nursing recruitment strategies which are generating very positive and very real results," with a net gain of 207 registered nurses since April 1, plus 103 internationally educated nurses hired, he said.

According to figures from the Department of Health, Horizon has hired 359 registered nurses since April 1, and Vitalité, 141, for a provincial total of 500.

Of those, 319 are permanent and 181 are temporary/casual, the department spokesperson said.

During that same period, Horizon and Vitalité lost 387 registered nurses, including 192 in permanent positions and 195 in temporary/casual roles, he said.

Vitalité has strategies to 'wean' off

Vitalité's decision to "resort to agency personnel to deal with hospital staffing shortages was taken after a thorough review of health and patient safety risk requirements," said spokesperson Anthony Doiron.

"The use of agency workers is a temporary but necessary measure that has allowed us to save lives, provide relief to our workforce, and reduce the exhaustion of our teams and turnover," he said.

"Numerous strategies are in place to wean ourselves off this need." Doiron did not provide any details, but did say Vitalité's efforts to recruit and retain health-care workers is "already bearing fruit."

N.S. to limit use of travel nurses

The Nova Scotia government is taking steps to end its reliance on private nursing agencies by limiting the amount of time someone employed as a travel nurse can work in the province.

Health Minister Michelle Thompson told CBC Monday that her government decided the money could be better spent on people who are a part of the public system and that the use of agency nurses works against efforts to fill the more than 1,000 vacancies in Nova Scotia.

Under the terms of the policy change, anyone who works in the province as an agency nurse can only work for 180 days before having to wait a year before working there again. Graduates of Nova Scotia nursing schools will not be allowed to work in the province as a travel nurse during their first year after graduation.

Earlier this year the Quebec government passed a bill that will limit the use of health-care staffing agencies, with a goal of banning hospitals from using them by the end of 2025.

New Brunswickers deserve good quality health care, they deserve publicly funded health care, and they deserve for their government to be prudent with taxpayers' money.
— Paula Doucet, New Brunswick Nurses Union president

Doucet said New Brunswick is currently "in the eye of the storm" and even relies on the use of travel nurses to keep some hospitals open after failing to heed years of warnings about the need to educate, hire and retain more.

But the union has set a deadline of the end of 2025 to end their use.

The government should focus on supporting registered nurses who want to become nurse practitioners so they don't have to work full-time and study at the same time, and making Bachelor of Nursing and licensed practical nurse courses more accessible and affordable, said Doucet.

Travel nurses were never intended to help keep emergency departments open in urban centres, she said. They were intended to ensure remote communities had access to health care.

"New Brunswickers deserve good quality health care, they deserve publicly funded health care, and they deserve for their government to be prudent with taxpayers' money as they provide the services the people of the province need."

With files from Information Morning Fredericton

 
 
 
184 Comments
 
 
David Amos
"Department of Health spokesperson Sean Hatchard noted travel nurses are contracted by the regional health authorities (RHAs), not the province, and said they're only used when no other nurses are available."

Enough said 

  

Donald Smith 
Found out at supper time, some local nursing nurses are leaving to become travel nurses and make more Money lol in NB  
 
 
 
Lou Bell  
This is the same union that less than 2 years ago signed a contract and ever since have demanded the province pay them a 10,000 dollar per " retention bonus " . They complaines about being overworked , and with this help in place they're complaining about the help they're getting . Hundreds of new nurses are and will will be coming online in the next couple of years . NB taxpayers have only so much money to pay in taxes and most all of the middle class now pays over 50 % of it's earniings in taxes . Health / Education workers , the homeless , feeding the hungry , time to give the middle class a break !!! 
 
 
Wilbur Ross
Reply to Lou Bell
You are not middle class.  
 
 
Kyle Woodman
Reply to Lou Bell 
Nova Scotia has the retention bonus. That's why my neighbor works in Amherst, an hour away. Still getting less that Higgs pays the travel nurse who replaced her. 
 
 
Donald Smith
Reply to Lou Bell  
Lou, why did your man get involved with COR, then get involved with Liberals',? Enlighten us please. Are you president f his fan club?
 
 
MR Cain
Reply to Donald Smith
Before joining the Confederation of Regions party, Higgs was a Liberal party member but left the Liberals because he opposed Canadian bilingualism and the New Brunswick Official Languages Act. Opportunity arose when he found he could bully the PC party; took 3 votes because they didn't want him either.