Lawyers and journalists sued the CIA and former CIA Director Mike Pompeo Monday for spying on them while they met Julian Assange when he was living in the Ecuadorian Embassy in London, where he had political asylum. The lawsuit is being filed as Britain prepares to extradite the WikiLeaks founder to the United States, where he faces up to 175 years in prison for violating the Espionage Act by publishing classified documents exposing U.S. war crimes in Iraq and Afghanistan. We speak with the lead attorney in the case, Richard Roth, who details how a private security company stationed at the London Embassy unknowingly sent images from Assange's visitors' cellphones and laptops as well as streamed video from inside meetings to American intelligence. He says the offenses breach a range of client privileges and could sway a U.S. judge to dismiss the case if Assange is successfully extradited.
Democracy Now! is an independent global news hour that airs on over 1,500 TV and radio stations Monday through Friday. Watch our livestream at https://democracynow.org Mondays to Fridays 8-9 a.m. ET.
Support independent media: https://democracynow.org/donate
Subject: Re: RE: Iceland and Bankers etc I must ask the obvious
question. Why have you people ignored me for three years?
To: David Amos david.raymond.amos@gmail.com
Dear David Amos
Unfortunately there has been a considerable delay in responding to
incoming letters due to heavy workload and many inquiries to our office.
We appreciate the issue raised in your letter. We have set up a web site
www.iceland.org where we have gathered various practical information
regarding the economic crisis in Iceland.
Subject: Re: Bon Soir Birgitta according to my records this is the
first email I ever sent you
To: David Amos david.raymond.amos@gmail.com
dear Dave
i have got your email and will read through the links as soon as i
find some time
keep up the good fight in the meantime
thank you for bearing with me
i am literary drowning in requests to look into all sorts of matters
and at the same time working 150% work at the parliament and
the creation of a political movement and being a responsible parent:)
plus all the matters in relation to immi
I know that the Yankee law enforcement people are either as dumb as posts or pure evil. There appears to be few exceptions. The ethical Ms. Olson is my favourite klady today. Does anyone speaking or acting in the best interests of the decent folks in Iceland understand my sincerity and her Integrity YET?
Veritas Vincit
David Raymond Amos
The Honourable Wyman W. Webb
The Honourable Justice Wyman W. Webb was appointed as a Judge of
the Tax Court of Canada on November 23, 2006 and as a Judge of Federal
Court of Appeal on October 5, 2012. He received both a Master of
Business Administration degree and a Bachelor of Laws degree in 1982
from Dalhousie University and a Bachelor of Science degree in 1978 from
Mount Allison University. He was admitted to the Bar of Nova Scotia in
1982. He practised law with Patterson Law and its predecessor firms
(Patterson Palmer, Patterson Kitz and Patterson Smith Matthews &
Grant). He also worked for two years on secondment (under the
Interchange Canada program) with Revenue Canada Taxation Rulings
Directorate, in the Natural Resources and Corporate Reorganizations
sections. His practice expertise was in tax law (including income tax
and HST/GST), commercial law and tax litigation. He is a former Governor
of the Canadian Tax Foundation and was a part-time professor of tax law
at Dalhousie Law School. He has made presentations at the Canadian Tax
Foundation Annual Conference, the Atlantic Provinces Tax Conferences,
and CBA tax conferences. Judge of the Federal Court of Appeal. Address:
Federal Court of Appeal, Ottawa, Ontario, K1A 0H9.
The U.S. Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) and its former director Mike Pompeo
were slapped with a lawsuit Monday from a group of journalists and
lawyers over allegations that the government agency spied on them and
hundreds of others while meeting with Wikileaks founder Julian Assange at the Ecuadorean Embassy in London.
The lawsuit
alleges that the CIA under Pompeo violated the Fourth Amendment rights
of journalists Charles Glass and John Goetz and attorneys Margaret
Kunstler and Deborah Hrbek, who have represented Assange.
“The
United States Constitution shields American citizens from U.S.
government overreach even when the activities take place in a foreign
embassy in a foreign country,” Richard Roth, the leading lawyer
representing the group, told Daily Wire in a statement.
The
filings allege authorities made each visitor surrender any electronic
device such as smartphones or laptops during their interactions with
Assange, who is currently fighting extradition to the U.S., where he
faces 175 years in prison for publishing classified information. The
Wikileaks founder had lived in the Ecuadorian Embassy in London under
political asylum since 2012 until authorities arrested him seven years
later.
However, Roth said the journalists and lawyers who met with
Assange had their conversations recorded and data from their electronic
devices copied by Undercover Global SL, a private security contractor,
and passed along to the CIA under the direction of Pompeo.
Plaintiffs in the lawsuit have also filed the case again Undercover Global and its Chief Executive David Morales Guillen.
“It
is somewhat startling that in light of the Fourth Amendment protection
we have in the Constitution, the federal government would actually go
ahead and take this confidential information,” Roth told reporters
during a press conference.
Monday’s
lawsuit was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District
of New York and the plaintiff’s are only asking for
injunctive relief and not money damages.
U.S. law prohibits the CIA from collecting intelligence on citizens. However, Reuters reports that lawmakers have alleged that the alphabet agency keeps clandestine of Americans’ communications data.
“Think
of what we store in our phones and our computers — birthdays, bank
information, dates of birth — all of this was recorded, and then given
over to the Central Intelligence Agency,” Robert Boyle, a New York Civil
Rights and constitutional law attorney, told reporters during the press
conference. “So the violations of the privacy rights here were
particularly egregious.”
Boyle argues that the alleged violations have also “tainted, if not destroyed,” a fair trial for Assange.
Margaret
Kunstler, a criminal and civil rights attorney and a plaintiff in the
case, called the act by the government agency “terrible,” adding she
can’t think of anything worse than the opposition listening in on their
plans and conversations.
“Gross misconduct is exactly what has
happened here,” Kunstler said. “And I don’t understand how the CIA — I
guess through the insanity of Pompeo — could think that they could do
this is so outrageous that it’s beyond my comprehension.”
Kunstler visited Assange at the Embassy between January 2017 and March 2018.
Deborah
Harbeck, an attorney who has visited Mr. Assange, echoed her fellow
plaintiff, saying the violation of her constitutional rights is an
outrage.
“I have the right to assume that the U.S. government is
not listening to my private and privileged conversations with my
clients,” Harbeck told reporters, adding that information about other
clients in cases she may have on her phone or laptop is secure from
illegal government intrusion.
Harbeck reportedly visited Assange during the relevant period.
John
Goetz, the editor of investigations at German public broadcaster NDR,
told reporters he worked with Assange between 2011 and 2017. He said he
met with the political asylee for editorial discussion about stories at
the Embassy.
“I find that quite disturbing that what was
essentially a private editorial situation was conceivably or possibly
are likely being listened to,” Goetz said. “I thought that we were
protected, especially as American citizens, by the Fourth Amendment.”
Nathan
Fuller, director of Assange’s defense committee, argued that the
journalists tried to publish crucial content for the public interest and
its right to know what lengths the government would reach to silence
reporters who reveal information “embarrassing to the regime.”
“This
should worry anybody who values investigative journalists and
journalism and should be aware of the unprecedented threat that this
prosecution poses to it,” Fuller told reporters.
According to Reuters, Pompeo and Undercover Global S.L. could not immediately be reached for comment.
The
filings allege that Pompeo has said in the past he would target
whistleblowers who exposed U.S. government secrets and argued that “the
one thing [current] whistleblowers don’t need is a publisher” due to the
availability of the Internet. The former CIA director allegedly called
WikiLeaks “a non-state hostile intelligence service” while referring to
Assange as a “narcissist,” “fraud,” and a “coward.”
Assange
founded Wikileaks in 2006 and has since published over 10 million
documents exposing war crimes, human rights violations, corruption, and
other government misconduct worldwide. He faces 18 counts under the
Espionage Act, including a spying charge related to WikiLeaks’ release
of confidential U.S. military records and diplomatic cables.
John Goetz is an investigative journalist at ARD-Hauptstadtstudio in
Berlin. Previously, he wrote for Der Spiegel until 2011. Together with
Danish documentary filmmaker Poul-Erik Heilbuth, he wrote and directed
the 2015 documentary Terminal F/Chasing Edward Snowden. The documentary
was awarded a special commendation in the category of Best European TV
Current Affairs Programme at the 2015 Prix Europa in Berlin.
The Centre for Investigative Journalism
Goldsmiths, University of London
Department of Media, Communications and Cultural Studies
8 Lewisham Way, London SE14 6NW
United Kingdom
That is, we are a full-service firm with an emphasis on securities, entertainment, and business litigation and arbitration.
We are resolution oriented. Through personalized attention, dedicated
representation, aggressive strategies and out-of-the-box
problem-solving techniques, we pride ourselves on successfully and
expeditiously resolving client disputes.
We consistently adopt a pragmatic approach to the speedy resolution
of complicated litigations and sophisticated transactions, on behalf of
plaintiffs and defendants alike.
Founder and partner Richard A. Roth is highly regarded by his colleagues, adversaries, judges, arbitrators and peers for his strong litigation experience,
aggressive nature and innovative “out of the box” thinking. Earning a
long string of successes on both a national and international level, Mr.
Roth has represented and continues to represent a myriad of clients,
from FORTUNE 100 publicly held corporations to small privately held
businesses, C.E.O.’s and industry magnates. He also represents
celebrities, nationally recognized artists, singers, actors, songwriters
and Hall of Fame and all-star athletes, directors, producers and
professional sports organizations.
He is featured in all media and is regularly on television
commenting on civil and criminal trial and legal issues of national
significance, particularly in the entertainment/sports and securities
areas. He has also been asked to comment on various celebrities who
experience legal troubles and was featured on a recent series Celebrity Damage Control, which
was comprised of 27 episodes of celebrities who have come back from
legal difficulties including Mike Tyson, Wesley Snipes, Mickey Rourke,
Ray Lewis, Vanessa Williams and many others. His television appearances
include CNBC, FOX News, Entertainment Tonight, Access Hollywood, CBS,
MSNBC, TruTV, CNN, Bloomberg Television, Huff Live, I-24, The Blaze and
several local televisions stations. In the print media, Mr. Roth is
regularly quoted in the Wall Street Journal, The New York Times, the New
York Post, the New York Daily News and other local, national and
international newspapers and magazines. At least five of his cases were
featured on the front page of those newspapers.
Throughout his career, Mr. Roth has been honored with numerous awards
for his aggressive, powerful and successful litigation results and
trial skills. Commencing in 2011 to date, he has been repeatedly
selected as a “SuperLawyer” and was awarded the coveted “Most Versatile
Attorney” award in the nation from Lawline. He has also won the “Top
Attorneys in the New York Metropolitan Area” award annually. He and the
firm also have the distinguished honor of being ranked first in the
nation in bestattorneysonline.com for ‘Entertainment Litigation” and “Securities Litigation.
He was also recently honored to have been named to the Furthered40, a
recognition of the top 40 attorneys in the nation who dedicate their
time, energy, and knowledge to further education among their peers and
the public at large. Each of the nominees had a passion for teaching and
have been described as “proven innovators in their methods of
delivering educational content.” His firm has also been recognized as a
“Go To” Top 500 Law Firms in the nation.
Mr. Roth has litigated several hundred cases in his career, which
includes both jury and non-jury trials in state and federal court and
appeals from Anchorage to Miami. He is admitted to practice before the
Courts of the State of New York, the United States District Courts for
the Northern, Southern, Eastern, and Western Districts of New York, the
Second Circuit Court of Appeals, the Third Circuit Court of Appeals, the
Eleventh Circuit of Appeals and the United States Supreme Court. He has
also been admitted pro hac vice in various other state and federal courts and has arbitrated securities disputes across the country.
He also practices daily before numerous arbitration and mediation
tribunals, including the American Arbitration Association (“AAA”), JAMS,
the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (“FINRA”) and has tried
hundreds of hearings before the National Association of Securities
Dealers, Inc. and the New York Stock Exchange, Inc. throughout the
country. He serves as an arbitrator before FINRA. Mr. Roth travels
across the country representing various entities and individuals,
including public companies, in defending large commercial and securities litigations. His clients
have ranged from large broker-dealers, clearing and custodial firms,
and investment and financial institutions, to start-up ventures,
investment bankers, venture capital institutions, closely held
corporations and individuals.
Mr. Roth is a member of the Litigation and Entertainment Committees
of the American Bar Association, a member of the Litigation and
Legislation Committees of the New York State Bar Association and the New
York County and a member of the Small Firm Committee of the New York
City Bar Associations. Mr. Roth has also published articles on various
aspects of litigation and has been quoted in magazines, periodicals,
trade journals, and daily newspapers. Certain of his results have
received regional prominence and have been cited and discussed in legal
journals. He has also served as a judge at various law school moot court
competitions and high school debate tournaments at Fordham, Princeton,
Yale, Harvard, and Columbia Universities.
Mr. Roth received his B.A. degree, cum laude, from Union
College in Schenectady, N.Y. and his J.D. degree from Hofstra University
School of Law, where he graduated near the top of his class. While at
Hofstra Law, Mr. Roth was selected to the prestigious Hofstra law Review
where he served as Associate Editor of the Hofstra Law Review and
published “The Essence of the Agent Orange Litigation: The Government
Contract Defense.”
Mr. Roth’s prior experience includes working for the Office of the
United States Attorney General, interning for a Judge of the Second
Circuit Court of Appeals and working for law firms both large and small.
After graduating law school, Mr. Roth began his career at an
internationally recognized law firm which, at the time, had over 1,000
attorneys. After that large firm experience, he went to a small,
boutique litigation firm that specialized in entertainment litigation and sophisticated commercial/securities litigation.
Thereafter, Mr. Roth joined Gordon Hurwitz Butowsky Weitzen Shalov
& Wein P.C., a one hundred person law firm whose litigation
department concentrated on comprehensive securities, entertainment,
and commercial litigation. Upon leaving that firm in 1993, he formed
Littman Krooks & Roth P.C., a small full service law firm. As head
of the litigation department, Mr. Roth continued his innovative style
and proceeded to develop a strong following among the corporate,
financial and entertainment communities. He formed The Roth Law Firm in
March 2003.
295 Madison Ave 22nd Floor New York, New York 10017
Deborah
Hrbek is the firm's founder, focusing her practice on entertainment
law, small business law and regulatory compliance for fine art dealers
and the cannabis industry. Hrbek represents creative professionals,
entrepreneurs and artists, including independent record labels, TV and
film production companies, art galleries, collectors, book publishers
and digital publications, podcast producers, directors, talent, writers,
managers, talent agents, literary agents, spokespersons and
influencers, musicians, independent filmmakers, visual artists,
animators, graphic artists, photographers and Instagrammers, as well as
investors in the arts. Hrbek's Featured Client artist roster includes an Oscar winning film production team, a novelist short-listed for the Booker Prize, and Hyperallergic.com, the digital publication that has become required reading for those interested in the fine art world.
Hrbek
is spearheading the firm's provision of anti-money laundering (AML)
compliance services for galleries, collectors and dealers in fine art.
Working closely with Margaret Ratner Kunstler and TPC Art Finance,
Hrbek is developing a unique customized service offering to assist
sellers of fine art comply with applicable AML/KYC regulations in
London, New York and beyond. Her small business clients include fashion
designers, artisans and makers, branding and influencer agencies, art
gallery owners, specialty food distributors, venue owners, event
planners, marketing companies, beauty product distributors, app
developers, multi-media companies, social networking sites and other
Internet-based business ventures. With this broad corporate and
entertainment industry background, Hrbek has been able to provide
effective representation to parties involved in the multi-platform,
transmedia deals that fuel the new media industry.
An established
voice in drug policy reform advocacy in New York City since the early
'90s, Hrbek has represented and advised investors in cannabis grows, CBD
and hemp product distributors and medical cannabis patients. Hrbek is a
co-founder of New York Cannabar and an active member of the NYC Cannabis Industry Association.
Born
in Princeton, N.J., Hrbek was raised in Palo Alto, California and
London, England. She received her law degree at King's College,
Cambridge University, and went on to qualify as a barrister in England.
Hrbek argued cases and conducted trials in London's Magistrates' Courts,
the High Courts and the Old Bailey, and completed pupillage at 1 Dr.
Johnson's Buildings (now Doughty Street Chambers) and Tooks Court
under her maiden name of Deborah Weich. After an initial stint in New
York City starting in 1990, Hrbek moved to the British Virgin Islands
and practiced law at a BVI-based international corporate law firm for
two years. It was the height of the dot-com boom, and most of the firm's
clients were in the technology business. Hrbek prepared investment
agreements and other financing documents for international technology
companies raising capital through IPOs and private placements, and
handled international corporate litigation. She chaired the BVI
Association of Registered Agents' e-Commerce Working Group (1999-2000)
and drafted that group's Report and Recommendations to the BVI
Government.
After transferring back to Manhattan to work at Beck
& Arad LLP, the New York tech law firm affiliated with her BVI
employer, Hrbek started her own law firm - HRBEKKunstler - in Manhattan
in January 2002. She is a proud member and past co-president, of the New York City Chapter of the National Lawyers Guild.
Hrbek currently serves on the board of directors of the Institute for
Media Analysis (IMA), a New York based non-profit organization whose
mission is to conduct and support research and dissemination of
information on government activities and the media.
Hrbek pays
close attention to the needs of her clients, helps them to determine
which legal projects should be prioritized and which can be
back-burnered, and provides them with the legal protection they need
working within their budget. From as early as the first consultation
meeting, Hrbek works with her clients to develop an effective strategy
designed to move them closer to accomplishing their business and
professional goals. Hrbek has a strong, engaging personality and a
practical approach to problem solving and business planning. Her broad
experience in a variety of cultures gives her a unique sensitivity and
perspective in every aspect of her practice. She lives in Astoria,
Queens with her boyfriend Brad and her cockapoo and frequent office
mascot, Henry.
295 Madison Ave 22nd Floor New York, New York 10017
Civil
rights attorney Margaret Ratner Kunstler has spent her career providing
movement support and protecting the rights of activists. She is a
powerful speaker on human rights issues, a consultant to Wikileaks
journalists and other activists, and an author of numerous legal books
and essays. Together with Tariq Ali, Kunstler edited the anthology In Defense of Julian Assange (OR Books, 2019). Kunstler's Hell No: Your Right To Dissent In Twenty-First Century America co-authored with the late Michael Ratner of the Center for Constitutional Rights, is the leading handbook for activists today.
In
addition to her legal work and writing, Kunstler is Director of the
Institute for Media Analysis (IMA), a New York based non-profit
organization whose mission is to conduct and support research and
dissemination of information on government activities, the media and the
populace and the interrelationship between them, with a particular
focus on activities that relate to national security. Kunstler works
closely with Deborah Hrbek
on numerous matters, including speaking engagements in support of
Julian Assange, advice to small businesses and activists regarding the
cannabis laws and regulations in New York, and anti-money laundering
(AML) compliance services for galleries, collectors and dealers in fine
art.
Kunstler represents Sarah Harrison, and has advised Anonymous
and WikiLeaks in connection with grand jury subpoenas, encounters with
the FBI, and overcoming fundraising hurdles in the face of corporate
obstruction and governmental suppression. She was also the attorney for
Jeremy Hammond. An advocate for street protesters and other activists
utilizing more modern tools for getting their voices heard, Kunstler
fights to protect constitutional rights of demonstrators online and on
the street.Together with her late husband, William M. Kunstler, subject
of the Oscar short-listed documentary, Disturbing the Universe,
Margaret Kunstler worked on high profile matters that included the
Virgin Island 5, Attica, and Wounded Knee. Kunstler is the founder of
the William Moses Kunstler Fund for Racial Justice, established to work
to combat racism in the criminal justice system, which spearheaded the
successful fight for the reform of New York State’s Rockefeller Drug
Laws and helped hundreds of nonviolent first-time drug offenders get out
of prison.
Kunstler was a founding member of the National
Lawyers Guild NYC Mass Defense Committee, formed to coordinate
representation for those arrested during the 1968 Columbia University
Protests. To this day, the NLG-NYC Mass Defense Committee provides legal
observers at demonstrations and pro bono criminal defense
representation for arrestees at protests. After working as public
defender at the Legal Aid Society in New York City, Kunstler went on to
represent grand jury resisters nationwide and became recognized as a
leading expert on grand jury law. She was director of the Grand Jury
Project Kunstler and edited Representing Witnesses Before Federal Grand Juries,
the authoritative practice manual in the field. Kunstler worked at the
Center for Constitutional Rights (CCR) as an attorney and educational
director. At CCR, she originated the Movement Support Network, work for
which she was named ABC Person of the Week, and authored the now famous
pamphlet, If An Agent Knocks.
No comments:
Post a Comment