---------- Original message ----------
From: Cindy Bruneau cindy.bruneau@edmonton.ca
Date: Sun, 25 Jun 2017 09:38:58 -0700
Subject: Out of Office Re: Justice Paulette Garnett in her lightning fast decision dismissing Chucky Leblanc's lawsuit warned of common-law action for defamation and "beware of the Lone Ranger" N'esy Pas?
To: motomaniac333@gmail.com

I am away from the office and will return Monday June 26th, 2017

If your matter is *time sensitive* please contact our Corporate Security
Dispatch Centre at 780-496-8888, and ask to speak to the Advisor on Call.

I will respond to your email when I return.

Have a great day!

--
Thank you,

Cindy Bruneau, CPP
Corporate Security Advisor
Law / Corporate Security
Financial and Corporate Services
780-496-5156

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

“Corporate Security’s mission is to mitigate risks to

corporate assets and to contribute to the improved

livability of employees and the citizens of Edmonton”

To report a security incident:

click here

---------- Original message ----------
From: Jean-Yves.Duclos@parl.gc.ca
Date: Sun, 25 Jun 2017 16:38:53 +0000
Subject: Merci / Thank you
To: motomaniac333@gmail.com

Bonjour,

Nous vous remercions d'avoir communiqué avec le bureau de circonscription de Jean-Yves Duclos, député de Québec.

Ce courriel confirme la réception de votre correspondance. Votre demande sera traitée dans les meilleurs délais.

Salutations distinguées,

L'équipe du bureau de circonscription de Jean-Yves Duclos

Hello,

Thank you for contacting the office of Jean-Yves Duclos, Member of Parliament for Québec.

This email confirms the reception of your message. Your request will be processed as soon as possible.

Best regards,

The riding office of Jean-Yves Duclos

---------- Original message ----------
From: Póstur FOR postur@for.is
Date: Sun, 25 Jun 2017 16:40:23 +0000
Subject: Re: Justice Paulette Garnett in her lightning fast decision dismissing Chucky Leblanc's lawsuit warned of common-law action for defamation and "beware of the Lone Ranger" N'esy Pas?
To: David Amos motomaniac333@gmail.com

Erindi þitt hefur verið móttekið / Your request has been received

Kveðja / Best regards

---------- Original message ----------
From: David Amos motomaniac333@gmail.com
Date: Sun, 25 Jun 2017 12:38:41 -0400
Subject: Justice Paulette Garnett in her lightning fast decision dismissing Chucky Leblanc's lawsuit warned of common-law action for defamation and "beware of the Lone Ranger" N'esy Pas?
To: rgoren@richardgorenlaw.com, just.1.father@gmail.com, TJ.Harvey@parl.gc.ca, Matt.DeCourcey@parl.gc.ca, Diane.Lebouthillier@cra-arc.gc.ca, jeanyves.duclos@hrsdc-rhdcc.gc.ca, Jean-Yves.Duclos@parl.gc.ca, Louise.Levonian@hrsdc-rhdcc.gc.ca, webcomms@sen.parl.gc.ca, Michael.Wernick@pco-bcp.gc.ca, Gerald.Butts@pmo-cpm.gc.ca, ethiec@sen.parl.gc.ca, dan.bussieres@gnb.ca, patrick_doran1@hotmail.com, cps@calgarypolice.ca, Themayor@calgary.ca, mike.obrienfred@gmail.com, eps@edmontonpolice.ca, Cindy.Bruneau@edmonton.ca, Paul.Lynch@edmontonpolice.ca, don.iveson@edmonton.ca, sunrayzulu@shaw.ca, randy.mckeen@gnb.ca, Stephen.Horsman@gnb.ca, alan.white@cbc.ca, dean.buzza@rcmp-grc.gc.ca, deanrogerray@hotmail.com, david@lutz.nb.ca, danadurnford@hotmail.com, brian@brianruhe.ca, paul@paulfromm.com, radical@radicalpress.com
Cc: david.raymond.amos@gmail.com, mcu@justice.gc.ca, denis.landry2@gnb.ca, Jody.Wilson-Raybould@parl.gc.ca, oldmaison@yahoo.com, premier@gnb.ca,
bob.paulson@rcmp-grc.gc.ca, Liliana.Longo@rcmp-grc.gc.ca, brian.gallant@gnb.ca, postur@for.is, smarim@althingi.is, smari@immi.is, editor@grapevine.is, editor@frankmagazine.ca>, Glen Canning grcanning@gmail.com, andrew@frankmagazine.ca, editor@wikileaks.org, briangallant10@gmail.com, martin.gaudet@fredericton.ca, Leanne.Fitch@fredericton.ca, andre@jafaust.com, jbosnitch@gmail.com, Jacques.Poitras@cbc.ca, Robert.Jones@cbc.ca, jeremy.keefe@globalnews.ca, nick.moore@bellmedia.ca, Norman.Sabourin@cjc-ccm.gc.ca, leanne.murray@mcinnescooper.com

Hey

Chucky Leblanc, Andre Faust and two members of the RCMP witnessed me argue the Crown in Federal Court On May 24th, exactly one month ago and a week or so before his old blogging buddy Barry Winters ' latest blogs went "Poof" as he was arrested and being charged.

Yet still these wacko Trolls playing evil games within Encyclopedia Dramatica and YoutTbe etc don't believe that I am serious about getting even byway of a lawsuit about being libeled all over the Internet since 2005???

It appears that I may be the "Lone Ranger" in Canada that Justice Paulette Garnett was referring to (How could she not know of my lawsuit by now?) .However I see that on May 24th another Trolll who is an obvious fan of Encyclopedia Dramatica informs us that others are sick and tired of the Evil Trolls.

Perhaps the Yankee lawyers do not know that Encyclopedia Dramatica's actions are criminal in nature in Canada however the RCMP certainly do and have done nothing thus far with regards to my Clan's rights and interests for very obvious political reasons involving my litigation in the USA back in 2002.

http://www.topix.com/forum/ca/petitcodiac-nb/TNI9HUTBDGU5LOGKS

RCMP post video evidence on YouTube

There are 3 comments on the CBC story from Feb 22, 2008, titled RCMP post video evidence on YouTube. In it, CBC reports that:

“We're being innovative and using the latest technology available.”

New Brunswick RCMP are using the video sharing website YouTube in an attempt to capture an arsonist. via CBC

Join the discussion below, or Read more at CBC.

Whereas Richard Goren is located in downtown Beantown Perhaps this lawyer and I should talk ASAP. Below is just some of your evil work that still remains opublished n the Internet EH Dean Roger Ray and Patrick Doran of Alberta EH?

http://theralphretort.com/encyclopedia-dramatica-in-danger-of-closing-after-750k-lawsuit-5024017/

Encyclopedia Dramatica In Danger After $750K Lawsuit Brought by Copyright Cretin
by Ethan Ralph · May 24, 2017

http://www.richardgorenlaw.com/contact

Law Office of Richard Goren
1 State Street
Suite 1500
Boston, Massachusetts 02109
Email: rgoren@richardgorenlaw.com
Tel: 617-933-9494
Fax: 617-933-9495

FYI I just called Mr Goren and left a voicemail telling him to expect this email

Veritas Vincit
David Raymond Amos
902 800 0369

P.S YO Chucky Leblanc and your llatest "IT Guy"Andre Faust   quite likely by the time you and "Dumb and Dumber" as you now call yourselves (I agree) read this email will already be published in my blog about about my ongoing Federal Lawsuit Ckeck for yourselves if you don't believe me by now.

https://encyclopediadramatica.rs/David_Raymond_Amos

David Raymond Amos

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wu8z4ouinY0

The Mad Shangi Show "The Roast of David Raymond Amos: Cyberstalker"
Mad Shangi
Streamed live on Apr 23, 2016

From the Baconfat Chronicles:

Pat Doran the lion he is has had enough of the criminal, craven and insane David Amos!

The Mad Shangi is dealing with our little "friend" David Amos and standing betwixt Amos the animal, and McCunt.

Shangi is hosting a show with your's truly myself, all about the sordid and tawdry life, and times of Davis Ramond Amos. Our little "friend's" outstanding warrants in amerka will be dicussed. Amos' insane claims that our amerkan cousins attempted to "render" him to Guantanamo, Amos being put on "the No Fly terrorist list" and let's not forget his living of the avails of prostitution from his children in Boston!

Call constable Paul Lynch little David!

    Notice
        Age-restricted video (requested by uploader)
    Category
        People & Blogs
    License
        Standard YouTube License

https://www.change.org/p/canadian-immigration-deport-david-raymond-amos

Deport David Raymond Amos
Teslabrotherhood

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hSY0nxkZIxM

Dean Roger Ray aka Dirty Dicky Dean STOLE this video and Huffington Post Promoted it
David Amos
Published on May 19, 2008

I do not appreciate GOOGLE allowing other people to steal my work particularly after they killed my old faithful YOUTUBE account

http://www.youtube.com/user/DavidRaym...

My Channel and old blog worked fine before GOOGLE bought the company and then killed them both it based on false flagging of TROLLS such as Dean Roger Ray and Scott Agnew many friends within GOOGLE's and FaceBooks domains

Here is one comment the RCMP and GOOGLE's should review ASAP

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gB5mkk...

Once folks quit watching the porn that the Diddler Dana Durnford puts up in my name and quit reading his butt buddy's Dirty Dicky Dean's nonsense and that of their Zionist Platooncommander Mr Baconfat53 say about mean old me and everybody else and simply listen for a bit. These three stooges who ARE RCMP shills are proving that my complaint against the CROWN will be a cakewalk once their malice becomes common knowledge
blogtalkradio com/YouThinkYouKnow/2009/05/30/Religion-Division-Political-
DavidRaymondAmos 2 years ago

Here are but few of the Wacko Fatso Dean Roger Ray's many channels

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yKwVsU...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Yo6I3...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gB5mkk...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1O6A51...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=URUB_K...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RSbbFe...

http://teslacoils2001-exposingamos.bl...

    Category
        News & Politics
    License
        Standard YouTube License

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eW76Mgj5wQA&t=933s

RCMP backing Drug Dealer David Raymond Amos.
Dean Roger Ray
Published on May 9, 2013

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PhntEtYpNxI

Hits From the Bong (call the police in Chipman Newbrunswick!)
AMOSthestalker
Published on Jun 8, 2011

David Raymond Amos daughter!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fQ355TBYA10

DAvid Raymond Amos son joins the teslabrotherhood.
Dean Roger Ray
Published on Jul 15, 2013

Actually it was Canadian cointelpro!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=scFL-W-Kb5A

David Raymond Amos talking About Byron Prior
tesladoxed
Published on May 28, 2012

http://www.byronprior.com/

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EdB4SV08H6I

David raymond Amos Crackhead troll hired by RCMP
William Week
Published on Oct 18, 2012

http://www.bikernet.com/default.aspx
http://www.youtube.com/user/WernerBock

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nNaww7WB_Dw

DAvid Raymond Amos
sylvantaxiguy

Published on Aug 18, 2009

http://www.bikernet.com/shops/shopbys...

http://teslacoils2001-exposingamos.bl...

http://www.youtube.com/user/DavidRaym...
http://community.theblackvault.com/gr...

David Raymond Amos and I have a history and it all started when he was helping Byron Prior. In the video I expose the fact David RAymond Amos admits in his own voice to working for the RCMP! So why would he be helping an Iluminati judge named T.Alex Hickman ! The connection is freemasonry which both the Hells Angels And RCMP have come from! Why do you think if you have a loud muffler you are ticketed and bikers can terrorize all they want!

Werner Bock has some interesting things happening to the cattle! could it be that the RCMP sent a provocateur to stop Werner Bock from exposing a illegal urainium mine operation! http://www.minesandcommunities.org/ar...

http://www.healthscout.com/ency/68/72...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xoL8LK...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VEo8Dc...
Platooncommander (2 minutes ago) Show Hide 0 Marked as spam Reply | Spam Well YOU are indeed an indictment of the state of "education" in the United States of Amerka......
TruTHTVSpokaneWA (19 minutes ago) Show Hide Marked as spam Reply MESSAGE to all you agents of evil trying to discredit David. Your STUPID COMMENTS will be removed and you WILL immediately be blocked! One more THING my standard answer back to you will BE FUCK OFF AND DIE!

Douglas Bickford
Real Name BECAUSE I DON'T FEAR YOU EVIL FUCKING AGENTS!
imbackteslacoils2001 (25 minutes ago) Show Hide 0 Marked as spam Reply | Remove 3:00 So let me get this straight the rest of us have no luck with the masonic courts and you were able to sue a cardinal?
TruTHTVSpokaneWA (16 minutes ago) Show Hide Marked as spam Reply FUCK OFF AND DIE AGENT OF EVIL!
imbackteslacoils2001 (32 minutes ago) Show Hide 0 Marked as spam Reply | Remove 2:52 David Raymond Amos tells how bad the federal system is? Whos behind it what work have you done to expose them ?
TruTHTVSpokaneWA (24 minutes ago) Show Hide Marked as spam Reply Dave has been in jail for EXPOSING the EVIL lying fucks in the US Government/Canadian Government. What have you done!
imbackteslacoils2001 (33 minutes ago) Show Hide 0 Marked as spam Reply | Remove 2:20 Amos brags mainstream media was going to expose his troubles? Where do they start do they talk about the troubles of being in a criminal gang and a bike mechanic court witness or head straight to your evidense you have on the net?
TruTHTVSpokaneWA (23 minutes ago) Show Hide Marked as spam Reply When was the LAST time you saw a real investigative journalist EXPOSE anything in the US Government. How about 911?
imbackteslacoils2001 (38 minutes ago) Show Hide 0 Marked as spam Reply | Remove 1:57 David Raymond Amos talks about running for public office. What he does not tell you is he was promoted by a Hells Angels Strip club. How is it possible he works for the RCMP and is liked by the Hells Angels Bike club?
TruTHTVSpokaneWA (21 minutes ago) Show Hide Marked as spam Reply I would like to KNOW the SKELETONS in your closet what are they!

    Category
        Entertainment
    License
        Standard YouTube License

http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/nobody-safe-from-edmonton-blogger-charged-with-hate-crime-1.4161015

'Nobody was safe from it': Edmonton blogger charged with rare hate crime targeted individuals across Canada
Police say Barry Winters, 62, made derogatory remarks about race, gender, politics
By Roberta Bell, CBC News Posted: Jun 14, 2017 5:38 PM MT

http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/edmonton-police-lgbtq-hate-blogger-kris-wells-1.4158528

Edmonton police charge blogger with hate crime against prof
'It made me concerned for my own safety,' said Kris Wells, one of the LGBTQ advocates allegedly targeted
By Andrea Huncar, CBC News Posted: Jun 13, 2017 4:32 PM MT

http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/curfew-and-internet-ban-for-b-c-man-who-promoted-hatred-against-jewish-people-online-1.4022817

Curfew and internet ban for B.C. man convicted of online hate against Jewish people
Arthur Topham tells judge it was his 'duty to alert public ... to 'imminent threat of Jewish lobby'
By Wil Fundal, Betsy Trumpener, CBC News Posted: Mar 13, 2017 4:30 PM PT

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9KwvFKL9Tn4

Jay Cullen CBC Radio 2nd Nov 15
LocalRadioFrance
Published on Nov 12, 2015

https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/british-columbia/charges-laid-against-bc-man-who-called-for-death-of-fukushima-researcher/article27136264/

Charges laid against B.C. man who called for death of Fukushima researcher
Mark Hume VANCOUVER — The Globe and Mail Published Friday, Nov. 06, 2015 6:00AM EST

http://charlesotherpersonalitie.blogspot.ca/2017/03/judgement-by-judge-paulette-garnett.html

Thursday, 23 March 2017

Judgement by Judge Paulette Garnett against Blogger is debated by Andre Faust and Charles LeBlanc!!!!

https://youtu.be/miZeKxiSPDY

Posted by Charles Leblanc at 7:06 pm

Tuesday, 18 April 2017
Blogger Charles LeBlanc appeal Civil Suit Case against the City of Fredericton!!!!

https://youtu.be/AL4NFXN6zuY

This was the CBC story on this issue...I just wish the media would have been in the Room to witness what happened...

http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/new-brunswick/paulette-garnett-charles-leblanc-defamation-1.4034343

Charles Leblanc at 4:50 pm

http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/new-brunswick/paulette-garnett-charles-leblanc-defamation-1.4034343

Judge says defamation law will eventually tame internet

Blogger Charles LeBlanc ordered to pay $2,925 in court costs to Fredericton as lawsuit dismissed

By Alan White, CBC News Posted: Mar 21, 2017 3:00 PM AT

A lawsuit against the City of Fredericton by blogger Charles LeBlanc has been dismissed by the Court of Queen's Bench. (Redmond Shannon/CBC)

Court of Queen's Bench Justice Paulette Garnett says defamation laws will eventually tame "the Wild West" of the internet.

Garnett makes the statement in her March 16 decision that dismissed a claim by blogger Charles LeBlanc that the City of Fredericton breached his rights under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

Acrimonious history

LeBlanc has an acrimonious history with the Fredericton Police Force that culminated in a charge of criminal libel under Section 301 of the Criminal Code being laid against LeBlanc for posting on his blog at various times that a Fredericton constable was a "fascist cop" and "sexual pervert."

LeBlanc also used a bullhorn outside the Fredericton police station to state the force employs "sexual perverts" and that the constable who issued him a ticket in 2011 for bicycling without a helmet in the city's downtown was a "faggot."

New Brunswick's Attorney General eventually directed in 2012 that the criminal libel charge against LeBlanc be dropped because several other provinces had found Section 301 of the Criminal Code to be unconstitutional.

In November 2016, LeBlanc was informed by two members of the Edmundston Police Force that he was being investigated for defamatory libel under Section 300 of the Criminal Code following a complaint lodged with the Fredericton force.

Because of its contentious history with LeBlanc, the Fredericton force asked Edmundston police to investigate the complaint.

Child sexual exploitation cited

Meanwhile, LeBlanc initiated the lawsuit against the City of Fredericton and its police force because in the initial criminal libel investigation, Det. Robb Costello made an official request for information about LeBlanc's internet usage by stating he was carrying out a criminal investigation related to child sexual exploitation.

Following a two-day hearing last week, Garnett dismissed LeBlanc's lawsuit, noting that the city filed 17 affidavits in the case and LeBlanc did not file any, so the only evidence before the court was the city's.

"This evidence leads to the conclusion that the actions of the City were done in good faith, that the procedures were in keeping with the policies of the police department, that Mr. LeBlanc was treated in the same way as any other citizen in similar circumstances and that his [Charter] rights were not infringed," Garnett says in her ruling.

Garnett ordered that LeBlanc pay $2,925 to the city in court costs.

'He believes that his right to free speech includes the right to defame others with impunity.' - Paulette Garnett, Court of Queen's Bench justice

However, in her decision Garnett comments on defamation in the internet age.

"Although Mr. LeBlanc clings to his rights under the Charter, it does not appear that he has any concern for the rights of others," Garnett writes. "He believes that his right to free speech includes the right to defame others with impunity.

"One commentator has compared the internet to the Wild West and although the common-law action for defamation may take time to tame it, it will eventually do so. Those who carelessly or viciously attack their neighbours should beware of the Lone Ranger."

LeBlanc v. City of Fredericton, 2017 (CanLII)

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

32 Comments
(However the most Important comment of mine was blocked by CBC out of the gate)

Commenting is now closed for this story.

Frank Johnston

Charles is that irascible "gadfly" essential to the health of the state.

3 months ago

Rod McLeod

This guy again? For someone who complains about KGB style policing he sure illustrates a good case for it.

3 months ago

Matt Steele
When you look at all the incidents involving the Fredericton City Police and Mr. LeBlanc ; then it is obvious that the police has abused its authority on several occasions when dealing with Mr. LeBlanc . This includes such instances as raiding his home , and seizing his computer equipment ; petty charges such as riding a bicycle without a helmet , etc . As this current case proves , it is difficult for a man like Mr. LeBlanc who has limited funds to fight the City of Fredericton who is funded by the taxpayers . It is truly an injustice .

3 months ago

Graham McCormack

@Matt Steele Oh please! This was all his making and as much I was would like to think this will make him go away, I don't see that really happening.

3 months ago

David Raymond Amos
Content disabled.
@Matt Steele Ask yourself an obvious question. If you go to Chucky's Leblanc"s blog you will see that last evening he was reading this CBC article and no doubt all the comments as well. I would bet dimes to dollars all the cops and politicians in Fredericton are reading them too.

If Chucky were truly an honest dude then why does he not defend himself in this comment section instead of allowing people like you to comment on his behalf in his defense?

After all you and Chucky cannot deny that this domain controlled by the Crown is supported by taxpayers who also pay for Chucky's welfare and health care. I know why Chucky does not speak up in a public domain which he can do for free. It quite simply is because he cannot control the comment section and delete his responses if he becomes embarrassed by his own published words. More importantly Chucky cannot block folks he calls "Coward Jerk faces" because in fact that is just exactly what he is.

David Raymond Amos
@David Raymond Amos Interesting that CBC would block that comment I guess just like their blogging buddy Chucky I will have to blog it N'esy Pas?

David Raymond Amos
@David Raymond Amos At the very least CBC should not deny the fact that these are Chucky's words last night about this article about him.

Blogger gives his views on the decision of Court of Queen's Bench Justice Paulette Garnett!

https://youtu.be/UMeC2MFxhmI

I wish we had true Journalists that would investigate issues. The Judge wants me to pay court cost.. < good luck with that one >..but seriously....How much money have the Lawyers made from the Taxpayers to pursue this case? < Trust me it's not over yet >

Must be well over $100,000!!!!

Posted by Charles Leblanc at 10:51 pm

Everybody knows that Chucky and I hate each other with a passion and that I am proud of my Scottish ancestors and that he is not. However the Scottish guy in me agrees that it is kinda strange that CBC knew of the judge's decision before the French dude did. However everybody knows how the Crown plays with the Justice System in New Brunswick N'esy Pas Blaine, David, Justin, Dominic, Brian, Serge and Denis???« less

3 months ago

Rosemary Stones
What a hilarious temper tantrum and all for what -- a bicycle helmet? Too funny. Always makes my day seeing one of these stroppy boys of the net getting a good scolding.

3 months ago

David Raymond Amos
@Rosemary Stones Cease and desist with your fancy British words that we poor Maritmers cannot understand

3 months ago

Mike Archibald

There's a big difference in making these claims when one side admits 17 affidavits and the other side doesn't know what an affidavit is. He represented himself, and all anybody has to do is read Bernard Richard's report on the matter to know that he was not 'treated like any other citizen'.

Even Bernard Richard said that it was pretty specious for an officer to ticket Charles for riding a bicycle without a helmet immediately after Charles had videotaped fredericton police officers beating a guy on the ground.

The incident of the form couldn't be proven to be fraudulant, which doesn't make it not so. The police maintained it was 'an error' that they somehow used the child exploitation form to get the IP address rather than the criminal libel form, which is pretty ludicrous on the face of it.

And even the fredericton police force admitted that they made a mistake in taking Charles computer to read through all his correspondence for a charge which was ultimately dropped.

While I agree that Charles was irresponsible with his comments, the fact is that nobody in their right mind would take such comments seriously, and had Charles the money for a lawyer this case would have turned out far differently. For one thing, Charles comments have ZERO to do with whether the police force infringed on his rights, its interesting that the judge spends more time talking about what HE did rather than what the police did. But its hardly surprising.

3 months ago

David Raymond Amos
@Mike Archibald Did you forget the obvious? This was Chucky's lawsuit attacking the cops.

3 months ago

David Raymond Amos
@Mike Archibald Your old buddy Chucky is reading this stuff. Why does he not respond?

3 months ago

Paul Bourgoin
Judge says defamation law will eventually tame internet AND SANTA CLAUSES LIVIES AT THE NORTH POLE!!!!

3 months ago

David Raymond Amos
@Paul Bourgoin What!!! Where does my favourite fat guy live then?

3 months ago

Marc LeBlanc
Here's some advise on exercising your right to free speech Charles.Buy yourself one of those HD recorders that look like an ipod(complete with fake ear buds).It's truly amazing what MLA's and Crown Corp managers will tell you when you ask the right questions.

3 months ago

David Raymond Amos
@Marc LeBlanc Do tell us.

3 months ago

Rick Aubie
Yup, have fun identifying them through TOR and several cascading IP changers. Yup....great idea!

3 months ago

David Raymond Amos
@Rick Aubie Thats not exactly true. Best that you confer with the CSE and their Yankee and British cohorts within the Five Eyes. They know a few tricks that would astound the most clever of hackers. I know for a fact that the RCMP and the FBI often partake of their cyber space expertise.

However down here in the Maritmes we have are local clowns like Chucky who think that they are untouchable and are surprised when they push things way past too far. Remember this article by CBC?

http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/new-brunswick/charles-leblanc-fredericton-police-libel-1.3853481

I'm waiting for the next shoe to drop signaling that Chucky has finally been properly arrested and charged under Section 300 and 319 of the Canadian Criminal Code.

For the record I also suspect that the nasty little dude attacking the young lady in Moncton will be cornered in short order.merely because it is politically important to do so.

http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/new-brunswick/university-moncton-emails-police-no-contact-1.4033306

Too bad that the RCMP and the FBI did not work so diligently when they knew my kids were being harassed on the Internet since 2005 and it obvious malice continues to this very day.

3 months ago

John Jude

Hooray!
Justice Garnett and the Fredericton and Edmundston police forces.

3 months ago

<3 and="" br="" edmundston="" forces.="" fredericton="" garnett="" justice="" police="" the="">

Jonas Smith

"Court of Queen's Bench Justice Paulette Garnett says defamation laws will eventually tame "the Wild West" of the internet."

Yup.....just like how the trickle down effect was supposed to take care of the middle class............Laughable

3 months ago

Winston Smith

@Jonas Smith
The "Trickle Down Effect" did take care of the middle class. It decimated it.

3 months ago

David Raymond Amos

@Jonas Smith Perhaps Her honour should inform President Trump to smarten up or she will fine him three grand and hang him by his nasty Tweeting thumbs as well

3 months ago

Joseph Vacher

haha i do love seeing people get their come-up-ins

3 months ago

Phil Peters

@Joseph Vacher
He won't have to pay. The province has a program for people who don't have the means. I also think the judge is dreaming in technicolor if she thinks you can tame anyone you can't identify. Mr. LeBlanc's case is special in that regard. Trump's been slandering and defaming non stop. How typical is it that try and make examples of poor people who can't make things go away with their money. Court looks foolish here thinking it has more power than it does.

3 months ago

David Raymond Amos

@Phil Peters The only thing about Chucky's case is that has managed to get away with the obvious malice for so long. Never forget this was his lawsuit that he could not carry forward after he yaaped too much and pissed off his British ghost writer.

3 months ago

<3 and="" br="" edmundston="" forces.="" fredericton="" garnett="" justice="" police="" the="">
<3 and="" br="" edmundston="" forces.="" fredericton="" garnett="" justice="" police="" the="">

Ray Bungay

One can only hope Judge Garnett. The sooner some realize the internet is not as annomyous as they think then yes it will settle Down.

But news media like this one, CBC, could do a better job vetting some of its posters to ensure those you still use made up names stop posting or commenting. When this media and others made the policy change I went right away with my real name! CBC as done a great job but other media needs to come on board.

3 months ago

David Peters

@Ray Bungay

You want to threaten people into silence?

3 months ago

Jonathan Stephenson

@David Peters If you make the post, you own it.

If people are afraid of the ramifications of owning what you post, they should post positive stuff.

Like they say: if you have nothing nice to say, don't say it at all.

3 months ago

Rosemary Stones

@Ray Bungay CBC has not made it fake name free, on the comments section. Not by a long shot. There are several clever fake ones being used. I guess the millenials who might be in charge of vetting are too young to get some of the cultural references.

3 months ago

David Raymond Amos

@Ray Bungay I have always used my real name and yet CBC has blocked me for years for political reasons. Go Figure

3 months ago

David Raymond Amos

@Rosemary Stones Your comment begs the obvious question. Is that your real name?

3 months ago

David Peters

@Jonathan Stephenson

When you have all the corruption that's going on, do your really want to silence people? Pointing out corruption is not nice but needs to be done.

...and who are more vindictive than those responsible for the corruption? Would you want them knowing your address?

3 months ago

David Raymond Amos

@David Peters I do it all the time I am not shy with my name and contact info.<3 and="" br="" edmundston="" forces.="" fredericton="" garnett="" justice="" police="" the="">

<3 and="" br="" edmundston="" forces.="" fredericton="" garnett="" justice="" police="" the="">

<3 and="" br="" edmundston="" forces.="" fredericton="" garnett="" justice="" police="" the=""> 3 months ago

Submission Policy

Note: The CBC does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comments, you acknowledge that CBC has the right to reproduce, broadcast and publicize those comments or any part thereof in any manner whatsoever. Please note that comments are moderated and published according to our submission

http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/new-brunswick/paulette-garnett-slow-judge-1.4170391
<3 and="" br="" edmundston="" forces.="" fredericton="" garnett="" justice="" police="" the="">

Slow judge hitting deadlines — barely

Justice Paulette Garnett's last decision handed down took 5 months and 30 days, just under a 6 month deadline

By Robert Jones, CBC News Posted: Jun 21, 2017 7:00 AM AT

Justice Paulette Garnett has been meeting deadlines, but doing so with a photo finish. (CBC)

<3 and="" br="" edmundston="" forces.="" fredericton="" garnett="" justice="" police="" the="">

Justice	Number
Paulette Garnett	7
Michel Robichaud	2
Judy Clendenning	1
Darrell Stephenson	1
William Grant	1
Larry Landry	1
Fred Ferguson	1
20 others	0

No response from judicial council

A property tax dispute involving this Fredericton office building landed in Justice Paulette Garnett's courtroom last fall. She took 178 days to decide the taxes were reasonable. (CBC)

In Garnett's case, the judicial council made the point that it preferred judgements to be issued as quickly as possible but it did not immediately respond this week to a question about whether consistently running up against — but not crossing — the six month deadline was acceptable.

"Undue delays in rendering decisions can lessen public confidence in our justice system," the council wrote in its original release concerning Garnett.

But although still consistently the slowest judge in New Brunswick to issue decisions, Garnett is also much faster than she used to be.

According to CanLii in 2013 Garnett issued a judgement related to the cancellation of women's hockey at UNB more than 600 days following a one day hearing on the matter. In 2007 she took nearly 800 days to issue a ruling on a dispute involving Elm City Chrysler

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

26 Comments
Commenting is now closed for this story.

stephen blunston

really should have been civil servant , judge cop something .. only jobs I know where cant be fired for lying cheating and being icompetent in your job

4 days ago

Jay Boucher-Langlais

All English judges, except two....just an observation...

4 days ago

Jay Boucher-Langlais

@ thumbs down; can't argue with the facts. And 19 judges out of 32 are English and 11 out of those 14 late decisions are from English judges. So much for the incompetent French getting all the government Jobs. https://www.gnb.ca/cour/04CQB/judiciary-e.asp

4 days ago

David Lutz

@Jay Boucher-Langlais I'd like to compare the work load of the english judges vs. french then. I'd like to see how many english trials vs. french trials there are. Are the french judges handling the same amount of cases... before you start on your crusade you should get the facts.

4 days ago

Tony Petrocelli

@David Lutz , French judges do English as well as French trials. Do not speak of what you know nothing of.

4 days ago

Tony Petrocelli

DARE TO COMPARE, I might add.

4 days ago

Jay Boucher-Langlais

@David Lutz, you are right; French only judges do NO trial at all. I have yet to meet a judge in New Nouveau-Brunswick who speaks only French as they are all bilingual; therefore they do most French trials on top of English trials.

4 days ago

Jay Boucher-Langlais

... as I stated, it's just an observation. If it was the other way around, you guys would be all over it like hyenas on a rotting carcass.

3 days ago

Joe Allaire

@David Lutz - OWNED !!!!!!

3 days ago

David Peters

Short term limits and elections for the positions of Judges, Crown Prosecutors and Police Chiefs would solve the problem.... and would give the voter more say.

4 days ago

Michael McFadden

@David Peters And like the US the job becomes aligned with a political party and their philosophy. The process becomes aligned with the supporters with the most money. No thank you, we just have to see the wingnuts that get elected to these positions in the US to take a pass on that. Now renewable contracts based on performance might be an alternative to look at, but again it has it's drawbacks.

3 days ago

David Peters

@Michael McFadden

Difference is, their system is much more open where you can make a judgement call on their personalities and how they perform(comes out in an election)...not so here. Here its one-sided. The other side, politically, is not represented.

The only argument for our current system is inertia and apathy.

3 days ago

Paul Bourgoin

Don't forget the Judge might be wrong but he or she is still the judge.
My question is; Who is the Boss, the overseer, the employer or their Friends?

4 days ago

William Roberts

I have NO faith in the justice system of this province or country. It comes down to who can afford the best lawyers and these judges of course were once lawyers. Even the ruling of a duly appointed jury has NO weight it would seem. It is a joke..... not a very funny JOKE

4 days ago

David Peters

@William Roberts

Not to mention the god like status of Judges, Crown Prosecutors and Police Chiefs...virtually unaccountable an untouchable. Voter/citizen has virtually no input or say.

4 days ago

Matt Steele

Sadly , this is what happens when people are hired based on WHO they know ; and not WHAT they know . Politicians , and government in general , never seem to understand that if they make a bad appointment based on political connections ; then that hire will be around for 30 to 35 years . It is true not just in this case , but in many cases where government employees are not suited for their positions , but they slide along doing very little work while receiving big salaries on the taxpayers dime.

4 days ago

William Roberts

@Matt Steele Like winning a lottery based on who you support climbing the ladder?

4 days ago

stephen blunston

@Matt Steele I so agree it why this province is in trouble all about who you know , never putting the person with the best credentials in place, just look at nb power nb liquor well I bet most crown corps

4 days ago

Murray Brown

Pardon the pun... But there was obviously bad judgement in the appointment of this judge.

If you have a hard time making a decision maybe you should make at least one decision for the good of judicial system. Resign your post and allow somebody who's expedient to take your place. The right to speediness is essential in the judicial system.

4 days ago

William Roberts

@Murray Brown Justice delayed is justice denied.

4 days ago

David Peters

@Murray Brown

Short term limits are need here badly.

4 days ago

William Roberts

@David Peters That would just be another excuse for trail delays and decision making. Perhaps we should move to computers to render the final decisions and leave emotions and political influence out of the final verdict. We could save a fortune. I once saw a decision postponed because the fool charged forgot his glasses and could read the charges against him . Not sure what his lawyer was being paid for.

4 days ago

Tony Petrocelli

@William Roberts, the computer says you're guilty. No appeal; after all, justice delayed is justice denied. Off to Jail you Go!

4 days ago

Mary MacKenzie

What is her explanation for taking so long? There has to be a reason.

4 days ago

William Roberts

@Mary MacKenzie A very busy social life no doubt. Who would have time to weigh the evidence in a trail when other matters are more important? A rush to judgement in many of these cases would not be a same day ruling. If you are poor that is what you get. If you can afford to challenge you need to max out on the clock.

4 days ago

David Peters

@Mary MacKenzie

She is a Judge, and an appointed one at that, with no coming election or term limit. She doesn't have to explain herself.

Short term limits and elections would change all that.

4 days ago

Submission Policy
Note: The CBC does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comments, you acknowledge that CBC has the right to reproduce, broadcast and publicize those comments or any part thereof in any manner whatsoever. Please note that comments are moderated and published according to our submission guidelines.

http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/new-brunswick/justice-paulette-garnett-chastised-for-very-late-decisions-1.2807772

<3 and="" br="" edmundston="" forces.="" fredericton="" garnett="" justice="" police="" the="">

Justice Paulette Garnett chastised for 'very late' decisions

Canadian Judicial Council says Justice Paulette Garnett will not face discliplinary action

By Robert Jones, CBC News Posted: Oct 22, 2014 6:14 AM AT

A New Brunswick judge, who routinely kept parties waiting months, sometimes years, for decisions, has been mildly chastised by the Canadian Judicial Council for her conduct, 15 years after the lengthy delays first surfaced.

Justice Paulette Garnett will face no disciplinary action for bogging down the judicial system with delayed decisions. (CBC)

Court of Queen's Bench Justice Paulette Garnett was the subject of a complaint by an unknown person to the judicial council last spring, a year after CBC News reported on several of her overdue decisions.

But she will face no disciplinary action for bogging down the judicial system, according to a decision released on Tuesday.

"The judge had been very late in issuing reasons in a number of cases," the council said in a press release.
"Undue delays in rendering decisions can lessen public confidence in our justice system. ... The judge has acknowledged that she needs to do better in future, She is working to ensure that this situation does not happen again."

Garnett was appointed in 1998 and almost immediately began violating judicial council guidelines, which call for delivering judgments within six months of the conclusion of a hearing.

One of her first cases, a claim for back rent at the Bathurst Supermall made in August of 1998 wasn't decided on for nearly 13 months.

That became a familiar pattern to lawyers and parties in her courtroom for years to come.
In 2005, she presided over a one-day hearing between Fredericton's old Elm City Chrysler dealership, its owners and their bank to resolve questionable transactions. She delivered a decision two years and two months later.

In 2012, she took so long to decide whether employees of Fredericton's Jones Masonry had properly unionized, Gordon Petrie, the company's lawyer, eventually died.

Garnett's decision approving the union was eventually made a month after Petrie's funeral and 15 months after the original hearing, by which time the workers who had voted for the union had all left the company.

David Smith, Chief Justice of the Court of Queen's Bench, put Justice Paulette Garnett on restricted courtroom duty in 2013. (Court of Queen's Bench)

New Brunswick Chief Justice David Smith finally intervened early in 2013, restricting cases going to Garnett until she brought outstanding decisions up to date.

One of those cases involved an attempt by former University of New Brunswick women's hockey players to challenge the cancellation of their varsity team in 2008.

It landed in Garnett`s courtroom in the summer of 2011 and she took nearly two years to decide part of the case could continue.

The decision took so long it became an issue at the next hearing when the university unsuccessfully tried to use it to argue former players were now too old to get a team back.

But even after the chief justice's interventions and publicity surrounding delays in her courtroom, Garnett continued to deliver slow rulings.

In August 2013, the dispute over who should win an NB Liquor agency store in Hanwell landed in front of her, a case she took more than seven months to rule on. That case apparently triggered the complaint which the judicial council finally acted on.

Garnett will work 'very diligently' to get decisions done

Robert Pidgeon, the senior associate chief justice of the Superior Court of Quebec, dealt with the complaint about Garnett's tardiness and a second complaint by Fredericton resident Andre Murray about Garnett's "attitude and demeanour" during his time in her court.

Norman Sabourin, the judicial council`s executive director, said Garnett had satisfied Pidgeon that she has improved and noted she had apologized to Murray for being "abrupt" with Murray.

'We shouldn't have to wait for a citizen to make a complaint before inquiring into the conduct of a judge.' - Norman Sabourin, Canadian Judicial Council

"There was an undertaking by the judge to get some coaching and to work very diligently to get her decisions done," said Sabourin.

"The judge acknowledged that her conduct had been at issue. She made an undertaking it would not happen again. Chief Justice Pidgeon decided it was not a case that needed to go further."

Natalie LeBlanc, the registrar of New Brunswick's Court of Queen's Bench, said neither Garnett nor Smith would speak about the council's decision.

"I am advised that no further comment will be offered," LeBlanc told CBC News in an email.

Garnett`s extreme tardiness has been a sore spot in New Brunswick legal circles for 15 years and Sabourin says the case shows the need for the judicial council to respond to problem judges more quickly than it has in the past.

"We shouldn't have to wait for a citizen to make a complaint before inquiring into the conduct of a judge," said Sabourin.

"We think there should be the ability of a council member or the executive director to say, 'There's a concern here, there seems to be something happening and we`re going to initiate a review of that judge's conduct."

<3 and="" br="" edmundston="" forces.="" fredericton="" garnett="" justice="" police="" the="">0 Comments
Commenting is now closed for this story.

David Raymond Amos Round 3

Sunday 25 June 2017

Justice Paulette Garnett in her lightning fast decision dismissing Chucky Leblanc's lawsuit warned of common-law action for defamation and "beware of the Lone Ranger" N'esy Pas?

Judge says defamation law will eventually tame internet

Blogger Charles LeBlanc ordered to pay $2,925 in court costs to Fredericton as lawsuit dismissed

Acrimonious history

Child sexual exploitation cited

Slow judge hitting deadlines — barely

Justice Paulette Garnett's last decision handed down took 5 months and 30 days, just under a 6 month deadline

Related Stories

No response from judicial council

Justice Paulette Garnett chastised for 'very late' decisions

Canadian Judicial Council says Justice Paulette Garnett will not face discliplinary action

Garnett will work 'very diligently' to get decisions done

No comments:

Post a Comment