Thursday 14 March 2024

Overhaul governance of long-term-care sector, advocate recommends

 

Overhaul governance of long-term-care sector, advocate recommends

Kelly Lamrock says local, regional authorities can provide better patient-centred care

New Brunswick's child, youth and seniors' advocate is calling for a new governance system for the province's struggling long-term-care sector.

Kelly Lamrock says putting nursing and special care homes under smaller, local authorities — while still ensuring provincial funding and standards — would make it easier to match patients with the care they need. 

A range of challenges plague the system now, from scarce staffing resources to inadequate funding to provide the needed hours of care, he said in a 198-page report released Wednesday.

At the same time, hundreds of people, mostly seniors, are getting care in hospitals while they wait for long-term care accommodation, even though hospital care is far more expensive and less tailored to their needs. 

WATCH | 'I understand why Mrs. Baker cried': Lamrock on bananas and the big picture:
 

Seniors advocate Kelly Lamrock calls for changes to long-term care

8 hours ago
Duration 1:38
Child, youth and seniors' advocate Kelly Lamrock uses the example of a senior in hospital-based care to argue for patient-centred care.

Creating long-term care authorities that are "integrated, nimble, community-based, and administratively flexible" would make it easier for local managers to communicate with hospital staff about patients, the report says.

"Currently, communication occurs between two large, centralized bureaucracies with highly distinct subunits," Lamrock wrote. 

"The long-term-care authority can develop a structured framework that outlines the roles, responsibilities, and mobility between types of care and would define how they work together to create an integrated approach to care."

The Higgs government has adopted a more centralized, provincial-level planning approach to health care, arguing there needs to be better co-ordination of scarce resources between different parts of the province.

A woman with blond hair wearing dark pink lipstick and a teal shirt. Jan Seely, president of New Brunswick Special Care Home Association, said many of the problems Lamrock identified sounded familiar to her. (Ed Hunter/CBC)

Lamrock rejected the idea that decentralizing long-term care might not make sense given that philosophy.

Currently, patients moving from one level of care to another need an entirely new, time-consuming assessment from a social worker, which he said could be eliminated by a local authority. 

"It's not about more administration. It's about administration that is flexible and integrated and close to the patient," he told reporters at a news conference.

In a statement, a spokesperson for Social Development Minister Jill Green said the government "will be taking the necessary time to review this sizable report and once finished will be able to comment further."

The two opposition party leaders in the legislature agreed with the idea of decentralization though they did not commit to implementing Lamrock's exact proposal.

Liberal Leader Susan Holt said the system needs to be more responsive to individual patient needs, and "that flexibility can come with a more decentralized model." 

A women with blond hair and blue eyes. She is wearing a dark red shirt, a black cardigan and beaded earrings. Liberal Leader Susan Holt said the system needs to be more responsive to individual patient needs, and 'that flexibility can come with a more decentralized model.' (Ed Hunter/CBC)

Green Leader David Coon said the proposal was interesting "as long as these don't become bureaucratic entities, but really nimble." 

The report examined pressures on nursing homes and special care homes, as well as home-care programs and the situation of patients now in hospitals who are waiting for long-term care and receiving what is called an "alternative level of care." 

Lamrock used an anecdote about a banana to illustrate the flaws he found in the system.

A tearful senior waiting in hospital for a long-term-care space told a nursing student she'd been trying for a week to get her regular morning banana included with her breakfast. 

David Coon speaks to reporters in the rotunda of the New Brunswick Legislature. Green Leader David Coon said the proposal was interesting 'as long as these don’t become bureaucratic entities, but really nimble.' (Ed Hunter/CBC)

"It sounds minor. I mean why am I starting a report on a $3-billion health-care system with a banana?" Lamrock said.

"It captures the urgency for me very well, that helplessness.

"If we're too helpless to get our own banana, we need somebody to care about what it means to us. We need somebody to understand that it's more than just a banana, that somebody sees us and knows who we are."

The report recommends new service standards for people in alternative level care — so-called ALC patients — in hospitals and the tabling in the legislature of a costed plan with "hard targets" for reducing those numbers.

The report was praised by people working in the sector.

"I was trying to keep myself in my seat. I wanted to stand up and applaud, actually," said Jan Seely, president of the New Brunswick Special Care Home Association.

Many of the problems Lamrock identified, including the silos in the system that have spread resources "all over the map," sounded familiar to her, she said.

A man with grey hair wearing square glasses and a crewneck sweater overtop a dress shirt. Ken Pike, the director of social policy with Inclusion New Brunswick, said he was happy Lamrock identified that there are almost 2,000 adults with disabilities living in special care homes. (Ed Hunter/CBC)

"I've heard it echoed in the halls of many meetings we've had with our key partners. … It seemed like he was speaking our language," she said. 

Ken Pike, the director of social policy with Inclusion New Brunswick, said he was happy Lamrock identified that there are almost 2,000 adults with disabilities living in special care homes, some of whom could live and work in their communities if they had proper support. 

The report recommends modernizing services and financial support for people with disabilities.

"Those are the things we wanted to see reflected in the report and we're very pleased that they were," said Pike.

The report also recommends other measures, including more support for home modifications, and flexible benefits so that people have more incentives and ability to stay in their homes.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR


Jacques Poitras

Provincial Affairs reporter

Jacques Poitras has been CBC's provincial affairs reporter in New Brunswick since 2000. He grew up in Moncton and covered Parliament in Ottawa for the New Brunswick Telegraph-Journal. He has reported on every New Brunswick election since 1995 and won awards from the Radio Television Digital News Association, the National Newspaper Awards and Amnesty International. He is also the author of five non-fiction books about New Brunswick politics and history.

 
 
 
43 Comments

 
David Amos
Higgy knows that Lamrock has being ignoring one senior's concerns for way past too long 
 
 
David Amos 
Reply to David Amos 
I wonder if Lamrock knows how I finally got a Health Care Card
 
 
David Amos  
Reply to David Amos 
and a new doctor

 
 
David Amos  
Lamrock should review his files 
 
 
David Amos  
Reply to David Amos 
For the public record Lamrock received Hard Copy of some of my concerns on June 24th 2004 and I have been keeping him updated ever since
 
 
 
Al Clark  

Kelly loading up on potassium? 
 
 
Al Clark
Reply to Al Clark
Or ready for faytene if she shows up?   
 
 
David Amos
Reply to Al Clark 
Faytene who?  
 
 

Lou Bell  
And we get no commitment from the leader of teh liberals . Means " ain't gonna happen " !  
 
 
Jim Lake 
Reply to Lou Bell
Finally sounds like you’re willing to acknowledge the Higgs “CORservatives” won’t be forming the next government … but give the opposition the credit they deserve for not committing to things until they’ve had the opportunity to fully review the very lengthy report - sounds like a very prudent response.  
 
 
David Amos
Reply to Jim Lake
Dream on  
 
 
 
Matt Steele    
Yep , more layers of government , and lots more taxpayer cash to be squandered on social experiments . Hiring political appointments like this supposedly Advocate , has been Premier Higgs biggest mistakes and downfall ; and it could very well cost him the next election.
 
 
Jim Lake 
Reply to Matt Steele  
Not even remotely accurate. 
 
 
David Amos
Reply to Matt Steele  
It may cost him a majority put Higgy will still get his hat trick 
 
 
 
 
Jimmy Cochrane 
This guy again?

I want a paying job as an “advocate”. 

 

Jim Lake 
Reply to Jimmy Cochrane   
He’s the only one in this government that objectively analyzes 1) what’s going on with, and 2) how our government is failing, the vulnerable populations in our province … he actually communicates with New Brunswickers (unlike the premier and his ministers) and lays out well thought out and logical recommendations … the fact they go against how governments have operated for years does not mean they aren't good solutions under which all New Brunswickers will eventually benefit. 
 
 
David Amos
Reply to Jim Lake
I bet you liked him when he was the Attorney General in a red coat   
 
 
David Amos
Reply to Jimmy Cochrane 
Me too




Bill Watson 
I put a lot of the blame of the failure of long-term care homes in Ontario on the adult children of the elderly people requiring the care.  
 
 
David Amos
Reply to Bill Watson
I believe a lot of "Adult Children" still require day care and their elder parents basements to camp in



 
Roger devry
I like bananas..... they have appeal! 
 
 
David Amos
Reply to Roger devry
Thats not the best part 


 
 
SarahRose Werner
I have to wonder if "smaller, local authorities" are really the answer to the number of seniors who are stuck in hospitals. My understanding is that many (most?) of them are there because they're determined to wait for beds in local care and nursing homes rather than accepting beds further away. If everything is managed locally, who is even trying to match seniors with beds outside the local authority area?
 
 
Bob Smith
Reply to SarahRose Werner 
Is it the seniors who are determined or is it family members who want them close for their own comfort? Methinks the latter. For too long, hospitals are being used by some families as defacto long term care homes for seniors to save themselves money and energy needed to care for the elderly.
 
 
Koffi Babone
Reply to Bob Smith
No, long term care facilities are not able to take in more seniors. There is a long waiting list before they are admitted.  
 
 
Rosco holt
Reply to Bob Smith
Many senior have special needs due to their health issues. Families taking care of seniors don't get much help from government(s) and it's an around the clock job.
 
 
SarahRose Werner
Reply to Bob Smith
Seniors "living" in hospitals while waiting for LTC beds are charged a hefty per-diem fee. It's more expensive than living in a nursing home.

Also, as someone who comes from a family where dementia is common in old age, I can tell you that taking care someone with dementia requires both training and far more energy than anyone has who also works, as most adults do.

 
Don Corey
Reply to Bob Smith
So you think seniors requiring long term care want to be located to a home that is a significant distance away from where they lived, and worked, and from the family members who would be visiting them? You do realize that the vast majority are still able to think for themselves?
 
 
Rosco holt
Reply to Bob Smith
There is also the issue if the long term care home is situated is far from family it makes it difficult to monitor the elder's well being. Some long term care home sedate their residents.
 
 
Bob Smith
Reply to Koffi Babone 
Nope. There are beds available but not enough staff to support them. The home admins stated that a short time ago. 
 
 
Bob Smith
Reply to Rosco holt
If you are claiming all families regularly visit seniors in long term care homes, you're incorrect. 
 

David Amos  
Reply to Don Corey
Methinks Lamrock was once our Attorney General N'esy Pas?  
 
 
 

William Peters
The current system wants one man in charge who can pressure another one man in charge of healthcare with the weight of his exorbitant salary to cut and cut and cut until there is nothing left. If we want better healthcare, that starts with getting more diffuse political power. Get it out of the ideologues' hands who think our economy is about economic productivity numbers. The economy is about the social outcomes, and it has never been poorer than it is now despite the surpluses. Care, when it is provided, comes from the interaction between people who are not strictly economic entities in to extract a salary. We should care that NBers aren't being care and that business men in no need of help are. They will leave you the minute they see the profit motive vanish. 
 
 
David Webb 
Reply to William Peters
Just imagine in NB what about $2 MILLION PER DAY going to education and health care could do, rather than paying interest on the debt. The takers don't care since they pay minimal or no tax. The makers (So called middle class) on the other hand are in deep trouble because of federal policies chasing away investment in the country, failed $10 day child care, failing dental care and soon to be failing pharmacare and assorted added taxes, carbon, booze, clean energy all with federal sales tax added on. And how many billion going to pay interest on the debt, from massive overspending? $11.3 BILLION in third quarter 2023 alone, so you don't have to look it up. Feds and provinces expected to pay $81.8 billion for 2023-2024. Sustainable? I think not!
 
 
Don Corey
Reply to David Webb  
Well put, but incomprehensible to all the lefty free spenders.  
 
 
Eugene Peabody 
Reply to David Webb     
Is that you Mr.Higgs? 
 
 
MR Cain
Reply to David Webb
Increase population, increase demand, increase revenue, decrease in debt. Invest in people, and the return is tenfold.  
 
 
David Amos  
Reply to Don Corey
At least bananas are relatively cheap  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

No comments:

Post a Comment