Sunday, 23 October 2022

Challenging Trudeau's Emergencies Act

 
 

  
 
 
 
 

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MXY0KUauAJE&ab_channel=CanadianConstitutionFoundation 

 

Case Announcement - Challenging Trudeau's Emergencies Act

6,367 views
Feb 19, 2022
39.4K subscribers
TORONTO: The Canadian Constitution Foundation (CCF) has announced it is launching a legal challenge to the federal government’s invocation of the Emergencies Act. The challenge will be by way of urgent application for judicial review at the Federal Court. 
 
“Prime Minister Trudeau has set a dangerous precedent by invoking the never before used federal Emergencies Act to address the current situation. The high threshold for declaring a public order emergency in the Emergencies Act has not been met. The Act has been invoked to address a failure to use existing legal tools under the Criminal Code, which were used effectively on the Ambassador Bridge. The federal government has invoked the Emergencies Act as a matter of political convenience. This is illegal and violates the rule of law, and that’s why we are challenging the government in court,” said CCF Litigation Director, Christine Van Geyn. 
 
The Emergencies Act was enacted to replace the discredited War Measures Act, which was used during the Second World War to intern Japanese Canadians and Italian Canadians, and during the FLQ Crisis in Quebec. The Act is drafted carefully and narrowly, to ensure the federal government cannot abuse emergency powers ever again. The Act defines a national emergency as “an urgent and critical situation of a temporary nature that (a) seriously endangers the lives, health or safety of Canadians and is of such proportions or nature as to exceed the capacity or authority of a province to deal with it, or (b) seriously threatens the ability of the Government of Canada to preserve the sovereignty, security and territorial integrity of Canada”. It also requires that the federal government demonstrate that this situation cannot be effectively dealt with under any other law of Canada. 
 
“Emergency legislation should not be normalized. The threshold for using the Emergencies Act is extremely high and has not been met. The decision to invoke the Emergencies Act, which has never been used or interpreted by the courts, is unprecedented. If Parliament authorizes the proclamation of the public order emergency, the courts will be the last defence for the rule of law”, continued Van Geyn. “This isn’t about the convoy versus the city. This is about the rule of law.” 
 
 The CCF is represented by lawyers Sujit Choudhry and Janani Shanmuganathan. 
 
Members of the public who are interested in supporting the case can make a tax deductible charitable donation at theccf.ca/emergenciesact/ 
 
You can read more here: theccf.ca/legal-challenge-emergencies-act/ 
 
Sign up for our freedom updates here: theCCF.ca/FreedomUpdates/
 
 
 
 

Update in CCF legal challenge to access unredacted Emergencies Act evidence from Trudeau government

33,131 views
Aug 29, 2022
39.4K subscribers
On August 26, Justice Mosley of the Federal Court issued a decision on the Canadian Constitution Foundation’s motion to access complete and unredacted documents before cabinet when it invoked the Emergencies Act. The CCF argued that the federal government claim of cabinet confidentiality over these documents was an attempt to immunize the government’s decision to invoke the Emergencies Act from judicial review. The CCF sought access to these documents on a counsel-only basis and subject to a confidentiality undertaking. 
 
 Justice Mosley dismissed the motion, but held that the Court will determine if the government’s assertion of additional heads of privilege – solicitor-client privilege, public interest privilege, and national security privilege – are valid. The Court has given the government 14 days to respond. The Court also confirmed that the documents the government has produced so far would not have become public without the motion brought by the CCF. 
 
“While this was not the result we wanted, the Court affirmed the Canadian Constitution Foundation’s position that the government must prove its case. The federal government’s position has been ‘just trust us’ when it comes to the Emergencies Act. Justice Mosley has made it clear that this isn’t good enough,” said CCF Litigation Director, Christine Van Geyn. 
 
 “While Justice Mosley held on this motion that he has enough evidence to perform his legal duty to decide the CCF’s legal challenge to the public order emergency, this does not mean that the evidence proves that the public order emergency was lawful or constitutional,” continued Van Geyn. “This decision is just the first of many steps on the way to a decision on the merits of the Canadian Constitution Foundation’s challenge.” 
  
Justice Mosley held that the record in this case needed to include the minutes of the Cabinet and Incident Response Group, and that the government (at para. 101) “avoided a declaration to the effect that it had produced an incomplete record by belatedly delivering the IRG and Cabinet minutes and agendas.” 
 
 “We are pleased that the Court acknowledged that the evidence we do have now would never have been disclosed without the Canadian Constitution Foundation motion,” continued Van Geyn. 
 
This evidence was reported on the front page of the Globe and Mail and the Toronto Star, and received significant national media attention. 
 
Members of the public who are interested in supporting the case can make a tax deductible charitable donation at theccf.ca/donate 
 
 
Watch our other videos about our legal challenge to the Trudeau government's use of the Emergencies Act here:  
 
 
Media Coverage about the evidence disclosed as a result of this motion: https://www.theglobeandmail.com/polit... 
 
 

 

Additional information on :  T-306-22

Type :  Federal Court

Nature of Cause :  S. 18.1 Application for Judicial Review

Office :  Toronto     Language :  English

Type of Action :  Non-Action

Filing Date :  2022-02-18

Party Information:

Party NameSolicitorLawyer(s) / file no
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF CANADA - -
Canadian Frontline NursesJOHNSTONE & COWLING LLPBOISSONNEAU LEHNER, ALEXANDER
Kristen Nagle
Recorded Entry Information :   T-306-22

Type :  Federal Court

Nature of Proceeding :  S. 18.1 Application for Judicial Review

Office :  Toronto     Language :  English

Type of Action :  Federal Court

Filing Date :  2022-02-18

Recorded Entry Summary Information

Certain public documents in some proceedings are now available for online access in accordance with the Federal Court’s Online Access to Court Records – Pilot Project. These documents are identified with a download icon () in the Download column below.

You may obtain copies of other public documents by contacting the Registry. Copies of public documents which are already in electronic format can be sent by e-mail, upon request to the Registry: fc_reception_cf@cas-satj.gc.ca. Indicate the Court File number in the subject of your email. In the text, you must clearly identify the document number and its name (this information is located in the Recorded Entry Summary column).

The availability of documents from the Registry, including through online access, does not grant a copyright licence or permission. Your use of such materials must be in accordance with the Copyright Act, RSC 1985, c C-42.

112 records found
DocDate FiledOfficeRecorded Entry SummaryDownload
null2022-10-20Toronto Letter from Respondent dated 20-OCT-2022 This letter outlines the disagreements in a draft order. received on 20-OCT-2022
null2022-10-05TorontoToronto 05-OCT-2022 BEFORE The Honourable Mr. Justice Mosley Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: Parties discuss various motions and scheduling held by way of Conference Call Duration per day: 05-OCT-2022 from 03:00 to 03:56 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Andrew Murray Total Duration: 56min Appearances: Alexander Boissonneau-Lehner N/A representing Applicant John Provart N/A representing Respondent Kathleen Kohlman N/A representing Respondent Comments: DARS not used. The parties discuss scheduling various motions and hearings. Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1084 page(s) 306 - 307 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-09-16TorontoToronto 16-SEP-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Motion Doc. No. 48 on behalf of Respondent Result of Hearing: Matter partially granted held by way of video conference Duration per day: 16-SEP-2022 from 10:05 to 11:25 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Andrew Murray Total Duration: 1h 20min Appearances: David Cowling N/A representing Applicant Alexander Boissonneau-Lehner N/A representing Applicant John Provart N/A representing Respondent Idorenyin Udoh-Orok N/A representing Respondent Comments: Recorded on Zoom cloud. Various questions refused and ordered answered. Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1083 page(s) 382 - 383 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
572022-09-15Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of John Provart confirming service of Doc 56 upon Applicant by email on 15-SEP-2022 filed on 15-SEP-2022
562022-09-15Toronto Respondent's Compendium re: September 16th motion filed on 15-SEP-2022
null2022-09-07TorontoToronto 07-SEP-2022 BEFORE The Honourable Mr. Justice Mosley Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: Parties discuss various matters. held by way of Conference Call Duration per day: 07-SEP-2022 from 10:00 to 10:43 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Andrew Murray Total Duration: 43min Appearances: David Cowling N/A representing Applicant Alexander Boisonneau-Lehner N/A representing Applicant Christopher Rupar N/A representing Respondent John Provart N/A representing Respondent Kathleen Kohlman N/A representing Respondent Comments: DARS not used. The parties discuss various matters. Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1083 page(s) 119 - 120 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
552022-08-29Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Alexander Boisonneau-Lehner confirming service of Applicant's written representations upon Respondent by email on 29-AUG-2022 filed on 29-AUG-2022
542022-08-29Toronto Written Representations on behalf of Applicant concerning Motion in writing Doc. No. 48 filed on 29-AUG-2022
null2022-08-03Toronto S. 39 material transmitted by the DOJ received on 03-AUG-2022
532022-07-28Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Idorenyin Udoh-Orok confirming service of Motion Record upon Applicants by electronic mail on 28-JUL-2022 filed on 28-JUL-2022
522022-07-28Toronto Motion Record containing the following original document(s): 48 49 50 51 Number of copies received: 1 on behalf of Respondent filed on 28-JUL-2022
512022-07-28Toronto Written Representations contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Respondent concerning Motion in writing Doc. No. 48 filed on 28-JUL-2022
502022-07-28Toronto Transcript of hearing held at Ottawa, ON by VC on 25-FEB-2022 contained in motion record filed on 28-JUL-2022 51 pages (including covering pages).
492022-07-28Toronto Transcript of cross-examination contained in the Motion Record in support of doc. 48 RE: Affidavits of Kristen Nagle sw. 18-FEB-2022 and 4-MAR-2022 held 24-JUN-2022 filed on 28-JUL-2022
482022-07-28TorontoNotice of Motion contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Respondent in writing to be dealt with in the Toronto local office for an Order requiring the applicant, Kristen Nagle, to answer questions that were improperly objected to during the cross-examination on her affidavit (including marking various documents as full exhibits), and to answer any questions arising from the answers filed on 28-JUL-2022
null2022-07-05Toronto Copy of oral direction ID 71 dated 30-JUN-2022 placed on file on 05-JUL-2022 Original placed on Court File No. T-316-22
null2022-06-30Ottawa Oral directions received from the Court: K. Trudeau, Judicial Administrator dated 30-JUN-2022 directing that "Parties are advised to remain available for a hearing on the merits from October 17 to 21 and November 14 to 18, 2022. An Order scheduling the hearing on the merits will follow in due course." placed on file on 30-JUN-2022
null2022-06-30TorontoToronto 30-JUN-2022 BEFORE The Honourable Mr. Justice Mosley Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: July 5th motions on T-316-22 and T-347-22 adjourned to 18-JUL-2022 at 10:00 via Zoom V/C. Duration of 2 days. held via Zoom V/C Duration per day: 30-JUN-2022 from 11:08 to 11:42 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Jake Schutz Total Duration: 42min Appearances: Mr. Boisseneau-Lehner n/a representing applicant on T-306-22 Ms. Krajewska and Mr. Chung n/a representing applicant on T-316-22 Ms. Shanmuganathan and Mr. Choudhry n/a representing applicant on T-347-22 Mr. Miller n/a representing applicant on T-382-22 Ms. England and Ms. McDaniel n/a representing Intervenor Mr. Anderson, Ms. Kohlman, Mr. Provart and Mr. Rupar n.a representing Respondent Comments: Associate Judge Milczynski also co-presided on this matter. Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1081 page(s) 144 - 145 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-06-22TorontoToronto 22-JUN-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: The parties are on track for the Motion July 5, 2022; a further Case Management Conference to take place June 30, 2022 held by way of Conference Call Duration per day: 22-JUN-2022 from 11:02 to 11:23 Courtroom : Toronto (Zoom) Court Registrar: Monica Mecca Total Duration: 21min Appearances: Alexander Boissonneau-Lehner, David Cowling, MacKenzie Campbell NA representing Applicants (T-306-22) Ewa Krajewska, Brandon Chung NA representing Applicant (T-316-22) Sujit Choudhry, Janani Shanmuganathan NA representing Applicant (T-347-22) Brendan Miller, Blair Ector, Bath-Sheba van den Berg NA representing Applicants (T-382-22) Jeff Anderson, John Provart, Kathleen Kohlman NA representing Respondent Mandy England, Leah McDaniel, Shaheer Meenai NA representing Intervenor Comments: Recorded via Zoom Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1080 page(s) 453 - 454 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-05-25Toronto Oral directions received from the Court: Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary dated 25-MAY-2022 directing that Further to the case management conference held this day, motions filed by the Applicants in T-316-22 and T-347-22 shall be heard by zoom on 5-JUL-2022 (full day - start time to be confirmed), with all materials for the Court to be filed by 29-JUN-2022. Cross examinations in all files shall be completed by 20-JUN-2022 (exception: parties shall complete cross examination of Denis Beaudoin by or shortly after 20-JUN-2022, but so as to meet filing and hearing deadlines). A case management conference shall be conducted by zoom on 22-JUN-2022 at 11:00AM(ET) to discuss the status of the Applicants' motions, and any motions contemplated by the Respondent that arise from the cross-examinations of affiants in any of T-306-22, T-316-22, T-347-22 or T-382-22. A further case management conference shall be conduceted if required (by zoom) on 30-JUN-2022 at 11:00AM(ET). placed on file on 25-MAY-2022
null2022-05-25TorontoToronto 25-MAY-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: motion scheduled 27-MAY-2022 has been adjourned, a direction scheduling the next date for the motion to follow held by way of video conference Duration per day: 25-MAY-2022 from 11:00 to 12:00 Courtroom : Toronto (Zoom) Court Registrar: Shaun Nelson Total Duration: 1hour Appearances: Mr. Boissenault-Lehner na representing Applicant Mr. Anderson, Mr. Provart, Ms. Kohlman na representing Respondent Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1079 page(s) 273 - 274 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-05-09TorontoToronto 09-MAY-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: Parties discuss timeline for expert examination held by way of Conference Call Duration per day: 09-MAY-2022 from 11:00 to 11:40 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Andrew Murray Total Duration: 40min Appearances: David Cowling N/A representing Applicant Alexander Boissonneau-Lehrer N/A representing Applicant Jeff Anderson N/A representing Respondent Kathleen Kohlman N/A representing Respondent Comments: Recorded on Zoom cloud. Parties discuss expert timelines. Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1078 page(s) 221 - 222 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
472022-05-04TorontoOrder dated 04-MAY-2022 rendered by Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Matter considered without personal appearance The Court's decision is with regard to Motion Doc. No. 19 Result: granted Filed on 04-MAY-2022 copies sent to parties entered in J. & O. Book, volume 1537 page(s) 313 - 318 Interlocutory Decision
null2022-05-04Toronto Oral directions received from the Court: Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary dated 04-MAY-2022 directing that "Further to the case management teleconference conducted this day, and upon reviewing the correspondence from counsel for the Respondent dated April 28, 2022: 1)The Respondent is granted an extension to May 19, 2022 to deliver their expert report. 2)As agreed to by the parties, the Respondent will provide the name and proposed area of expertise (including the questions on which the expert is asked to provide an opinion) to the Applicants on a confidential party-to-party basis as of the date this direction is issued. The parties have confirmed that doing so will not constitute a broader waiver of litigation privilege or limit the expert's ultimate area of expertise or the scope of the final report, as the expert conducts their research and drafts their report, and the information provided will not be admissible unless and until a report is filed. In particular, should the Respondent decide not to file an expert report, the Applicants will not seek to retain the expert or be entitled to any working papers or drafts or evidence with respect to the expert's opinion 3)The Respondent will not oppose the filing of responding expert evidence should the Applicants or any of them believe this to be necessary, and the parties shall endeavor to work out a schedule for this. After receiving the information from the Attorney General of Canada about the expert as outlined above, if any Applicant decides to proceed to cross-examine the Respondent's fact affiants before May 19, 2022, this will not prevent the Applicant from filing a responding expert report or to re-open cross examination of the fact affiants (either in person or in writing) on issues that arise from the expert evidence. In addition, as discussed on the May 4, 2022 case management teleconference, the dates for the filing of application records are suspended and will be further discussed on the next CMC (May 9 at 11am), together with new dates for the hearing of the application. It is also acknowledged that the moving materials for the Respondent's motions to strike the applications on the grounds of mootness and sanding have been filed - the date for responding records remains June 20, 2022. With respect to the motions in T-347-22 (to amend the application and regarding the CTR), the hearing of the motions is confirmed: May 27, 2022 commencing at 9:30am by Zoom - although the AGC's responding motion is currently due on May 25, 2022 (following the extension of time for the Applciant's record), counsel for the Respondent AGC shall advise whether a May 20, 2022 filing date can be met." placed on file on 04-MAY-2022 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
null2022-04-29Toronto Letter from Respondent dated 28-APR-2022 This letter is in reply to the applicant's letter in T-306-22 received on 29-APR-2022
null2022-04-28Toronto Letter from Applicant dated 28-APR-2022 This letter is in response to the AGC's letter sent earlier today. received on 28-APR-2022
null2022-04-28Toronto Letter from Respondent dated 28-APR-2022 This letter is in regards to the expert reports. received on 28-APR-2022
null2022-04-11TorontoToronto 11-APR-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: court to issues a scheduling direction held by way of video conference Duration per day: 11-APR-2022 from 11:05 to 12:25 Courtroom : Toronto (Zoom) Court Registrar: Shaun Nelson Total Duration: 1h 20min Appearances: David Cowling, Simon Sigler, Alexander Boissonneau-Lehner na representing Applicant John Provart, Jeff Anderson na representing Respondent Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1078 page(s) 60 - 61 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-04-25Toronto Letter from Respondent dated 25-APR-2022 This letter from the respondent contains a small update. received on 25-APR-2022
null2022-04-21Toronto Letter from Respondent dated 21-APR-2022 This letter discusses the expert reports received on 21-APR-2022
462022-04-19Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Alexander Boissonneau-Lehner confirming service of Written reps dated 19-APR-2022 upon all parties by email on 19-APR-2022 filed on 19-APR-2022
null2022-04-20Toronto Letter from Respondent dated 19-APR-2022 This letter is in regards to the experts received on 20-APR-2022
452022-04-19Toronto Written Representations on behalf of Applicant concerning Motion Doc. No. 19 filed on 19-APR-2022
null2022-04-19Toronto Oral directions received from the Court: Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary dated 19-APR-2022 directing that "Having review the correspondence/materials filed to date following the April 11, 2022 cmc: i)T-306-22 - confirming that the Applicant's motion to amend their application will proceed in writing. The Respondent's motion/cross motion to strike (on grounds of mootness and standing) will NOT be determined in writing and will NOT be determined prior to the date set for the hearing of the application. ii)AG of Alberta motion to intervene - no change to direction issued on April 11, 2022. Motion, in writing, will be determined following Reply or the time for filing any Reply has expired. iii)T-347-22 - Parties will confirm their availability for a one day hearing (by Zoom) on one of: May 26, 27, 30 or 31, 2022. Hearing is for the Applicants' motion to amend their application and motion relating to the CEA s.39 certificate and counsel's eyes only disclosure. To confirm: any motion or cross motion to strike the application on grounds of mootness or standing will be determined in the same manner and time as in T-306-22. iv)All files: Having considered the CCLA's proposal outlined in its April 14, 2022 letter: -the Respondent shall provide the name and area of expertise of its expert by April 21, 2022; -the Respondent's expert report shall be served and filed by May 5, 2022; -the parties shall in the meantime consult with one another and submit a jointly proposed protocol and schedule to complete the cross examinations (with a view to setting dates for the filing of the application records so as to preserve hearing dates in July); and -a case management teleconference shall be conducted (by Zoom) on May 9, 2022 at 11:00am (EST). The Court remains available on May 4, 2022 if any party wishes to also proceed with a CMC on that date. Confirmation to be submitted by May 2nd, otherwise the date is cancelled placed on file on 19-APR-2022 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
null2022-04-12Toronto Letter from Respondent dated 12-APR-2022 This letter contains a status update on all emergency act files received on 12-APR-2022
442022-04-12Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of David Aaron confirming service of Doc 42 upon Applicant by email on 11-APR-2022 filed on 12-APR-2022
432022-04-12Toronto Motion Record containing the following original document(s): 37 38 39 40 41 42 Number of copies received: 1 on behalf of Respondent filed on 12-APR-2022
422022-04-12Toronto Written Representations contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Respondent concerning Motion Doc. No. 37 filed on 12-APR-2022
412022-04-12TorontoAffidavit of Vincent Gircys sworn on 08-MAR-2022 contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Respondent in support of Motion Doc. No. 37 filed on 12-APR-2022
402022-04-12TorontoAffidavit of Edward Cornell sworn on 23-FEB-2022 contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Respondent in support of Motion Doc. No. 37 filed on 12-APR-2022
392022-04-12TorontoAffidavit of Harold Ristau sworn on 09-MAR-2022 contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Respondent in support of Motion Doc. No. 37 filed on 12-APR-2022
382022-04-12TorontoAffidavit of Kristen Nagle sworn on 06-MAR-2022 contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Respondent in support of Motion Doc. No. 37 filed on 12-APR-2022
372022-04-12TorontoNotice of Motion contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Respondent in writing to be dealt with in the Toronto local office for an Order striking the application filed on 12-APR-2022
362022-04-12Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Ayesha Laldin confirming service of Doc 35 upon Applicant by email on 11-APR-2022 filed on 12-APR-2022
352022-04-12Toronto Motion Record in response to Motion Doc. No. 19 containing the following original document(s): 33 34 Number of copies received: 1 on behalf of Respondent filed on 12-APR-2022
342022-04-12Toronto Written Representations contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Respondent concerning Motion Doc. No. 19 filed on 12-APR-2022
332022-04-12TorontoAffidavit of Kristen Nagle sworn on 06-MAR-2022 contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Respondent in opposition to Motion Doc. No. 19 filed on 12-APR-2022
null2022-04-12Toronto Oral directions received from the Court: Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary dated 12-APR-2022 directing that "Further to the case management teleconference conducted on April 11, 2022: (i)T-306-22: Counsel for the Respondent AGC confirmed that their motion record responding to the Applicants' motion to amend their application will be served today. Any Reply shall be served and filed within 5 days of service. (motion in writing) (ii)Attorney General of Alberta motion to intervene in T-316-22 and T-347-22 Alberta AG has circulated their notice of motion and will serve and file their complete motion record by April 14, 2022. Attorney General of Canada and Applicants in the two files shall file any responding motion records by April 25 and any Reply is due April 29, 2022. (motion in writing) (iii)T-347-22: Counsel for the Respondent AGC confirmed that their motion record responding to the Applicant's motion to amend their application will be served by Wednesday April 13th. Any Reply shall be served and filed within 5 days thereafter. (motion in writing) (iv)T-347-22: Motion relating to validity of CEA s. 39 certificate and counsel's eyes only disclosure - Applicant has circulated a notice of motion and will serve and file a complete motion record with amended notice of motion by April 19, 2022. Responding AGC motion record shall be served and filed by May 19, 2022. The Court notes that both parties are requesting an oral hearing of the motion and that counsel for the Applicant also suggested that this and their motion to amend the application be heard together. The Court will advise of available dates. (v)All files: with respect to next steps and current timetable, counsel for the AGC confirmed that it was their intention to serve an expert affidavit. They are directed to do so by April 29, 2022 and circulate any possible information/content/unsworn draft prior to this date. This has an impact on the timelines. The evidence stage of the applications should nonetheless be completed and closed prior to cross examinations. So as to facilitate the scheduling of cross examinations, ensure a coordinated and coherent manner of proceeding, a case management teleconference shall be conducted on May 4, 2022 at 2pm (ET). The purpose of the call is to confirm whether any of the Applicants seek to respond to the AGC's expert report, and to confirm the schedule and protocol amongst counsel for the cross examinations. Counsel will discuss and submit their proposal ahead of the call. (vi)All files: The Respondent AGC advised that their motions to strike applications on the grounds of lack of standing and mootness would be served and filed this week. The current timetable had this step scheduled for May 20, 2022, with responding motion records to be filed by June 20 and per the applications judge the motions heard at the same time as hearing of the applications. Any change to accelerate the time for the filing of the responding records may be discussed at the May 4th cmc, but at present, the direction regarding responding records and the hearing of the motions remains as is. (vii)All files: The Court notes that the applications have generally followed the timelines for applications under the Federal Court Rules, and with the exception of a hearing date being scheduled prior to the filing of application records and requisition for hearing. The goal is to have the applications hearing in an efficient, timely and coordinated manner so as to ensure a just and fair hearing on a complete record that will assist the hearing judge. Accordingly, in light of the foregoing matters discussed and outstanding interlocutory motions, the Court invites the parties to consult with one another and file submissions/proposals regarding the time by which cross examinations can reasonably be completed, application records filed and the applications heard - keeping in mind that a July hearing ought to still be possible." placed on file on 12-APR-2022 Confirmed in writing t
322022-04-05Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Nur Muhammed-Ally confirming service of Coleman Affidavit upon Applicant by email on 04-APR-2022 filed on 05-APR-2022
312022-04-05TorontoAffidavit of Rebecca Coleman sworn on 04-APR-2022 on behalf of Respondent in opposition to Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A-RRRRR filed on 05-APR-2022
302022-04-04Ottawa Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Kathleen Kohlman confirming service of the Affidavit of Steven Shragge upon Applicant by e-mail on 04-APR-2022 filed on 04-APR-2022
292022-04-04OttawaAffidavit of Steven Shragge sworn on 04-APR-2022 on behalf of Respondent in opposition to Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A-D filed on 04-APR-2022
282022-04-04OttawaAffidavit of Denis Beaudoin sworn on 04-APR-2022 on behalf of Respondent in opposition to Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A-D filed on 04-APR-2022
272022-04-01Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of John Provart confirming service of Doc 26 upon Applicant by email on 01-APR-2022 filed on 01-APR-2022
262022-04-01TorontoAffidavit of Jeremy Adler sworn on 01-APR-2022 on behalf of Respondent in opposition to Motion Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A filed on 01-APR-2022
252022-04-04Ottawa Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Kathleen Kohlman confirming service of the Affidavit of Denis Beaudoin upon Applicant by e-mail on 04-APR-2022 filed on 04-APR-2022
null2022-04-01Toronto Letter from Respondent dated 01-APR-2022 This letter contains the s. 39 request to the clerk of the privy council. received on 01-APR-2022
null2022-03-31Toronto Letter from Respondent dated 31-MAR-2022 This letter is in response to the applicant's motion record received on 31-MAR-2022
242022-03-30Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of A. Boissonneau-Lehner confirming service of doc 22 & 23 upon Respondent by e-mail on 29-MAR-2022 filed on 30-MAR-2022
232022-03-30Toronto Bill of costs of Applicant filed on 30-MAR-2022
222022-03-30Toronto Motion Record containing the following original document(s): 19 20 21 Number of copies received: 3 on behalf of Applicant filed on 30-MAR-2022
212022-03-30Toronto Written Representations contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Applicant concerning Motion Doc. No. 19 filed on 30-MAR-2022
202022-03-30TorontoAffidavit of Simon Sigler sworn on 29-MAR-2022 contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Applicant in support of Motion Doc. No. 19 with Exhibits A-I filed on 30-MAR-2022
192022-03-30TorontoNotice of Motion contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Applicant in writing to be dealt with in the Toronto local office for an Order to amend the Notice of Application filed on 30-MAR-2022
null2022-03-25TorontoToronto 25-MAR-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: Parties discuss the r. 317 material held by way of video conference Duration per day: 25-MAR-2022 from 11:00 to 11:32 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Andrew Murray Total Duration: 32min Appearances: David Cowling N/A representing Applicant Simon Sigler N/A representing Applicant Alexander Boissonneau-Lehner N/A representing Applicant John Provart N/A representing Respondent Jeff Anderson N/A representing Respondent Comments: Recorded on Zoom cloud. Parties discuss r. 317 material Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1076 page(s) 348 - 349 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-03-11TorontoToronto 11-MAR-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: Court to issue a direction outlining the next steps in the proceeding held by way of video conference Duration per day: 11-MAR-2022 from 10:00 to 11:00 Courtroom : Toronto (Zoom) Court Registrar: Shaun Nelson Total Duration: 1h Appearances: Simon Sigler, David Cowling, Alexander Boisonneau-Lehner n/a representing Applicant John Provart, Jeff Anderson na representing Respondent Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1076 page(s) 331 - 332 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-03-23Toronto Oral directions received from the Court: Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary dated 23-MAR-2022 directing that "A case management teleconference shall be conducted on Friday March 25, 2022 at 11am by Zoom. The purpose of the call is to discuss the Rule 317 requests, responses, and next steps. If any party has anything to add to the correspondence already submitted, they shall file their submissions by 3pm March 24th." placed on file on 23-MAR-2022 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
null2022-03-23Toronto Letter from Respondent dated 22-MAR-2022 This letter is in response to the applicant's letter of March 18th received on 23-MAR-2022
null2022-03-18Toronto Letter from Applicant dated 18-MAR-2022 This letter is in regards to the material produced by the respondent received on 18-MAR-2022
null2022-03-15Toronto Letter from Respondent dated 15-MAR-2022 Attaching a copy of the Clerk of the Privy Council's office's response to the rule 317 request... also notes CPC intends to engage section 39 of the Canada Evidence Act at their earliest opportunity. with proof of service upon Applicant on 15-MAR-2022 received on 15-MAR-2022
null2022-03-11Toronto Oral directions received from the Court: Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary dated 11-MAR-2022 directing that "Scheduling direction" placed on file on 11-MAR-2022
null2022-03-11Toronto Letter from Applicant dated 11-MAR-2022 This letter is in regards to the proposed motion to strike, and about a possible amended notice of application. received on 11-MAR-2022
182022-03-04TorontoAffidavit of service of Alexander Boissonneau-Lehner sworn on 04-MAR-2022 on behalf of Applicant confirming service of Sigler, Nagle, and Marazzo affidavit upon Respondent by email on 04-MAR-2022 filed on 04-MAR-2022
172022-03-04TorontoAffidavit of Kristen Nagle sworn on 04-MAR-2022 on behalf of Applicant in support of Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A-G filed on 04-MAR-2022
162022-03-04TorontoAffidavit of Simon Sigler sworn on 18-FEB-2022 on behalf of Applicant in support of Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A filed on 04-MAR-2022
152022-03-04TorontoAffidavit of Tom Marazzo sworn on 04-MAR-2022 on behalf of Applicant in support of Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 filed on 04-MAR-2022
null2022-03-02Ottawa Letter from Respondent dated 02-MAR-2022 "Please provide this correspondence to the Case Management Judges..." -sent directly to atention of CMJ (Mosley,J & Milczynski,P) received on 02-MAR-2022
null2022-03-01Ottawa Acknowledgment of Receipt received from Applicant with respect to the oral direction issued by the Court on 1-MAR-2022 placed on file on 01-MAR-2022
null2022-03-01Ottawa Acknowledgment of Receipt received from Both parties with respect to Doc. 14 placed on file on 01-MAR-2022
142022-03-01OttawaReasons Order and Reasons dated 01-MAR-2022 rendered by The Honourable Mr. Justice Mosley Matter considered with personal appearance The Court's decision is with regard to Motion in writing Doc. No. 3 Result: dismissed Filed on 01-MAR-2022 copies sent to parties Interlocutory Decision Copy of Reasons for Order and Order entered in J. & O. Book, volume 1529 page(s) 122 - 134
null2022-03-01Ottawa Oral directions received from the Court: Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary dated 01-MAR-2022 directing that "The notice of motion seeking an order granting intervenor status in Court File T-306-22 shall not be accepted for filing": see e-copy... placed on file on 01-MAR-2022 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
null2022-03-01Ottawa Memorandum to file from OTTAWA, JONATHAN MACENA dated 01-MAR-2022 advising that the Registry only received the proposed third party, Jane Scharf's notice of motion to intervene dated 24-FEB-2022 on 1-MAR-2022, it has beeen forwarded to case management judges for further instructions. placed on file.
132022-02-28Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of John Provart confirming service of doc. 12 upon Respondent by email on 22-FEB-2022 filed on 28-FEB-2022
122022-02-28Toronto Notice of appearance on behalf of Third Party filed on 28-FEB-2022
null2022-02-25OttawaOttawa 25-FEB-2022 BEFORE The Honourable Mr. Justice Mosley Language: E Before the Court: Motion Doc. No. 3 on behalf of Applicant Result of Hearing: Matter reserved held by way of video conference Duration per day: 25-FEB-2022 from 10:00 to 11:19 Courtroom : Ottawa (Zoom) Court Registrar: Jonathan Macena Total Duration: 1 hour and 15 minutes Appearances: Alexander Boissonneau-Lehner, Simon Sigler and David G. Cowling 416-546-2103 representing Applicant John Provart, Ayesha Laldin and Shain Widdifield 647-256-0784, 647-256-7516, 647-256-0574 representing Respondent Comments: Used Zoom to record, few interruptions due to video sharing violations from attendees. This hearing was conducted by way of webinar. Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1075 page(s) 247 - 248 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-02-25Ottawa Supplementary Book of Authorities consisting of 1 volume(s) on behalf of Applicant received on 25-FEB-2022 Sent directly to Presiding Judge
112022-02-25Ottawa Bill of costs of Defendant Applicant with proof of service on Respondent on 25-FEB-2022 filed on 25-FEB-2022
null2022-02-25Ottawa Memorandum to file from Ottawa dated 25-FEB-2022 This memo is to indicate that Mr. Alexandre Boissonneau-Lehner solicitor for the Applicant acknowledged receipt via telephone of the Order sent on 02-18- 2022 by email. placed on file.
102022-02-24Ottawa Acknowledgment of Receipt received from Respondent with respect to doc 9 filed on 24-FEB-2022
92022-02-24Ottawa Reply Representations on behalf of Respondent in response to the opposing submissions doc. No. 8 to the Motion in writing Filed on 24-FEB-2022
null2022-02-24Ottawa Oral directions received from the Court: The Honourable Mr. Justice Mosley dated 24-FEB-2022 directing that "The parties are advised that the hearing will proceed as scheduled. The Court will hear the parties on the issue of costs and on the question of whether the principles expressed in Borowski v. Canada have any application in the context of a motion for a stay that is moot. The Respondent may file their motion record, if any, responding to these questions by 9 a.m. Friday, February 25, 2022. placed on file on 24-FEB-2022 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
null2022-02-24Ottawa Letter from Applicant dated 24-FEB-2022 providing a response to Justice Mosley's second direction requesting the ability to make oral submissions during the hearing set for 25-FEB-2022 received on 24-FEB-2022
null2022-02-24Ottawa Acknowledgment of Receipt received from both parties with respect to the two directions issued by Justice Mosley on 24-FEB-2022 placed on file on 24-FEB-2022
null2022-02-24Ottawa Oral directions received from the Court: The Honourable Mr. Justice Mosley dated 24-FEB-2022 directing that "The Court (Justice Mosley) has read the parties' responses to the Registry 's inquiry about the status of the Applicant's motion for an interim injunction. The Court notes that it does not have the jurisdiction to decide stay motions in the absence of a live controversy between the parties." (see e-copy...) placed on file on 24-FEB-2022 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
null2022-02-24Ottawa Oral directions received from the Court: The Honourable Mr. Justice Mosley dated 24-FEB-2022 directing that "Parties are to communicate whether the motion scheduled to be heard on February 25, 2022 is now moot and the hearing should be cancelled. Applicants are to advise the court whether they intend to proceed with their application for judicial review or disconinue it." placed on file on 24-FEB-2022 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
null2022-02-23Toronto Oral directions received from the Court: Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary dated 23-FEB-2022 directing that "Further to the case management teleconference conducted this day: -the Respondent shall provide an update regarding any preliminary issues (standing and mootness by March 2, 2022; -in respect of T-306-22, the Respondent shall deliver a response to the Applicants' Rule 317 request within 20 days; -in respect of T-306-22 and T-316-22: the Applicants shall serve and file their Rule 306 evidence by March 4, 2022 and the Respondent shall serve and file their Rule 307 evidence within 30 days of the date of service of the Applicants affidavits; -a case management teleconference is scheduled for Friday March 11, 2022 at 10am; and -the parties may at anytime requisition a case management teleconference by submitting their dates and times of mutual availability placed on file on 23-FEB-2022 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
82022-02-22Ottawa Amended Motion Record (Doc no. 4) by the Applicants filed on 22-FEB-2022
null2022-02-22Ottawa Oral directions received from the presiding judge dated 22-FEB-2022 directing that "The Applicants¿ urgent stay motion will be heard on Friday, February 25, 2022 at 10:00 am (Eastern Time), by Zoom videoconference. The Respondent's responding motion record shall be served and filed no later than Thursday, February 24, 2022, before 4:30 pm (Eastern Time)." placed on file on 22-FEB-2022
null2022-02-22TorontoToronto 22-FEB-2022 BEFORE The Honourable Mr. Justice Mosley Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: Justice Mosley discusses how these files will be conducted and sets a motion down for Friday February 25th @ 10am est held by way of video conference Duration per day: 22-FEB-2022 from 10:00 to 10:59 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Andrew Murray Total Duration: 59min Appearances: Simon Sigler 416-546-2103 representing Applicant David Cowling 416-546-2103 representing Applicant Alexander Boisonneau-Lehner 416-546-2103 representing Applicant John Provart 647-256-0784 representing Respondent R. J. Anderson 647-256-0784 representing Respondent Comments: Recorded on Zoom cloud. Prothonotary Milczynski also presided over this matter. Court schedules the motion for Friday February 25th @ 10am EST Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1075 page(s) 49 - 50 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-02-18Ottawa Acknowledgment of Receipt received from Applicant with respect to the Court's direction (Mosley J.) dated 18-Feb-22 BY E-MAIL placed on file on 18-FEB-2022
null2022-02-18Ottawa Acknowledgment of Receipt received from Respondent with respect to the court's direction (Mosley J.) dated 18_02-22 BY E-MAIL placed on file on 18-FEB-2022
null2022-02-18Ottawa Oral directions received from the presiding judge dated 18-FEB-2022 directing that "The Court is aware of the disagreement between the parties regarding scheduling of a case management conference in this matter but is cognizant that this motion has been filed judt today, Friday, February 18, 2022, that there are proceedings ebfore Parliament that may be concluded on Monday, February 21, 2022, and that there may be other applications filed in the coming days which could relate to the subject matter. In the interests of judicial economy and respect for the Parliament process, the Court thinks it is best to schedule a case management conference for Tuesday, February 22, 2 022 at 10 a.m. EDT, by Zoom videoconference. The Court also notes that the Applicants' Motion Record is incomplete." placed on file on 18-FEB-2022
null2022-02-18Toronto Letter from Applicant dated 18-FEB-2022 outling position for an urgent case conference received on 18-FEB-2022
72022-02-18OttawaOrder dated 18-FEB-2022 rendered by Chief Justice Crampton Matter considered without personal appearance The Court's decision is with regard to Motion ex proprio motu Result: «PURSUANT to Rules 47 and 384 of the Federal Courts Rules; IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT: 1. This proceeding shall continue as a specially managed proceeding. 2. Pursuant to Rule 383, Justice Richard G. Mosley and Prothonotary Martha Milczynski are assigned as Case Management Judges in this matter.» Filed on 18-FEB-2022 copies sent to parties entered in J. & O. Book, volume 1527 page(s) 379 - 380 Interlocutory Decision
62022-02-18Toronto Motion Record containing the following original document(s): 4 5 Number of copies received: 2 on behalf of Applicant filed on 18-FEB-2022
52022-02-18TorontoAffidavit of Simon Sigler sworn on 18-FEB-2022 contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Applicant in support of Motion Doc. No. 3 with Exhibits a-c filed on 18-FEB-2022
42022-02-18TorontoAffidavit of Kristen Nagle sworn on 18-FEB-2022 contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Applicant in support of Motion Doc. No. 3 with Exhibits A filed on 18-FEB-2022
32022-02-18TorontoNotice of Motion on behalf of Applicant returnable (but no hearing date indicated at this time) for an Order A temporary interlocutory order staying Order in Council PC Number: 2022-106 and other relief filed on 18-FEB-2022
22022-02-18TorontoAcknowledgment of Service received from Respondent with respect to DOC.1, Covering letter, Rule 35 Letter by email per covid protocol filed on 18-FEB-2022
null2022-02-18Toronto Letter from Applicant to JUDICIAL ADMINISTRATOR FEDERAL COURT dated 18-FEB-2022 requesting an urgent sitting - motion material to follow received on 18-FEB-2022
null2022-02-18Toronto Covering letter from Applicant dated 17-FEB-2022 concerning Doc. No. 1 placed on file on 18-FEB-2022
12022-02-18Toronto Notice of application and 2 copies with regard to Judicial Review (s.18) returnable (but no hearing date indicated at this time) filed on 18-FEB-2022 Certified copy(ies)/copy(ies) transmitted to Director of the Regional Office of the Department of Justice Tariff fee of $50.00 received: yes

 

Additional information on :  T-316-22

Type :  Federal Court

Nature of Cause :  S. 18.1 Application for Judicial Review

Office :  Toronto     Language :  English

Type of Action :  Non-Action

Filing Date :  2022-02-18

Party Information:

Party NameSolicitorLawyer(s) / file no
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF CANADA - -
CANADIAN CIVIL LIBERTIES ASSOCIATIONHenein Hutchison LLPKRAJEWSKA, EWA
Recorded Entry Information :   T-316-22

Type :  Federal Court

Nature of Proceeding :  S. 18.1 Application for Judicial Review

Office :  Toronto     Language :  English

Type of Action :  Federal Court

Filing Date :  2022-02-18

Recorded Entry Summary Information

Certain public documents in some proceedings are now available for online access in accordance with the Federal Court’s Online Access to Court Records – Pilot Project. These documents are identified with a download icon () in the Download column below.

You may obtain copies of other public documents by contacting the Registry. Copies of public documents which are already in electronic format can be sent by e-mail, upon request to the Registry: fc_reception_cf@cas-satj.gc.ca. Indicate the Court File number in the subject of your email. In the text, you must clearly identify the document number and its name (this information is located in the Recorded Entry Summary column).

The availability of documents from the Registry, including through online access, does not grant a copyright licence or permission. Your use of such materials must be in accordance with the Copyright Act, RSC 1985, c C-42.

100 records found
DocDate FiledOfficeRecorded Entry SummaryDownload
null2022-10-05TorontoToronto 05-OCT-2022 BEFORE The Honourable Mr. Justice Mosley Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: Parties discuss scheduling various motions and hearings held by way of Conference Call Duration per day: 05-OCT-2022 from 03:00 to 03:56 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Andrew Murray Total Duration: 56min Appearances: Ewa Krajewska N/A representing Applicant Brandon Chung N/A representing Applicant John Provart N/A representing Respondent Kathleen Kohlman N/A representing Respondent Comments: DARS not used. The parties discuss scheduling various matters Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1084 page(s) 308 - 309 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-09-21Toronto Letter from Respondent dated 21-SEP-2022 This letter is in response to the applicant's letter of Sept 20 received on 21-SEP-2022
null2022-09-20Toronto Letter from Applicant dated 20-SEP-2022 This letter provides an update from the applicant and their preference for the hearing on its merits. received on 20-SEP-2022
null2022-09-15Toronto Letter from Applicant dated 15-SEP-2022 This letter is in regards to the respondent's claim of privilege received on 15-SEP-2022
null2022-09-07TorontoToronto 07-SEP-2022 BEFORE The Honourable Mr. Justice Mosley Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: Parties discuss various matters held by way of Conference Call Duration per day: 07-SEP-2022 from 10:00 to 10:43 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Andrew Murray Total Duration: 43min Appearances: Ewa Krajewska N/A representing Applicant Bradon Chung N/A representing Applicant Christopher Rupar N/A representing Respondent John Provart N/A representing Respondent Kathleen Kohlman N/A representing Respondent Comments: DARS not used. Parties discuss various matters. Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1083 page(s) 121 - 122 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-08-25Toronto Letter from Intervenor dated 25-AUG-2022 This letter is in regards to the hearing dates. received on 25-AUG-2022
null2022-08-08TorontoOttawa 08-AUG-2022 BEFORE The Honourable Mr. Justice Mosley Language: E Before the Court: Motion Doc. No. 27 on behalf of Applicant withdrawn, Amended Notice of Motion doc. 38 in court file T-347-22 Result of Hearing: Matter reserved held by way of video conference via Zoom Duration per day: 08-AUG-2022 from 10:31 to 15:10 Courtroom : Ottawa (Zoom) Court Registrar: Beatriz Winter Total Duration: 4h 39min Appearances: Sujit Choudhry and Janani Shanmuganathan representing Applicant CCF (court file T-347-22) Ewa Krajewska and Brandon Chung representing Applicant Kathleen Kohlman and Christopher Rupar representing Respondent Comments: Hearing recorded with Zoom recording and TASCAM hand-recorder; hearing date of August 9, 2022 vacated. Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1082 page(s) 174 - 180 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-08-08Toronto Acknowledgment of Receipt received from all parties, and Applicant Canadian Frontline Nurses (T-306-22) and CCF with respect to Directions of the Presiding Judge dated 5-AUG-2022 placed on file on 08-AUG-2022
null2022-08-08Toronto Corrected Compendium of the Attorney General of Canada (Motions regarding Rule 317 Record and s. 39 of the CEA) received on 08-AUG-2022
null2022-08-08Toronto Copy of Compendium of the Canadian Civil Liberties Association received on 08-AUG-2022
null2022-08-08Toronto Copy of Compendium of the Canadian Constitution Foundation received on 08-AUG-2022
null2022-08-05Toronto Oral directions received from the presiding judge dated 05-AUG-2022 directing that "We will therefore follow the second option for the order and time allocations set out in Ms. Kohlman's email of earlier today. We will be dealing only with the CCF motion with limited submissions from the CCLA." placed on file on 05-AUG-2022 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
null2022-08-03Toronto S. 39 material received on 03-AUG-2022
null2022-08-05Toronto Communication to the Court from the Registry dated 05-AUG-2022 re: Applicant's letter dated 5-AUG-2022 (ID 86)
null2022-08-05Toronto Letter from Applicant dated 05-AUG-2022 on motions to be argued at hearing on 8-AUG-2022 received on 05-AUG-2022
null2022-08-05Toronto Letter from Respondent dated 05-AUG-2022 advising of parties discussions on timing for argument of the motions received on 05-AUG-2022
442022-08-05Ottawa Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Christopher Rupar confirming service of Compendium of the Attorney General of Canada upon all parties by email on 05-AUG-2022 filed on 05-AUG-2022
null2022-08-05Ottawa Compendium of the Attorney General of Canada (scanned to: Mosley, J.) received on 05-AUG-2022
null2022-08-04Toronto Oral directions received from the Court: The Honourable Mr. Justice Mosley dated 04-AUG-2022 directing that "The Court has read the summary prepared by Ms. Kohlman with input from counsel for the CCLA and CCF and it is generally in accord with the Court's notes and recollection of the August 2, 2022 case management conference call However, it is note clear to the Court that the material referenced in Ms. Kohlman's summary and provided to the Registry on Wednesday, August 3, 2022 includes all of the documents delivered to the Applicants on July 19 and July 22, 2022. Specifically, whether the material includes the Chair's Annotated Agendas for the IRG meetings of February 10, 12, and 13. The Court requests that counsel for the Attorney General clarify with the Registry that the material submitted includes all of the documents delivered to the Applicants. While the Court assumes that the material is now public as it has been delivered to counsel for the parties, the Registry has been instructed that it should be kept confidential until the hearing on Monday. It is expected that the documents will be placed on the public file subject to any comments that the parties may have at that time. Also to be clear, the Court has not granted leave to the CCF to bring additional motions to be argued on August 8-9, 2022 as requested in its Amended letter of July 22, 2022. Any additional motions that the parties may wish to bring will be dealt with after the motions currently scheduled to be heard on August 8th and 9th are dealt with." placed on file on 04-AUG-2022 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
null2022-08-02TorontoToronto 02-AUG-2022 BEFORE The Honourable Mr. Justice Mosley Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: Parties discuss the scope of the motions for August 8th and 9th held by way of Conference Call Duration per day: 02-AUG-2022 from 03:00 to 03:40 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Andrew Murray Total Duration: 40min Appearances: Ewa Krajewska N/A representing Applicant Bradon Chung N/A representing Applicant Christopher Rupar N/A representing Respondent Jeff Anderson N/A representing Respondent Kathleen Kohlman N/A representing Respondent Comments: DARS not used. The parties discuss the scope of what is being heard on August 8th and 9th Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1082 page(s) 73 - 74 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-07-25Toronto Letter from Respondent dated 25-JUL-2022 This letter is in response to the applicant's letter re: s. 39 received on 25-JUL-2022
null2022-07-22Toronto Letter from Applicant dated 22-JUL-2022 This letter provides a status update from the CCLA. received on 22-JUL-2022
432022-07-15TorontoOrder dated 15-JUL-2022 rendered by Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Matter considered with personal appearance The Court's decision is with regard to Motion Doc. No. 36 Result: granted in part Filed on 15-JUL-2022 copies sent to parties entered in J. & O. Book, volume 1547 page(s) 413 - 418 Interlocutory Decision
null2022-07-14TorontoToronto 14-JUL-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Motion Doc. No. 36 on behalf of Applicant Result of Hearing: Specific questions ordered answered held by way of video conference Duration per day: 14-JUL-2022 from 10:00 to 12:07 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Andrew Murray Total Duration: 2h 7min Appearances: Ewa Krajewska N/A representing Applicant Brandon Chung N/A representing Applicant David Aaron N/A representing Respondent Comments: Recorded on Zoom cloud. Various questions ordered answered Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1081 page(s) 351 - 352 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-07-13TorontoToronto 13-JUL-2022 BEFORE The Honourable Mr. Justice Mosley Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: Parties discuss the motions on the 18th and adjourn them to August 8th and 9 held by way of Conference Call Duration per day: 13-JUL-2022 from 03:00 to 03:32 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Andrew Murray Total Duration: 32min Appearances: Ewa Krajewska N/A representing Applicant Brandon Chung N/A representing Applicant Chris Rupar N/A representing Respondent Kathleen Kohlman N/A representing Respondent Comments: DARS not used. The parties agree to adjourn the motions originally set to be heard on July 18th to August 8th and 9th Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1081 page(s) 324 - 325 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
422022-07-12Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of David Aaron confirming service of Doc. 41 upon Applicant by e-mail on 12-JUL-2022 filed on 12-JUL-2022
412022-07-12Toronto Motion Record in response to Motion Doc. No. 36 containing the following original document(s): 39 40 Number of copies received: 1 on behalf of Respondent filed on 12-JUL-2022
402022-07-12Toronto Written Representations contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Respondent concerning Motion Doc. No. 36 filed on 12-JUL-2022
392022-07-12TorontoAffidavit of Barbara Brzezicki sworn on 11-JUL-2022 contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Respondent in opposition to Motion Doc. No. 36 with Exhibits A-B filed on 12-JUL-2022
null2022-07-05Toronto Oral directions received from the Court: Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary dated 30-JUN-2022 directing that further to the case conference held 30-JUN-2022: 1) motions scheduled for 5-JUL-2022 on T-316/347/382-22 are adjourned to 18-JUL-2022 to begin at 10:00. AGC responding materials due 14-JUL-2022; 2) motions to compel Beaudoin (T-316/382-22) shall be heard 14-JUL-2022 at 10:00 for a duration of one-half day. AGC responding materials due 12-JUL-2022 at noon; 3) with respect to AGC motions to strike any of the applications on the grounds of standing or mootness, AGC supplmental motion records to be filed by 31-AUG-2022. Responding motion records to be filed on same date as respondents' application records are due. placed on file on 05-JUL-2022 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
null2022-06-30Ottawa Oral directions received from the Court: K. Trudeau, Judicial Administrator dated 30-JUN-2022 directing that ¿Parties are advised to remain available for a hearing on the merits from October 17 to 21 and November 14 to 18, 2022. An Order scheduling the hearing on the merits will follow in due course.¿ placed on file on 30-JUN-2022
null2022-06-30Toronto Copy of minutes of Hearing dated 30-JUN-2022 placed on file on 30-JUN-2022 Original placed on Court File No. T-306-22
382022-06-29TorontoAffidavit of service of Mary Arulnesan sworn on 29-JUN-2022 on behalf of Applicant confirming service of Doc. No. 37 upon Respondent by email on 29-JUN-2022 filed on 29-JUN-2022
372022-06-29Toronto Motion Record containing the following original document(s): 36 Number of copies received: 1 on behalf of Applicant filed on 29-JUN-2022
362022-06-29TorontoNotice of Motion contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Applicant returnable at Special Sitting in Toronto on 14-JUL-2022 to begin at 10:00 for an Order to compel answers refused on cross-exam of Denis Beaudoin on 21-JUN-2022 filed on 29-JUN-2022
352022-06-29Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Kathleen Kohlman confirming service of doc. 34 upon Applicant by email on 29-JUN-2022 filed on 29-JUN-2022
342022-06-29Toronto Motion Record in response to Motion Doc. No. 27 Number of copies received: 1 on behalf of Respondent filed on 29-JUN-2022
332022-06-29Toronto Written Representations contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Respondent concerning Motion Doc. No. 27 filed on 29-JUN-2022
322022-06-28TorontoAffidavit of service of Mary Arulnesan sworn on 28-JUN-2022 on behalf of Applicant confirming service of Doc. 31 upon Respondent by e-mail on 28-JUN-2022 with Exhibits A filed on 28-JUN-2022
312022-06-28Toronto Motion Record containing the following original document(s): 27 28 29 30 Number of copies received: 1 on behalf of Applicant filed on 28-JUN-2022
302022-06-28Toronto Written Representations contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Applicant concerning Motion Doc. No. 27 filed on 28-JUN-2022
292022-06-28Toronto Transcript of cross examination contained within Motion Record in support of Doc. 27  RE: Affidavit of Steven Shragge sworn 04-APR-2022, held on 15-JUN-2022 filed on 28-JUN-2022
282022-06-28Toronto Transcript of cross examination contained within Motion Record in support of Doc. 27 RE: Affidavit of Steven Shragge sworn 04-APR-2022, held on 19-MAY-2022 filed on 28-JUN-2022
272022-06-28TorontoNotice of Motion contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Applicant returnable at Special Sitting in Toronto on 05-JUL-2022 to begin at 09:30 for Rulings on the objections made by the Respondent, AGC, to the document requests listed in the CCLA's May 12, 2022, Direction to Attend to Steven Shragge; and other relief filed on 28-JUN-2022
null2022-06-22TorontoToronto 22-JUN-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: The parties are on track for the Motion July 5, 2022; a further Case Management Conference to take place June 30, 2022 held by way of Conference Call Duration per day: 22-JUN-2022 from 11:03 to 11:23 Courtroom : Toronto (Zoom) Court Registrar: Monica Mecca Total Duration: 21min Appearances: Ewa Krajewska, Brandon Chung NA representing Applicant Alexander Boissonneau-Lehner, David Cowling, MacKenzie Campbell NA representing Applicants (T-306-22) Sujit Choudhry, Janani Shanmuganathan NA representing Applicant (T-347-22) Brendan Miller, Blair Ector, Bath-Sheba van den Berg NA representing Applicants (T-382-22) Jeff Anderson, John Provart, Kathleen Kohlman NA representing Respondent Mandy England, Leah McDaniel, Shaheer Meenai NA representing Intervenor Comments: Recorded via Zoom Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1080 page(s) 455 - 456 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-05-25TorontoToronto 25-MAY-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: minutes found on T-306-22 held by way of video conference Duration per day: 25-MAY-2022 from 11:00 to 12:00 Courtroom : Toronto (Zoom) Court Registrar: Shaun Nelson Total Duration: 1h Appearances: Mr. Chung, Mr. Gourlay, Ms. Krajewska na representing Applicant Mr. Anderson, Mr. Provart, Ms. Kohlman na representing Respondent Ms. England, Ms. McDaniel, Ms. Meenai na representing Intervenor Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1079 page(s) 356 - 357 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-05-09TorontoToronto 09-MAY-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: Parties discuss expert timelines held by way of Conference Call by way of video conference Duration per day: 09-MAY-2022 from 11:00 to 11:40 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Andrew Murray Total Duration: 40min Appearances: Eva Krajewska N/A representing Applicant Jeff Anderson N/A representing Respondent Kathleen Kohlman N/A representing Respondent Leah McDaniel N/A representing Respondent Mandy England N/A representing Respondent Comments: Recorded on Zoom. Parties discuss expert report timelines. Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1078 page(s) 223 - 224 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
262022-05-05TorontoOrder dated 05-MAY-2022 rendered by Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Matter considered without personal appearance The Court's decision is with regard to Motion Doc. No. 21 Result: granted Filed on 05-MAY-2022 copies sent to parties entered in J. & O. Book, volume 1537 page(s) 361 - 366 Interlocutory Decision
null2022-05-04TorontoCopy of oral direction dated 04-MAY-2022 rendered by Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary placed on file. Original filed on Court File No. T-306-22
null2022-05-02Toronto Letter from Applicant dated 02-MAY-2022 This letter requests the CMC on May 4th to go ahead received on 02-MAY-2022
null2022-04-29Toronto Copy of a letter on behalf of Respondent dated 28-APR-2022 placed on file on 29-APR-2022 Original placed on Court File No. T-306-22
null2022-04-28Toronto Copy of a letter on behalf of Respondent dated 28-APR-2022 placed on file on 28-APR-2022 Original placed on Court File No. T-306-22
null2022-04-11TorontoToronto 11-APR-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: minutes found on T-306-22 held by way of video conference Duration per day: 11-APR-2022 from 11:05 to 12:25 Courtroom : Toronto (Zoom) Court Registrar: Shaun Nelson Total Duration: 1h 20min Appearances: Matthew Gourlay na representing Applicant Jeff Anderson, John Provart na representing Respondent Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1078 page(s) 62 - 63 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-04-25Toronto Copy of a letter on behalf of Respondent dated 25-APR-2022 placed on file on 25-APR-2022 Original placed on Court File No. T-306-22
252022-04-14Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Shaheer Meenai, confirming service of doc 24 upon all parties by EMAil on 14-APR-2022 filed on 14-APR-2022
242022-04-14Toronto Motion Record containing the following original document(s): 21 22 23 Number of copies received: 1 on behalf of the Attorney General of Alberta (¿AG of Alberta¿) filed on 14-APR-2022
232022-04-14Toronto Written Representations contained within a Motion Record on behalf of the Attorney General of Alberta (¿AG of Alberta¿) concerning Motion in writing Doc. No. 21 filed on 14-APR-2022
222022-04-14TorontoAffidavit of DEPUTY CHIEF ROBERT ANDREWS sworn on 14-APR-2022 contained within a Motion Record on behalf of the Attorney General of Alberta (¿AG of Alberta¿) in support of Motion Doc. No. 19 filed on 14-APR-2022
212022-04-14TorontoNotice of Motion contained within a Motion Record on behalf of the Attorney General of Alberta (¿AG of Alberta¿) in writing to be dealt with in the Toronto local office for an Order adding the AG of Alberta as an intervener in these proceedings filed on 14-APR-2022
null2022-04-21Toronto Copy of a letter on behalf of Respondent dated 21-APR-2022 placed on file on 21-APR-2022 Original placed on Court File No. T-306-22
null2022-04-20Toronto Copy of a letter on behalf of Respondent dated 19-APR-2022 placed on file on 20-APR-2022 Original placed on Court File No. T-306-22
null2022-04-19TorontoCopy of oral direction dated 19-APR-2022 dated 19-APR-2022 rendered by Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary placed on file. Original filed on Court File No. T-306-22
202022-04-14TorontoAffidavit of service of Dana Beshok sworn on 13-APR-2022 on behalf of Applicant confirming service of NoCQ upon various AGs by email on 13-APR-2022 with Exhibits A filed on 14-APR-2022
192022-04-14TorontoAffidavit of service of Jessica Anderson sworn on 13-APR-2022 on behalf of Applicant confirming service of NoCQ upon Various AGs by email on 13-APR-2022 with Exhibits A filed on 14-APR-2022
182022-04-14Toronto Notice of a constitutional question on behalf of Applicant filed on 14-APR-2022
null2022-04-14Toronto Letter from Applicant dated 14-APR-2022 This letter provides a status update and a position on the AG of Albertas intervention received on 14-APR-2022
null2022-04-13Toronto Letter from AG of Alberta dated 13-APR-2022 This letter states that they have received a notice of constitutional question in regards to the above noted matter. received on 13-APR-2022
null2022-04-12Toronto Copy of a letter on behalf of Respondent dated 12-APR-2022 placed on file on 12-APR-2022 Original placed on Court File No. T-306-22
null2022-04-12Toronto Copy of Motion Record on behalf of Respondent dated 12-APR-2022 placed on file on 12-APR-2022 Original filed on Court File No. T-306-22
null2022-04-12TorontoCopy of Oral directions dated 12-APR-2022 dated 12-APR-2022 rendered by Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary placed on file. Original filed on Court File No. T-306-22
172022-04-08TorontoAffidavit of service of Luke Woulfe sworn on 08-APR-2022 on behalf of Intervenor confirming service of doc 15 & 16 upon all parties by e-mail on 08-APR-2022 with Exhibits A-D filed on 08-APR-2022
162022-04-08TorontoAffidavit of Robert Andrews sworn on 07-APR-2022 on behalf of Intervenor in support of Motion Doc. No. 15 filed on 08-APR-2022
152022-04-08TorontoNotice of Motion on behalf of Intervenor in writing to be dealt with in the Toronto local office for an Order for leave to intervene on behalf of the Attorney General of Alberta filed on 08-APR-2022
null2022-04-11Toronto Letter from Proposed intervenor dated 11-APR-2022 This letter outlines when they will be submitting their full motion record received on 11-APR-2022
142022-04-05Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Nur Muhammed Ally confirming service of Doc 13 upon Applicant by email on 04-APR-2022 filed on 05-APR-2022
132022-04-05TorontoAffidavit of Rebecca Coleman sworn on 04-APR-2022 on behalf of Respondent in opposition to Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A-RRRRR filed on 05-APR-2022
122022-04-04Ottawa Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Kathleen Kohlman confirming service of the Affidavit of Steven Shragge upon Applicant by e-mail on 04-APR-2022 filed on 04-APR-2022
112022-04-04OttawaAffidavit of Steven Shragge sworn on 04-APR-2022 on behalf of Respondent in opposition to Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A-D filed on 04-APR-2022
102022-04-04OttawaAffidavit of Denis Beaudoin sworn on 04-APR-2022 on behalf of Respondent in opposition to Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A-D filed on 04-APR-2022
92022-04-04Ottawa Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Kathleen Kohlman confirming service of the Affidavit of Denis Beaudoin upon Applicant by e-mail on 04-APR-2022 filed on 04-APR-2022
null2022-04-01Toronto Letter from Proposed intervener dated 01-APR-2022 This letter states that they have been served with a NOCQ, and requests to attend the next CMC on April 11th received on 01-APR-2022
null2022-03-25TorontoToronto 25-MAR-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: Parties discuss r. 317 material held by way of video conference Duration per day: 25-MAR-2022 from 11:00 to 11:32 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Andrew Murray Total Duration: 32min Appearances: Matthew Gourlay N/A representing Applicant John Provart N/A representing Respondent Jeff Anderson N/A representing Respondent Comments: Recorded on zoom cloud. Parties discuss r. 317 material Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1076 page(s) 350 - 351 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-03-11TorontoToronto 11-MAR-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: minutes found on T-306-22 held by way of video conference Duration per day: 11-MAR-2022 from 10:00 to 11:00 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Shaun Nelson Total Duration: 1h Appearances: Ewa Krajewska, Matthew Gourlay na representing Applicant John Provart, Jeff Anderson na representing Respondent Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1076 page(s) 335 - 336 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-03-23Toronto Oral directions received from the Court: Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary dated 23-MAR-2022 directing that "A case management teleconference shall be conducted on Friday March 25, 2022 at 11am by Zoom. The purpose of the call is to discuss the Rule 317 requests, responses and next steps. If any party has anything to add to the correspondence already submitted, they shall file their submissions by 3pm March 24th" placed on file on 23-MAR-2022 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
null2022-03-11TorontoCopy of Oral Direction dated 11-MAR-2022 rendered by Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary concerning Schedule placed on file. Original filed on Court File No. T-306-22
null2022-03-07Toronto Letter from Possible intervenor dated 07-MAR-2022 This document states that the AG of Alberta will be filing a motion to intervene. received on 07-MAR-2022
82022-03-04TorontoAffidavit of service of Mary Arulnesan sworn on 04-MAR-2022 on behalf of Applicant confirming service of Doc 7 upon Respondent by email on 04-MAR-2022 with Exhibits A filed on 04-MAR-2022
72022-03-04TorontoAffidavit of Abigail Deshman sworn on 04-MAR-2022 on behalf of Applicant in support of Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A-JJ filed on 04-MAR-2022
null2022-03-02Ottawa Letter from Respondent dated 02-MAR-2022 "Please provide this correspondence to the Case Management Judges... Further to the Direction of Prothonotary Milczynski, dated February 25, 2022..." received on 02-MAR-2022
62022-02-28Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of John Provart confirming service of Notice of Appearance upon Applicant by email on 22-FEB-2022 filed on 28-FEB-2022
52022-02-28Toronto Notice of appearance on behalf of Respondent filed on 28-FEB-2022
null2022-02-23Toronto Oral directions received from the Court: Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary dated 23-FEB-2022 directing that "Further to the case management teleconference conducted this day: -the Respondent shall provide an update regarding any preliminary issues (standing and mootness) by March 2, 2022; -in respect of T-306-22, the Respondent shall deliver a response to the Applicants' Rule 317 request within 20 days; -in respect of T-306-22 and T-316-22: the Applicants shall serve and file their rule 306 evidence by March 4, 2022 and the Respondent shall serve and file their Rule 307 evidence within 30 days of the date of service of the Applicants affidavits; -a case management teleconference is scheduled for Friday March 11, 2022 at 10am; and -the parties may at anytime requistion a case management teleconference by submitting their dates and times of mutual availability." placed on file on 23-FEB-2022 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
null2022-02-23TorontoToronto 23-FEB-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: Parties discuss schedule held by way of video conference Duration per day: 23-FEB-2022 from 10:00 to 10:27 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Andrew Murray Total Duration: 27min Appearances: Matthew Gourlay N/A representing Applicant John Provart N/A representing Respondent Jeff Anderson N/A representing Respondent Comments: Recorded on zoom cloud. Parties discuss schedule. Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1075 page(s) 167 - 168 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-02-21Toronto Letter from Applicant dated 21-FEB-2022 requesting leave to particpate in the CMC scheduled for Feb. 23 2022 in file T-306-22. received on 21-FEB-2022
null2022-02-21Toronto Oral directions received from the Court: Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary dated 21-FEB-2022 directing that "A case management conference shall be conducted by zoom on Wednesday February 23, 2023 at 10am. The purpose of the cmc is to discuss a schedule for the next steps and the hearing of the application." placed on file on 21-FEB-2022 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
null2022-02-21Ottawa Acknowledgment of Receipt received from both parties with respect to Doc 4 placed on file on 21-FEB-2022
42022-02-21OttawaOrder dated 21-FEB-2022 rendered by Chief Justice Crampton Matter considered without personal appearance The Court's decision is with regard to Motion ex proprio motu Result: "IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT: 1. This proceeding shall continue as a specially managed proceeding. 2. Pursuant to Rule 383, Justice Richard G. Mosley and Prothonotary Martha Milczynski are assigned as Case Management Judges in this matter." Filed on 21-FEB-2022 copies sent to parties entered in J. & O. Book, volume 1527 page(s) 404 - 405 Interlocutory Decision
32022-02-21Toronto Acknowledgment of Receipt received from Respondent with respect to doc 1 filed on 21-FEB-2022
22022-02-18Toronto****** CANCELLED ****** Acknowledgment of Receipt received from Respondent with respect to doc 1 filed on 18-FEB-2022
12022-02-18Toronto Notice of application with regard to Judicial Review (s.18) filed on 18-FEB-2022 Certified copy(ies)/copy(ies) transmitted to Deputy Attorney General of Canada Tariff fee of $50.00 received: yes

 

Additional information on :  T-347-22

Type :  Federal Court

Nature of Cause :  S. 18.1 Application for Judicial Review

Office :  Toronto     Language :  English

Type of Action :  Non-Action

Filing Date :  2022-02-23

Party Information:

Party NameSolicitorLawyer(s) / file no
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF CANADA - -
Canadian Constitution FoundationSUJIT CHOUDHRYCHOUDHRY, SUJIT

Related Cases:

Court Number Style of Cause Nature of Proceeding
A-180-22Canadian Constitution Foundation v. Attorney General of CanadaS. 18.1 Application for Judicial Review

 

Recorded Entry Information :   T-347-22

Type :  Federal Court

Nature of Proceeding :  S. 18.1 Application for Judicial Review

Office :  Toronto     Language :  English

Type of Action :  Federal Court

Filing Date :  2022-02-23

Recorded Entry Summary Information

Certain public documents in some proceedings are now available for online access in accordance with the Federal Court’s Online Access to Court Records – Pilot Project. These documents are identified with a download icon () in the Download column below.

You may obtain copies of other public documents by contacting the Registry. Copies of public documents which are already in electronic format can be sent by e-mail, upon request to the Registry: fc_reception_cf@cas-satj.gc.ca. Indicate the Court File number in the subject of your email. In the text, you must clearly identify the document number and its name (this information is located in the Recorded Entry Summary column).

The availability of documents from the Registry, including through online access, does not grant a copyright licence or permission. Your use of such materials must be in accordance with the Copyright Act, RSC 1985, c C-42.

112 records found
DocDate FiledOfficeRecorded Entry SummaryDownload
null2022-10-05TorontoToronto 05-OCT-2022 BEFORE The Honourable Mr. Justice Mosley Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: Parties discuss scheduling various motions and hearings held by way of Conference Call Duration per day: 05-OCT-2022 from 03:00 to 03:56 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Andrew Murray Total Duration: 56min Appearances: Sujit Choudhry N/A representing Applicant Janani Shanmuganathan N/A representing Applicant John Provart N/A representing Respondent Kathleen Kohlman N/A representing Respondent Mandy England N/A representing Intervenor Leah McDaniel N/A representing Intervenor Comments: DARS not used. The parties discuss scheduling various matters. Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1084 page(s) 310 - 311 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-09-21Toronto Letter from Respondent dated 21-SEP-2022 This letter is in response to the applicant's letter of Sept 20 received on 21-SEP-2022
null2022-09-20Toronto Letter from Applicant dated 20-SEP-2022 This letter is in regards to the ongoing redactions from the GC received on 20-SEP-2022
null2022-09-15Toronto Letter from Respondent dated 15-SEP-2022 This letter provides a status update regarding the s. 37 matter received on 15-SEP-2022
null2022-09-09Toronto Letter from Respondent dated 09-SEP-2022 providing dates of availability for 2 day hearing of the merits of this matter.... received on 09-SEP-2022
null2022-09-09OttawaCopy of Notice of Appeal (Appeal Court File No. A-180-22 ) appealing the Judgment rendered by Mr. Justice Mosley dated August 26, 2022 filed in the Court of Appeal on 06-SEP-2022 on behalf of Plaintiff placed on file on 09-SEP-2022
null2022-09-09Toronto Letter from Applicant dated 09-SEP-2022 providing dates of availability for 2-day hearing on the matter received on 09-SEP-2022
null2022-09-07TorontoToronto 07-SEP-2022 BEFORE The Honourable Mr. Justice Mosley Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: Various matters discussed held by way of Conference Call Duration per day: 07-SEP-2022 from 10:00 to 10:43 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Andrew Murray Total Duration: 43min Appearances: Sujit Choudhry N/A representing Applicant Janani Shanmuganathan N/A representing Applicant Christopher Rupar N/A representing Respondent John Provart N/A representing Respondent Kathleen Kohlman N/A representing Respondent Comments: DARS not used. Various matters discussed Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1083 page(s) 123 - 124 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-08-26Ottawa Acknowledgment of Receipt received from the AGC with respect to the Orders and Reasons (Mosley,J) dated August 26, 2022 placed on file on 26-AUG-2022
null2022-08-26Ottawa Acknowledgment of Receipt received from Intervenor with respect to the Orders and Reasons rendered by Mr. Justice Mosley on August 26, 2022. placed on file on 26-AUG-2022
null2022-08-26Ottawa Acknowledgment of Receipt received from Applicant with respect to the Orders and Reasons rendered by Mr. Justice Mosley on August 26, 2022. placed on file on 26-AUG-2022
502022-08-26OttawaReasons Order and Reasons dated 26-AUG-2022 rendered by The Honourable Mr. Justice Mosley Matter considered with personal appearance The Court's decision is with regard to Motion Doc. No. 26 Result: 1.The Motion for a declaration that the Governor in Council's Response to the Applicant's Rule 317 Request is incomplete is dismissed; 2.The motion for an Order that the Respondent shall deliver unredacted versions of the records described in the Section 39 Certificates on a counsel-only basis and subject to undertakings is dismissed; 3.The Respondent shall advise the Court and the parties in this matter, and the related judicial review applications, within 14 days of the receipt of this Order whether it intends to maintain claims of privilege under Sections 37 and 38 of the Canada Evidence Act in the disclosed materials; 4.The Court will convene a case management conference with counsel upon receipt of the Respondent's position to discuss next steps in this and the related proceedings; and 5. No costs are awarded. Filed on 26-AUG-2022 copies sent to parties Interlocutory Decision Certificate of Order entered in J. & O. Book, volume 1553 page(s) 494 - 495
492022-08-26OttawaReasons Order and Reasons dated 26-AUG-2022 rendered by The Honourable Mr. Justice Mosley Matter considered with personal appearance The Court's decision is with regard to Motion Doc. No. 13 Result: dismissed No costs are awarded Filed on 26-AUG-2022 copies sent to parties Interlocutory Decision Certificate of Order entered in J. & O. Book, volume 1553 page(s) 491 - 491
null2022-08-25Toronto Letter from Intervenor dated 25-AUG-2022 This letter is in regards to the hearing dates. received on 25-AUG-2022
null2022-08-03Toronto S. 39 material sent by the DOJ received on 03-AUG-2022
null2022-08-08Toronto Acknowledgment of Receipt received from all parties, and Applicants Canadian Frontline Nurses (T-306-22) and CCLA with respect to Directions of the Presiding Judge dated 5-AUG-2022 placed on file on 08-AUG-2022
null2022-08-08Toronto Corrected Compendium of the Attorney General of Canada (Motions regarding Rule 317 Record and s. 39 of the CEA) received on 08-AUG-2022
null2022-08-05Toronto Oral directions received from the presiding judge dated 05-AUG-2022 directing that "We will therefore follow the second option for the order and time allocations set out in Ms. Kohlman's email of earlier today. We will be dealing only with the CCF motion with limited submissions from CCLA." placed on file on 05-AUG-2022 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
null2022-08-08TorontoOttawa 08-AUG-2022 BEFORE The Honourable Mr. Justice Mosley Language: E Before the Court: Motion Doc. No. 26 on behalf of Applicant Amended Notice of Motion doc. 38 Result of Hearing: Matter reserved held by way of video conference via Zoom Duration per day: 08-AUG-2022 from 10:31 to 15:10 Courtroom : Ottawa (Zoom) Court Registrar: Beatriz Winter Total Duration: 4h 39min Appearances: Sujit Choudhry and Janani Shanmuganathan representing Applicant Ewa Krajewska and Brandon Chung representing CCLA, Applicant at court file T-316-22 Kathleen Kohlman and Christopher Rupar representing Respondent Comments: Hearing recorded with Zoom recording and TASCAM hand recorder; hearing date of August 9, 2022 vacated. Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1082 page(s) 167 - 173 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-08-08Toronto Compendium of the Canadian Civil Liberties Association received on 08-AUG-2022
null2022-08-08Toronto Compendium of the Canadian Constitution Foundation received on 08-AUG-2022
null2022-08-05Toronto Communication to the Court from the Registry dated 05-AUG-2022 re: letter dated 5-AUG-2022 (ID 90)
null2022-08-05Toronto Copy of a Letter from Applicant CCLA (court file T-316-22) dated 05-AUG-2022 on motions to be argued at hearing on 8-AUG-2022 received on 05-AUG-2022
null2022-08-05Toronto Letter from Respondent dated 05-AUG-2022 advising of parties discussions on timing for argument of the motions received on 05-AUG-2022
482022-08-05Ottawa Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Christopher Rupar confirming service of Compendium of the Attorney General of Canada upon all parties by email on 05-AUG-2022 filed on 05-AUG-2022
null2022-08-05Ottawa Compendium of the Attorney General of Canada (scanned to: Mosley, J.) received on 05-AUG-2022
null2022-08-04Toronto Copy of a set of oral directions from Justice Mosley dated 04-AUG-2022 oral directions placed on file on 04-AUG-2022 Original placed on Court File No. T-316-22
null2022-08-02TorontoToronto 02-AUG-2022 BEFORE The Honourable Mr. Justice Mosley Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: Parties discuss the scope of the August 8th and 9th motions held by way of Conference Call Duration per day: 02-AUG-2022 from 03:00 to 03:40 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Andrew Murray Total Duration: 40min Appearances: Sujit Choudhry N/A representing Applicant Christopher Rupar N/A representing Respondent Jeff Anderson N/A representing Respondent Kathleen Kohlman N/A representing Respondent Comments: DARS not used. The parties discuss the scope of what is to be argued on August 8th and 9th Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1082 page(s) 75 - 76 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-07-25Toronto Letter from Respondent dated 25-JUL-2022 This letter is in response to the applicant's response re: s. 39 received on 25-JUL-2022
null2022-07-22Toronto Letter from Applicant dated 22-JUL-2022 This letter provides an update as to the status of proceedings. Suggests additional motions be brought forward and an amicus curiae be appointed. received on 22-JUL-2022
null2022-07-13TorontoToronto 13-JUL-2022 BEFORE The Honourable Mr. Justice Mosley Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: The parties agree to adjourn the motion currently scheduled for July 18th. held by way of Conference Call Duration per day: 13-JUL-2022 from 03:00 to 03:32 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Andrew Murray Total Duration: 32min Appearances: Sujit Choudhry N/A representing Applicant Janani Shanmuganathan N/A representing Applicant Chris Rupar N/A representing Respondent Kathleen Kohlman N/A representing Respondent Mandy England N/A representing Intervenor Leah McDaniel N/A representing Intervenor Comments: DARS not used. The parties agree to adjourn the hearings currently scheduled for July 18th to August 8th and 9th Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1081 page(s) 326 - 327 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-07-05Toronto Copy of oral direction ID 71 dated 30-JUN-2022 placed on file on 05-JUL-2022 Original placed on Court File No. T-316-22
null2022-06-30Ottawa Oral directions received from the Court: K. Trudeau, Judicial Administrator dated 30-JUN-2022 directing that ¿Parties are advised to remain available for a hearing on the merits from October 17 to 21 and November 14 to 18, 2022. An Order scheduling the hearing on the merits will follow in due course.¿ placed on file on 30-JUN-2022
null2022-06-30Toronto Copy of minutes of Hearing dated 30-JUN-2022 placed on file on 30-JUN-2022 Original placed on Court File No. T-306-22
null2022-06-22TorontoToronto 22-JUN-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: The parties are on track for the Motion July 5, 2022; a further Case Management Conference to take place June 30, 2022 held by way of Conference Call Duration per day: 22-JUN-2022 from 11:02 to 11:21 Courtroom : Toronto (Zoom) Court Registrar: Monica Mecca Total Duration: 21min Appearances: Sujit Choudhry, Janani Shanmuganathan NA representing Applicant Alexander Boissonneau-Lehner, David Cowling, MacKenzie Campbell NA representing Applicants (T-306-22) Ewa Krajewska, Brandon Chung NA representing Applicant (T-316-22) Brendan Miller, Blair Ector, Bath-Sheba van den Berg NA representing Applicants (T-382-22) Jeff Anderson, John Provart, Kathleen Kohlman NA representing Respondent Mandy England, Leah McDaniel, Shaheer Meenai NA representing Intervenor Comments: Recoreded via Zoom Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1080 page(s) 457 - 458 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-05-25TorontoToronto 25-MAY-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: minutes found on T-306-22 held by way of video conference Duration per day: 25-MAY-2022 from 11:00 to 12:00 Courtroom : Toronto (Zoom) Court Registrar: Shaun Nelson Total Duration: 1h Appearances: Mr. Choudhry na representing Applicant Mr. Anderson, Mr. Provart, Ms. Kohlman na representing Respondent Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1079 page(s) 358 - 359 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
472022-05-25Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Kathleen Kohlman confirming service of doc. 46 upon Applicant by email on 25-MAY-2022 filed on 25-MAY-2022
462022-05-25Toronto Motion Record containing the following original document(s): 44 45 Number of copies received: 1 on behalf of Respondent, in response to Applicant's Motion doc. 38, filed on 25-MAY-2022
452022-05-25Toronto Written Representations contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Respondent concerning in opposition to Applicant's Motion doc. 38 filed on 25-MAY-2022
442022-05-25TorontoAffidavit of Steven Shragge sworn on 04-APR-2022 contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Respondent in opposition to Motion Doc. No. 38 with Exhibits A to D filed on 25-MAY-2022
null2022-05-09TorontoToronto 09-MAY-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: Parties discuss expert report timelines held by way of video conference Duration per day: 09-MAY-2022 from 11:00 to 11:40 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Andrew Murray Total Duration: 40min Appearances: Janani Shanmuganathan N/A representing Applicant Jeff Anderson N/A representing Respondent Kathleen Kohlman N/A representing Respondent Leah McDaniel N/A representing Respondent Mandy England N/A representing Respondent Comments: Recorded on Zoom. Parties discuss expert report timelines. Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1078 page(s) 225 - 226 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
432022-05-05TorontoOrder dated 05-MAY-2022 rendered by Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Matter considered without personal appearance The Court's decision is with regard to Motion Doc. No. 27 Result: granted Filed on 05-MAY-2022 copies sent to parties entered in J. & O. Book, volume 1537 page(s) 367 - 372 Interlocutory Decision
null2022-05-04TorontoCopy of oral direction dated 04-MAY-2022 rendered by Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary placed on file. Original filed on Court File No. T-306-22
422022-04-29TorontoAffidavit of service of Janani Shanmuganathan sworn on 29-APR-2022 on behalf of Applicant confirming service of doc 41 upon Respondent by EMAIL on 09-APR-2022 with Exhibits A filed on 29-APR-2022
412022-04-29Toronto Motion Record containing the following original document(s): 38 39 40 Number of copies received: 1 on behalf of moving party filed on 29-APR-2022
402022-04-29TorontoAffidavit of Madeleine Ross sworn on 22-APR-2022 on behalf of Applicant in support of motion doc 38 filed on 29-APR-2022
392022-04-29Toronto Written Representations on behalf of MOVING PARTY concerning motion doc 38 filed on 29-APR-2022
382022-04-29Toronto Amended Notice of motion on behalf of the Moving Party filed on 29-APR-2022
null2022-04-29Toronto Copy of a letter on behalf of Respondent dated 28-APR-2022 placed on file on 29-APR-2022 Original placed on Court File No. T-306-22
null2022-04-28Toronto Copy of a letter on behalf of Respondent dated 28-APR-2022 placed on file on 28-APR-2022 Original placed on Court File No. T-306-22
null2022-04-11TorontoToronto 11-APR-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: minutes found on T-306-22 held by way of video conference Duration per day: 11-APR-2022 from 11:05 to 12:25 Courtroom : Toronto (Zoom) Court Registrar: Shaun Nelson Total Duration: 1h 20min Appearances: Sujit Chaudhry, Janani Shanmuganathan na representing Applicant John Provart, Jeff Anderson na representing Respondent Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1078 page(s) 64 - 65 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-04-25Toronto Copy of a letter on behalf of Respondent dated 25-APR-2022 placed on file on 25-APR-2022 Original placed on Court File No. T-306-22
null2022-04-21Toronto Copy of a letter on behalf of Respondent dated 21-APR-2022 placed on file on 21-APR-2022 Original placed on Court File No. T-306-22
null2022-04-20Toronto Copy of a letter on behalf of Respondent dated 19-APR-2022 placed on file on 20-APR-2022 Original placed on Court File No. T-306-22
372022-04-14Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Shaheer Meenai confirming service of Doc 36 upon all parties by email on 14-APR-2022 filed on 14-APR-2022
362022-04-14Toronto Motion Record containing the following original document(s): 27 34 35 Number of copies received: 1 on behalf of proposed intervenor filed on 14-APR-2022
352022-04-14Toronto Written Representations contained within a Motion Record on behalf of proposed intervenor concerning Motion Doc. No. 27 filed on 14-APR-2022
342022-04-14TorontoAffidavit of Robert Andrews sworn on 07-APR-2022 contained within a Motion Record on behalf of proposed intervenor in support of Motion Doc. No. 27 filed on 14-APR-2022
null2022-04-19TorontoCopy of oral direction dated 19-APR-2022 dated 19-APR-2022 rendered by Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary placed on file. Original filed on Court File No. T-306-22
332022-04-13Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Ayesha Laldin confirming service of Doc 32 upon Applicant by email on 13-APR-2022 filed on 13-APR-2022
322022-04-13Toronto Motion Record in response to Motion Doc. No. 13 containing the following original document(s): 31 Number of copies received: 1 on behalf of Respondent filed on 13-APR-2022
312022-04-13Toronto Written Representations contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Respondent concerning Motion Doc. No. 13 filed on 13-APR-2022
null2022-04-12Toronto Copy of a letter on behalf of Respondent dated 12-APR-2022 placed on file on 12-APR-2022 Original placed on Court File No. T-306-22
null2022-04-12Toronto Copy of Motion Record on behalf of Respondent dated 12-APR-2022 placed on file on 12-APR-2022 Original filed on Court File No. T-306-22
302022-04-12TorontoAmended Notice of Motion on behalf of Applicant in writing to be dealt with in the Toronto local office for an Order declaring that the Responding party (AGC) has delivered an incomplete rec ord in response to the Rule 317 request. filed on 12-APR-2022
null2022-04-12TorontoCopy of Oral directions dated 12-APR-2022 dated 12-APR-2022 rendered by Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary placed on file. Original filed on Court File No. T-306-22
null2022-04-11Toronto Letter from Proposed intervenor dated 11-APR-2022 This letter gives the timeline for their motion material received on 11-APR-2022
292022-04-08TorontoAffidavit of service of L. Woulfe sworn on 08-APR-2022 on behalf of Intervenor confirming service of doc 27 & 28 upon Plaintiff Defendant by e-mail on 08-APR-2022 with Exhibits A-D filed on 08-APR-2022
282022-04-08TorontoAffidavit of Robert Andrews sworn on 07-APR-2022 on behalf of Intervener (AG of Alberta) in support of doc 27 filed on 08-APR-2022
272022-04-08TorontoNotice of Motion on behalf of Attorney General of Alberta in writing to be dealt with in the Toronto local office for an Order for leave to intervene filed on 08-APR-2022
262022-04-08TorontoNotice of Motion on behalf of Applicant in writing to be dealt with in the Toronto local office for an Order for a declaration that the Responding party (AGC) has violated Section 39 of the Canada Evidence Act. filed on 08-APR-2022
null2022-04-05Toronto Oral directions received from the Court: Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary dated 05-APR-2022 directing that "The matters raised by counsel for the Applicant in T-347-22 in their email of April 4, 2022 (proposed motion in respect of the CEA section 39 certificate) shall be discussed on the case management teleconference on April 11, 2022. Counsel may, however, submit their notice of motion ahead of the CMC so as to facilitate discussion." placed on file on 05-APR-2022 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
252022-04-05Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Nur Muhammed Ally confirming service of Doc 24 upon Applicant by email on 04-APR-2022 filed on 05-APR-2022
242022-04-05TorontoAffidavit of Rebecca Coleman sworn on 04-APR-2022 on behalf of Respondent in opposition to Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A-RRRRR filed on 05-APR-2022
232022-04-04OttawaAffidavit of service of Kathleen Kohlman sworn on 04-APR-2022 on behalf of Respondent confirming service of the Affidavit of Steven Shragge upon Applicant by e-mail on 04-APR-2022 with Exhibits A-D filed on 04-APR-2022
222022-04-04OttawaAffidavit of Steven Shragge sworn on 04-APR-2022 on behalf of Respondent in opposition to Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A-D filed on 04-APR-2022
212022-04-04OttawaAffidavit of Denis Beaudoin sworn on 04-APR-2022 on behalf of Respondent in opposition to Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A-D filed on 04-APR-2022
202022-04-01Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of John Provart confirming service of Doc 19 upon Applicant by email on 01-APR-2022 filed on 01-APR-2022
192022-04-01TorontoAffidavit of Jeremy Adler sworn on 01-APR-2022 on behalf of Respondent in opposition to Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A filed on 01-APR-2022
182022-04-04Ottawa Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Kathleen Kohlman confirming service of the Affidavit of Denis Beaudoin upon Applicant by e-mail on 04-APR-2022 filed on 04-APR-2022
null2022-04-01Toronto Letter from Respondent dated 01-APR-2022 This letter contains a s. 39 request to the clerk of the privy council received on 01-APR-2022
172022-04-01TorontoAffidavit of service of Janani Shanmuganathan sworn on 01-APR-2022 on behalf of Applicant confirming service of Motion Record of the Canadian Constitution Foundation upon Respondent by email on 01-APR-2022 with Exhibits A filed on 01-APR-2022
162022-04-01Toronto Motion Record containing the following original document(s): 13 14 15 Number of copies received: 3 on behalf of Applicant filed on 01-APR-2022
152022-04-01TorontoAffidavit of Madeleine Ross sworn on 28-MAR-2022 contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Applicant in support of Motion Doc. No. 13 with Exhibits A-C filed on 01-APR-2022
142022-04-01Toronto Written Representations contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Applicant concerning Motion in writing Doc. No. 13 filed on 01-APR-2022
132022-04-01TorontoNotice of Motion contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Applicant in writing to be dealt with in the Toronto local office for an Order 1. pursuant to rule 75 granting leave to the Moving Party to file an amended notice of application fo judicial review in the within proceeding; 2. pursuant to rule 317 directing the Responding Party to send to the Moving Party and the Registry certified copies of the record of material before the Governor in Council in respect of the Proclamation Revoking the Declaration of the Public Order Emergency, SOR/2022-26, and 3. other relief filed on 01-APR-2022
null2022-03-31Toronto Letter from Respondent dated 31-MAR-2022 This letter is in regards to a motion filed on T-306-22 received on 31-MAR-2022
null2022-03-25TorontoToronto 25-MAR-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: Parties discuss r. 317 material held by way of video conference Duration per day: 25-MAR-2022 from 11:00 to 11:32 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Andrew Murray Total Duration: 32min Appearances: Sujit Choudhry N/A representing Applicant Janani Shanmuganathan N/A representing Applicant John Provart N/A representing Respondent Jeff Anderson N/A representing Respondent Comments: Recorded on Zoom cloud. Parties discuss r. 317 material Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1076 page(s) 352 - 353 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-03-11TorontoToronto 11-MAR-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: minutes found on T-306-22 held by way of video conference Duration per day: 11-MAR-2022 from 10:00 to 11:00 Courtroom : Toronto (Zoom) Court Registrar: Shaun Nelson Total Duration: 1h Appearances: Sujit Choudhry, Janani Shanmugnathan na representing Applicant John Provart, Jeff Anderson na representing Respondent Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1076 page(s) 337 - 338 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-03-23Toronto Oral directions received from the Court: Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary dated 23-MAR-2022 directing that "A case management teleconference shall be conducted on Friday March 25, 2022 at 11am by Zoom. The purpose of the call is to discuss the Rule 317 requests, responses and next steps. If any party has anything to add to the correspondence already submitted, they shall file their submissions by 3pm March 24th." placed on file on 23-MAR-2022 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
null2022-03-23Toronto Letter from Respondent dated 22-MAR-2022 This letter is in response to the applicant's letter of March 21st received on 23-MAR-2022
122022-03-21TorontoAffidavit of service of Janani Shanmuganathan sworn on 18-MAR-2022 on behalf of Applicant confirming service of Doc 11 upon Respondent by email on 18-MAR-2022 with Exhibits A filed on 21-MAR-2022
null2022-03-21Toronto Letter from Applicant dated 20-MAR-2022 This letter is in regards to the r. 317 productions and produces the applicant's availability for a CMC. received on 21-MAR-2022
112022-03-21Toronto Amended Notice of Application filed on 21-MAR-2022
null2022-03-15Toronto Certified copy of original material relating to Rule 317 request received from Assistant Clerk of the Privy Council on 15-MAR-2022 placed on file on this file
null2022-03-11TorontoCopy of Oral Direction dated 11-MAR-2022 rendered by Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary concerning Schedule placed on file. Original filed on Court File No. T-306-22
null2022-03-07Toronto Letter from proposed intervenor dated 07-MAR-2022 This letter states that the AG of Alberta will be filing a motion to intervene. received on 07-MAR-2022
null2022-02-25Toronto Oral directions received from the Court: Kevin Aalto, Prothonotary dated 25-FEB-2022 directing that further to the orders that these applications (T-347-22 and T-382-22) be specially managed, a case management teleconference (by zoom) shall be conducted in respect of each file on Tuesday March 1, 2022, commencing at 10am. placed on file on 25-FEB-2022
102022-03-01TorontoAffidavit of service of Janani Shanmuganathan sworn on 28-FEB-2022 on behalf of Applicant confirming service of Doc 9 upon Respondent by email on 28-FEB-2022 with Exhibits A filed on 01-MAR-2022
92022-03-01TorontoAffidavit of Madeleine Ross sworn on 28-FEB-2022 on behalf of Applicant in support of Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A-C filed on 01-MAR-2022
null2022-03-01Toronto Oral directions received from the Court: Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary dated 01-MAR-2022 directing that "Further to the case management teleconference conducted this day: -the Respondent AG shall submit an update on any preliminary issues including standing and mootness by March 2, 2022; -the AG's response to the Rule 317 requests shall be delivered by March 15, 2022; -the Applicants in T-382-22 shall serve and file their affidavits by noon on March 10, 2022; and -the Respondent's affidavits shall be served and filed by April 4, 2022. A case management teleconference in Court files T-347-22 and T-382-22 shall be conducted on March 11, 2022 (together with T-306-22 and T-316-22, as previously scheduled) The purpose of the call will be to discuss next steps, including any preliminary motions regarding standing and mootness and the status of the Rule 317 requests." placed on file on 01-MAR-2022 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
null2022-03-01TorontoToronto 01-MAR-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: Matter heard with T-382-22, parties discuss scheduling held by way of Conference Call Duration per day: 01-MAR-2022 from 10:00 to 10:24 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Andrew Murray Total Duration: 24min Appearances: Sujit Choudhry 416-436-3679 representing Applicant John Provart 647-256-0784 representing Respondent Jeff Anderson 647-256-0784 representing Respondent Comments: Recorded on zoom cloud. Heard with T-382-22, parties discuss scheduling. Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1075 page(s) 270 - 271 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
82022-02-28Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of John Provart confirming service of Doc. 7 upon Applicant by e-mail on 28-FEB-2022 filed on 28-FEB-2022
72022-02-28Toronto Notice of appearance on behalf of Respondent filed on 28-FEB-2022
null2022-02-24Ottawa Acknowledgment of Receipt received from all parties with respect to the Order of the Court dated February 23, 2022 placed on file on 24-FEB-2022
62022-02-23OttawaOrder dated 23-FEB-2022 rendered by Chief Justice Crampton Matter considered without personal appearance The Court's decision is with regard to Motion ex proprio motu Result: " IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT: 1. This proceeding shall continue as a specially managed proceeding. 2. Pursuant to Rule 383, Justice Richard G. Mosley and Prothonotary Martha Milczynski are assigned as Case Management Judges in this matter. " Filed on 23-FEB-2022 entered in J. & O. Book, volume 1528 page(s) 136 - 137 Interlocutory Decision
52022-02-23TorontoAffidavit of service of Janani Shanmuganathan sworn on 23-FEB-2022 on behalf of Applicant confirming service of Doc 2, 3 upon Respondent by email on 23-FEB-2022 with Exhibits A, B filed on 23-FEB-2022
42022-02-23TorontoAffidavit of Madeleine Ross sworn on 22-FEB-2022 on behalf of Applicant in support of Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A-Z filed on 23-FEB-2022
32022-02-23TorontoAffidavit of Joanna Barron sworn on 22-FEB-2022 on behalf of Applicant in support of Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A filed on 23-FEB-2022
null2022-02-23Toronto Oral directions received from the Court: Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary dated 23-FEB-2022 directing that "Upon this application being specially managed, the parties shall, within 10 days of the date of this direction, confer with one another and submit (1) an update as to the status of the proceeding; (2) proposal for next steps; and (3) dates and times of mutual availability for a case management teleconference." placed on file on 23-FEB-2022 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
22022-02-23TorontoAcknowledgment of Service received from Respondent with respect to doc.#1 by e-mail filed on 23-FEB-2022
12022-02-23Toronto Notice of application with regard to Judicial Review (s.18) filed on 23-FEB-2022 Certified copy(ies)/copy(ies) transmitted to Director of the Regional Office of the Department of Justice Tariff fee of $50.00 received: yes

 

 

 

Additional information on :  T-382-22

Type :  Federal Court

Nature of Cause :  S. 18.1 Application for Judicial Review

Office :  Calgary     Language :  English

Type of Action :  Non-Action

Filing Date :  2022-02-24

Party Information:

Party NameSolicitorLawyer(s) / file no
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF CANADA - -
CORNELL, EDWARD - -
GIRCYS, VINCENT - -
GOVERNOR IN COUNCIL - -
HIS MAJESTY THE KING - -
JOST, JEREMIAHFoster LLPMILLER, BRENDAN
MINISTER OF PUBLIC SAFETY & EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS (THE) - -
RISTAU, HAROLD

 

Recorded Entry Information :   T-382-22

Type :  Federal Court

Nature of Proceeding :  S. 18.1 Application for Judicial Review

Office :  Calgary     Language :  English

Type of Action :  Federal Court

Filing Date :  2022-02-24

Recorded Entry Summary Information

Certain public documents in some proceedings are now available for online access in accordance with the Federal Court’s Online Access to Court Records – Pilot Project. These documents are identified with a download icon () in the Download column below.

You may obtain copies of other public documents by contacting the Registry. Copies of public documents which are already in electronic format can be sent by e-mail, upon request to the Registry: fc_reception_cf@cas-satj.gc.ca. Indicate the Court File number in the subject of your email. In the text, you must clearly identify the document number and its name (this information is located in the Recorded Entry Summary column).

The availability of documents from the Registry, including through online access, does not grant a copyright licence or permission. Your use of such materials must be in accordance with the Copyright Act, RSC 1985, c C-42.

80 records found
DocDate FiledOfficeRecorded Entry SummaryDownload
412022-10-21Ottawa Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Brendan M. Miller confirming service of Doc No. 40: Applicants Reply Representations upon Respondents by email on 21-OCT-2022 filed on 21-OCT-2022
402022-10-21Ottawa Written Reply Representations on behalf of Applicants in response to the opposing submissions doc. No. 38 to the Motion in writing Filed on 21-OCT-2022
392022-10-11Edmonton Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Kathleen Kohlman confirming service of Doc 38 upon Applicants by email on 11-OCT-2022 filed on 11-OCT-2022
382022-10-11Edmonton Written Representations on behalf of Respondent concerning Motion in writing Doc. No. 36 filed on 11-OCT-2022
null2022-10-05TorontoToronto 05-OCT-2022 BEFORE The Honourable Mr. Justice Mosley Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: Parties discuss scheduling various matters held by way of Conference Call Duration per day: 05-OCT-2022 from 03:00 to 03:56 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Andrew Murray Total Duration: 56min Appearances: Brendan Miller N/A representing Applicant Blair Ector N/A representing Applicant Bath-Sheba van den Berg N/A representing Applicant John Provart N/A representing Respondent Kathleen Kohlman N/A representing Respondent Comments: DARS not used. The parties discuss scheduling various matters. Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1084 page(s) 312 - 313 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-09-21Toronto Oral directions received from the Court: Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary dated 21-SEP-2022 directing that "Upon reviewing the Applicants' motion to compel arising from the cross examination of Steven Shragge and noting only one question/objection (Q75) is in issue, subject to either of the parties requesting that the motion be heard orally, the motion will be dealt with in writing. The Respondent shall serve and file the responding motion record within 20 days of the date of this direction and any reply shall be served and filed by the Applicants within 10 days of service of the Respondent's record." placed on file on 21-SEP-2022 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
372022-09-16Toronto Amended Motion Record containing the following original document(s): 36 Number of copies received: 1 on behalf of Applicant filed on 16-SEP-2022
362022-09-16TorontoNotice of Motion contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Applicant returnable (but no hearing date indicated at this time) for an Order compelling the production of documents filed on 16-SEP-2022
352022-09-16Toronto Amended Motion Record containing the following original document(s): 34 Number of copies received: 1 on behalf of Applicant filed on 16-SEP-2022
342022-09-16TorontoNotice of Motion contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Applicant returnable (but no hearing date indicated at this time) for an Order compelling the respondent's affiant to answer questions filed on 16-SEP-2022
null2022-09-07TorontoToronto 07-SEP-2022 BEFORE The Honourable Mr. Justice Mosley Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: Various matters discussed held by way of Conference Call Duration per day: 07-SEP-2022 from 10:00 to 10:43 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Andrew Murray Total Duration: 43min Appearances: Brendan Miller N/A representing Applicant Beth-Sheba van den Berg N/A representing Applicant Blair Ector N/A representing Applicant Christopher Rupar N/A representing Respondent John Provart N/A representing Respondent Kathleen Kohlman N/A representing Respondent Comments: DARS not used. The parties discuss various matters. Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1083 page(s) 125 - 126 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-08-03Toronto S. 39 material transmitted by the DOJ received on 03-AUG-2022
332022-07-15TorontoOrder dated 15-JUL-2022 rendered by Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Matter considered with personal appearance The Court's decision is with regard to Motion Doc. No. 28 Result: granted in part Filed on 15-JUL-2022 copies sent to parties entered in J. & O. Book, volume 1547 page(s) 405 - 411 Interlocutory Decision
null2022-07-14TorontoToronto 14-JUL-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Motion Doc. No. 28 on behalf of Applicant Result of Hearing: Various questions ordered answered held by way of video conference Duration per day: 14-JUL-2022 from 10:00 to 12:07 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Andrew Murray Total Duration: 2h 7min Appearances: Brendan Miller N/A representing Applicant David Aaron N/A representing Respondent Comments: Recorded on Zoom Cloud. Various questions ordered answered Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1081 page(s) 353 - 354 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
322022-07-12Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of David Aaron confirming service of Doc. 31 upon Applicants by e-mail on 12-JUL-2022 filed on 12-JUL-2022
312022-07-12Toronto Motion Record in response to Motion Doc. No. 28 containing the following original document(s): 30 Number of copies received: 1 on behalf of Respondent, ATTORNEY GENERAL OF CANADA filed on 12-JUL-2022
302022-07-12Toronto Written Representations on behalf of Respondent, ATTORNEY GENERAL OF CANADA concerning Motion Doc. No. 28 filed on 12-JUL-2022
null2022-07-05Toronto Memorandum to file from Toronto Local Office - B. Rousseau dated 05-JUL-2022 service of doc.29 confirmed on cmc - CMT-SRO confirmed motion record should be accepted for filing - Motion Record sent to CMJ placed on file.
292022-07-04Toronto Motion Record containing the following original document(s): 28 Number of copies received: 1 on behalf of Applicant filed on 04-JUL-2022
282022-07-04TorontoNotice of Motion contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Plaintiff returnable at Special Sitting in Toronto on 14-JUL-2022 to begin at 10:00 for an Order pursuant to R.91-R.100 motion to compel and other relief filed on 04-JUL-2022
null2022-07-05Toronto Copy of oral direction ID 71 dated 30-JUN-2022 placed on file on 05-JUL-2022 Original placed on Court File No. T-316-22
null2022-06-30Ottawa Oral directions received from the Court: K. Trudeau, Judicial Administrator dated 30-JUN-2022 directing that ¿Parties are advised to remain available for a hearing on the merits from October 17 to 21 and November 14 to 18, 2022. An Order scheduling the hearing on the merits will follow in due course.¿ placed on file on 30-JUN-2022
null2022-06-30Toronto Copy of minutes of Hearing dated 30-JUN-2022 placed on file on 30-JUN-2022 Original placed on Court File No. T-306-22
272022-06-28Toronto****** CANCELLED ****** Notice of Motion contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Applicant returnable at Special Sitting in Toronto on 05-JUL-2022 to begin at 09:30 for Rulings on the objections made by the Respondent, AGC, to the document requests listed in the CCLA's May 12, 2022, Direction to Attend to Steven Shragge; and other relief filed on 28-JUN-2022
262022-06-21Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Kathleen Kohlman confirming service of Affidavit of Rebecca Coleman, enclosing answers to Written Interrogatories upon the Applicants by E-mail on 20-JUN-2022 filed on 21-JUN-2022
252022-06-21Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Kathleen Kohlman confirming service of Affidavit of Denis Beaudoin, enclosing answers to Written Interrogatories upon the Applicants by Email on 20-JUN-2022 filed on 21-JUN-2022
null2022-06-22TorontoToronto 22-JUN-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: The parties are on track for the Motion July 5, 2022; a further Case Management Conference to take place June 30, 2022 held by way of Conference Call Duration per day: 22-JUN-2022 from 11:02 to 11:23 Courtroom : Toronto (Zoom) Court Registrar: Monica Mecca Total Duration: 21min Appearances: Brendan Miller, Blair Ector, Bath-Sheba van den Berg NA representing Applicant Alexander Boissonneau-Lehner, David Cowling, MacKenzie Campbell NA representing Applicants (T-306-22) Ewa Krajewska, Brandon Chung NA representing Applicant (T-316-22) Sujit Choudhry, Janani Shanmuganathan NA representing Applicant (T-347-22) Jeff Anderson, John Provart, Kathleen Kohlman NA representing Respondent Mandy England, Leah McDaniel, Shaheer Meenai NA representing Intervenor Comments: Recorded via Zoom Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1080 page(s) 462 - 463 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-05-25TorontoToronto 25-MAY-2022 BEFORE Kevin Aalto, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: minutes found on T-306-22 held by way of video conference Duration per day: 25-MAY-2022 from 11:00 to 12:00 Courtroom : Toronto (Zoom) Court Registrar: Shaun Nelson Total Duration: 1h Appearances: Mr. Ector, Ms. Van den Berg na representing Applicant Mr. Anderson, Mr. Provart, Ms. Kohlman na representing Respondent Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1079 page(s) 360 - 361 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
242022-05-19Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Brenden Miller confirming service of Doc 23 upon Respondent by email on 18-MAY-2022 filed on 19-MAY-2022
232022-05-19Toronto Written Examination questions for Rebecca Coleman filed on 19-MAY-2022
222022-05-18Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Denis Beaudoin confirming service of Doc 21 upon Respondent by email on 18-MAY-2022 filed on 18-MAY-2022
212022-05-18Toronto Written Examination questions of Denis Beaudoin filed on 18-MAY-2022
202022-05-16Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Brenden Miller confirming service of Written examination questions upon Respondent by email on 16-MAY-2022 filed on 16-MAY-2022
null2022-05-16Toronto Written examination questions received on 16-MAY-2022
null2022-05-09TorontoToronto 09-MAY-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: Parties discuss expert timelines held by way of video conference Duration per day: 09-MAY-2022 from 11:00 to 11:40 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Andrew Murray Total Duration: 40min Appearances: Brenden Miller N/A representing Applicant Jeff Anderson N/A representing Respondent Kathleen Kohlman N/A representing Respondent Comments: Recorded on zoom cloud. The parties discuss expert timelines. Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1078 page(s) 227 - 228 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-05-04TorontoCopy of oral direction dated 04-MAY-2022 rendered by Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary placed on file. Original filed on Court File No. T-306-22
null2022-04-29Toronto Copy of a letter on behalf of Respondent dated 28-APR-2022 placed on file on 29-APR-2022 Original placed on Court File No. T-306-22
null2022-04-28Toronto Copy of a letter on behalf of Respondent dated 28-APR-2022 placed on file on 28-APR-2022 Original placed on Court File No. T-306-22
null2022-04-11TorontoToronto 11-APR-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: minutes found on T-306-22 held by way of video conference Duration per day: 11-APR-2022 from 11:05 to 12:25 Courtroom : Toronto (Zoom) Court Registrar: Shaun Nelson Total Duration: 1h 20min Appearances: Brenden Miller, Beth-Sheba van den Berg na representing Applicant Kathleen Kohlman, Beth Tait na representing Respondent Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1078 page(s) 66 - 67 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-04-25Toronto Copy of a letter on behalf of Respondent dated 25-APR-2022 placed on file on 25-APR-2022 Original placed on Court File No. T-306-22
null2022-04-25Toronto Letter from Applicant dated 22-APR-2022 This letter provides the applicant's position on various matters received on 25-APR-2022
null2022-04-21Toronto Copy of a letter on behalf of Respondent dated 21-APR-2022 placed on file on 21-APR-2022 Original placed on Court File No. T-306-22
null2022-04-20Toronto Copy of a letter on behalf of Respondent dated 19-APR-2022 placed on file on 20-APR-2022 Original placed on Court File No. T-306-22
null2022-04-19TorontoCopy of oral direction dated 19-APR-2022 dated 19-APR-2022 rendered by Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary placed on file. Original filed on Court File No. T-306-22
null2022-04-12Toronto Copy of a letter on behalf of Respondent dated 12-APR-2022 placed on file on 12-APR-2022 Original placed on Court File No. T-306-22
null2022-04-12Toronto Copy of Motion Record on behalf of Respondent dated 12-APR-2022 placed on file on 12-APR-2022 Original filed on Court File No. T-306-22
null2022-04-12TorontoCopy of Oral directions dated 12-APR-2022 dated 12-APR-2022 rendered by Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary placed on file. Original filed on Court File No. T-306-22
192022-04-05Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Nur Muhammed Ally confirming service of Doc 18 upon Applicant by email on 04-APR-2022 filed on 05-APR-2022
182022-04-05TorontoAffidavit of Rebecca Coleman sworn on 04-APR-2022 contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Respondent in opposition to Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A-RRRRR filed on 05-APR-2022
172022-04-04OttawaAffidavit of service of Kathleen Kohlman sworn on 04-APR-2022 on behalf of Respondent confirming service of the affidavit of Steven Shragge upon Applicant by e-mail on 04-APR-2022 with Exhibits A-D filed on 04-APR-2022
162022-04-04OttawaAffidavit of Steven Shragge sworn on 04-APR-2022 on behalf of Respondent in opposition to Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A-D filed on 04-APR-2022
152022-04-04OttawaAffidavit of Denis Beaudoin sworn on 04-APR-2022 on behalf of Respondent in opposition to Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A-D filed on 04-APR-2022
142022-04-04Ottawa Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Kathleen Kohlman confirming service of the Affidavit of Denis Beaudoin upon Applicant by e-mail on 04-APR-2022 filed on 04-APR-2022
null2022-04-04Toronto Letter from Respondent dated 04-APR-2022 This letter discuss the s. 39 certificate on T-306-22 and T-347-22 received on 04-APR-2022
null2022-04-01Ottawa Letter from Respondents dated 01-APR-2022 "Please deliver this letter to the attention of Prothonotary Milczynski concerning this proceeding." (see electronic document) -sent to attention of CMJ(Milczynski,P) for consideration received on 01-APR-2022
null2022-03-25TorontoToronto 25-MAR-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: Parties discuss r. 317 material held by way of video conference Duration per day: 25-MAR-2022 from 11:00 to 11:32 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Andrew Murray Total Duration: 32min Appearances: Brenden Miller N/A representing Applicant Beth-Sheba van den Berg N/A representing Applicant Kathleen Kohlman N/A representing Respondent Beth Tait N/A representing Respondent Comments: Recorded on zoom cloud. The parties discuss r. 317 material Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1076 page(s) 354 - 355 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-03-11TorontoToronto 11-MAR-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: minutes found on T-306-22 held by way of video conference Duration per day: 11-MAR-2022 from 10:00 to 11:00 Courtroom : Toronto (Zoom) Court Registrar: Shaun Nelson Total Duration: 1h Appearances: Bath-Sheba van den Berg, Brenden Miller na representing Applicant Kathleen Kohlman, Beth Tait na representing Respondent Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1076 page(s) 339 - 340 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
null2022-03-23Toronto Oral directions received from the Court: Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary dated 23-MAR-2022 directing that A case management teleconference shall be conducted on Friday March 25, 2022 at 11am by Zoom. The purpose of the call is to discuss the Rule 317 requests, responses and next steps. If any party has anything to add to the correspondence already submitted, they shall file their submissions by 3pm March 24th." placed on file on 23-MAR-2022 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
null2022-03-18Toronto Letter from Applicant dated 17-MAR-2022 This letter is in regards to the r. 317 submissions received on 18-MAR-2022
132022-03-14TorontoAffidavit of service of Bethany DeWolfe sworn on 14-MAR-2022 on behalf of Applicant confirming service of Doc 12 upon all parties by telecopier on 14-MAR-2022 with Exhibits A, B filed on 14-MAR-2022
122022-03-14Toronto Notice of a constitutional question on behalf of Applicant filed on 14-MAR-2022
null2022-03-15Ottawa Letter from Respondent dated 15-MAR-2022 AGC's response to Rule 317 request, Encl. Certified Tribunal Record received on 15-MAR-2022
null2022-03-15Ottawa****** CANCELLED ****** Certified copy of original material received from Privy Council Office on 15-MAR-2022 placed on file on this file
null2022-03-11TorontoCopy of Oral Direction dated 11-MAR-2022 rendered by Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary concerning Schedule placed on file. Original filed on Court File No. T-306-22
112022-03-11Toronto Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Brenden Miller confirming service of Doc 10 upon Respondent by email on 09-MAR-2022 filed on 11-MAR-2022
102022-03-11TorontoAffidavit of Jermiah Jost sworn on 09-MAR-2022 on behalf of Applicant in support of Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A-K filed on 11-MAR-2022
92022-03-09Calgary Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Brendan M. Miller confirming service of Affidavit of Edward Cornell, Vincent Gircys, Harold Ristau upon Respondents by e-mail on 09-MAR-2022 filed on 09-MAR-2022
82022-03-09CalgaryAffidavit of Harold Ristau sworn on 09-MAR-2022 on behalf of Applicant in support of Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A filed on 09-MAR-2022
72022-03-09CalgaryAffidavit of Vincent Gircys sworn on 08-MAR-2022 on behalf of Applicant in support of Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A-D filed on 09-MAR-2022
62022-03-09CalgaryAffidavit of Edward Cornell sworn on 23-FEB-2022 on behalf of Applicant in support of Notice of Application Doc. No. 1 with Exhibits A-D filed on 09-MAR-2022
null2022-03-10Toronto Letter from Applicant dated 10-MAR-2022 This letter discusses a possible motion being heard, and proposes a schedule received on 10-MAR-2022
52022-03-02Calgary Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Brendan M. Miller confirming service of Notice of Application upon Respondents by e-mail on 23-FEB-2022 filed on 02-MAR-2022
null2022-03-02Ottawa Acknowledgment of Receipt received from all parties with respect to the Order of the Court dated february 24, 2022 placed on file on 02-MAR-2022
null2022-03-01Toronto Oral directions received from the Court: Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary dated 01-MAR-2022 directing that "Further to the case management teleconference conducted this day: -the Respondent AG shall submit an update on any preliminary issues including standing and mootness by March 2, 2022; -the AG's response to the Rule 317 requests shall be delivered by March 15, 2022; -the Applicants in T-382-22 shall serve and file their affidavits by noon on March 10, 2022; and -the Respondent's affidavits shall b e served and filed by April 4, 2022 -A case management teleconference in Court files T-347-22 and T-382-22 shall be conducted on March 11, 2022 (together with T-306-22 and T-316-22, as previously scheduled) The purpose of the call will be to discuss next steps, including any preliminary motions regarding standing and mootness and the status of the Rule 317 requests." placed on file on 01-MAR-2022 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
null2022-03-01TorontoToronto 01-MAR-2022 BEFORE Martha Milczynski, Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: Heard with T-347-22, parties discuss scheduling held by way of video conference Duration per day: 01-MAR-2022 from 10:00 to 10:24 Courtroom : Judge's Chambers - Toronto Court Registrar: Andrew Murray Total Duration: 24min Appearances: Bath-Sheba van den Berg N/A representing Applicant Brenden Miller N/A representing Applicant Kathleen Kohlman N/A representing Respondent Beth Tait N/A representing Respondent Comments: Recorded on Zoom cloud, heard with T-347-22. Parties discuss scheduling. Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1075 page(s) 272 - 273 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
42022-02-24Calgary Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of Kathleen Kohlman confirming service of Notice of Appearance upon Applicants by e-mail on 24-FEB-2022 filed on 24-FEB-2022
32022-02-24Calgary Notice of appearance on behalf of Respondent filed on 24-FEB-2022
22022-02-24OttawaOrder dated 24-FEB-2022 rendered by Chief Justice Crampton Matter considered with personal appearance The Court's decision is with regard to Order dated 24-FEB-2022 Result: "IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT: 1. This proceeding shall continue as a specially managed proceeding. 2. Pursuant to Rule 383, Justice Richard G. Mosley and Prothonotary Martha Milczynski are assigned as Case Management Judges in this matter." Filed on 24-FEB-2022 entered in J. & O. Book, volume 1528 page(s) 239 - 240 Interlocutory Decision
null2022-02-24Calgary Certified copy of Doc. 1 sent to Respondent pursuant to Rule 133 of the Federal Courts Rules placed on file on 24-FEB-2022
12022-02-24Calgary Notice of application and 2 copies with regard to Judicial Review (s.18) filed on 24-FEB-2022 Certified copy(ies)/copy(ies) transmitted to Director of the Regional Office of the Department of Justice Tariff fee of $50.00 received: yes

 

 

 

Judgment dated 20-OCT-2022 rendered by Associate Chief Justice Gagné Matter considered with personal appearance The Court's decision is with regard to Motion Doc. No. 40 Result: "THIS COURT'S JUDGMENT is that: 1. The Respondent's Motion is granted. 2. The Applicant's Applications for judicial review are struck out as moot. 3. The parties shall provide written submissions on costs, not exceeding 5 pages, within 10 days of the reasons to follow in both official languages." Filed on 20-OCT-2022 copies sent to parties entered in J. & O. Book, volume 1561 page(s) 63 - 65 Final Decision 

Ottawa 21-SEP-2022 BEFORE Associate Chief Justice Gagné Language: B Before the Court: Motion Doc. No. 40 on behalf of Respondent Result of Hearing: Matter reserved held in Court Senior Usher: Richard Carisse Duration per day: 21-SEP-2022 from 10:17 to 03:20 Courtroom : Federal Court of Appeal Courtroom - Ottawa Court Registrar: Wayne Sawtell Total Duration: 5h 3min Appearances: Sam A. Presvelos 416-844-3457 representing Applicants in T-1991-21 Evan A. Presvelos 416-844-3457 representing Applicants in T-1991-21 Keith Wilson 431-688-4885 representing Applicants in T-168-22 Eva Chipiuk 431-688-4885 representing Applicants in T-168-22 Sam Bachand 438-788-0838 representing Applicants in T-247-22 J. Sanderson (Sandy)_Graham 613-670-6274 representing Respondent Robert Drummond 613-670-6274 representing Respondent Virginie Harvey 613-670-6274 representing Respondent Court Reporter: Sean Prouse 613-261-8882 21-SEP-2022 Transcript not requested Sim. Translation: Charles André Marchand Yanitsa Cornano Comments: hearing recorded in DARS; TASCAM back-up recorder also used; hearing was broadcast via Zoom webinar; parties to make written submissions on costs within 10 days of the decision being rendered. Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 1084 page(s) 329 - 341 Abstract of Hearing placed on file

 Joint Compendium prepared by the Applicants in Court File T-168-22 on behalf of all Applicants in T-145-22, T-168-22, T-247-22, T-1991-21, for use at both the judicial review hearing and in response to the motion to strike (pursuant to the Order of Case Management Judge Tabib dated August 8, 2022) filed on 10-AUG-2022

 Oral directions received from the presiding judge dated 15-AUG-2022 directing that "The motion for mootness, scheduled to be heard before this Court in Ottawa on September 21, 2022, will now be conducted in a hybrid manner. The courtroom reserved for this hearing can accommodate eight counsel (four counsel tables with two seats at each table) and 28 members of the public. Parties shall submit a joint letter to the Court outlining each counsel's desired mode of participation while keeping the capacity limit of the courtroom in mind no later than Monday, September 12, 2022." placed on file on 15-AUG-2022

Order dated 28-JUN-2022 rendered by Mireille Tabib, Prothonotary Matter considered with personal appearance The Court's decision is with regard to Oral motion on behalf of Respondent requesting an adjournment (ID# 53) Result: "THIS COURT ORDERS that: 1. The hearing of these applications, initially scheduled to begin on eptember 19, 2022, is adjourned to begin on October 31, 2022, for a duration of 5 days. 2. The Attorney General's motion to dismiss for mootness will be heard on a date to be determined during the week of September 19, 2022. 3. The time within which the Attorney General is to serve and file its record is extended to a date to be fixed." Filed on 28-JUN-2022 copies sent to parties entered in J. & O. Book, volume 1545 page(s) 90 - 99 Interlocutory Decision

Toronto 22-JUN-2022  Appearances: Brendan Miller, Blair Ector, Bath-Sheba van den Berg NA representing Applicant Alexander Boissonneau-Lehner, David Cowling, MacKenzie Campbell NA representing Applicants (T-306-22) Ewa Krajewska, Brandon Chung NA representing Applicant (T-316-22) Sujit Choudhry, Janani Shanmuganathan NA representing Applicant (T-347-22) Jeff Anderson, John Provart, Kathleen Kohlman NA representing Respondent Mandy England, Leah McDaniel, Shaheer Meenai NA representing Intervenor

 

 

 

 

 

Posted by at

No comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)