J.D. Irving presents wind farm plans to rowdy public meeting
Residents of Juniper area loudly shared concerns over project
Residents had their first chance to speak face to face with J.D. Irving project leads about the Brighton Wind Farm in a meeting that devolved into a disorderly spectacle with audience members shouting over and heckling company experts trying to answer their questions.
The $550-million project, financed solely by JDI, would be the largest in the province, with 58 wind turbines, slightly larger than the Kent Hills Wind Farm outside Moncton.
JDI plans to break ground next year, and power would be sold to N.B. Power to help decarbonize the province's energy grid, according to the company website set up for the project. The property is already owned by the company and is the site of active forestry.
About 30 company officials and experts gathered to show off poster boards to explain different aspects of the project in a community hall followed by a Q&A session.
Concerns, some not scientifically proven, about how the project will affect the water supply, residents and wildlife, accusations of biased environmental studies, and allegations of poor communication from the company were all brought up by people in the crowd of about 100.
A spokesperson for Hatch, the company hired by JDI for the environmental consultation, told the crowd that studies to date have shown no significant impacts on animals or humans from the proposed project.
"From this session, I think the most important thing is just making sure that we answer all of the questions that the community has, and address any information they may have heard elsewhere," Dion Hanrahan, JDI's vice-president of energy, said in an interview before the meeting.
He said residents would be welcome to follow up via an email address that the company set up for the project.
Lone supporter speaks out at meeting
Only one member of the crowd, David Hunter of Florenceville-Bristol, attempted to speak in favour of the project before being interrupted by others, leading him to shout back.
"The world is in a climate crisis, and here people are doing this not-in-my-backyard syndrome stuff. This project is the way forward to decarbonize our electrical grid," Hunter shouted as he turned his back on the JDI panel to address the crowd.
In an interview after the Q&A session, Hunter apologized for raising his voice but said he viewed many of the concerns raised as "very subtle," and called for people to look at the bigger picture.
"I was like a snowball in hell. There was an incredible amount of negativity and cynicism and sarcasm about this project," Hunter said.
David Hunter from Florenceville-Bristol was the only audience member who spoke in favour of the project during the Q&A session. (Shane Fowler/CBC)
He called some people's concerns about noise from the wind farm "laughable," questioning why they took issue with that but not the constant loud noises from ATVs he constantly hears in the area.
"As a citizen of the planet, I'm in favour of more green energy, especially here in New Brunswick."
Residents say emails not answered, JDI says they were
Many residents audibly groaned and began shouting anytime the email address was mentioned as a way to get answers that the panel could not immediately provide.
People shouted that they only received automated responses, and others disputed JDI's claim that the company distributed flyers about the project and Thursday's meeting to hundreds of people in the area.
"What I can say about the emails, there are a number of us on this team who read every single one," said Renée Morais, JDI's director of environmental affairs.
The meeting was at times tense, with audience members shouting over J.D. Irving project leads and refuting their claims that emails were responded to. (Shane Fowler/CBC)
She said "dozens" of emails have been responded to, and that only three currently needed responses.
When asked what it would take to stop the project, Morais said following the environmental impact assessment submitted in April, the project is now being reviewed by regulators at all three levels of government. The EIA is available publicly on the project website.
If approved, "JDI had full intention to proceed with this project," Morais said.
Several residents posted protest signs outside the community hall with messages like, "Stop the war on nature" and referred to the wind turbines as the "58 monsters."
Leslie Noel Butler, who lives on South Ridge Road, near Brighton Mountain, spoke out against Hunter's claim that people voicing concern were NIMBYs. Many of those in attendance are part of the South Knowlesville Land Trust Project, an off-grid commune.
"Now the land that they live in and love so much is going to be changed unalterably without them having any say," Noel Butler said.
Leslie Noel Butler lives near Brighton Mountain and expressed concern over accusations of NIMBYism from Hunter. (Shane Fowler/CBC)
"So I think the accusation of NIMBYism is a little unfair, considering they don't use any of the resources that Irving is seeking to harvest from their world."
She also expressed concern about JDI clear cutting, which she said has already caused negative effects in the region.
JDI officials said only 447 hectares would need to be cleared to build bases for the turbines and new roads.
Aiyana Rahhali asked why the wind farm couldn't be placed on land that was already clear cut or farm fields. (Shane Fowler/CBC)
Aiyana Rahhali is involved with the off-grid commune and was one of the younger attendees to speak out during the meeting.
"This is my home, this is my future, and I care about my land and the land that I grew up on," Rahhali said, adding that she was pleasantly surprised by how many people showed up Thursday.
"I'm not against windmills per se, I'm against where they're putting it on that mountain behind my house," she said, questioning why the wind farm couldn't go in a field or land already clear cut.
No bird migratory paths over mountain, company says
When asked why this location was chosen Hanrahan told the crowd that studies had found the mountain to have high wind levels, and existing logging roads would minimize the need for any additional clear cutting for the project.
The company also has trained staff who visit areas being clear cut to make sure no endangered animals or vegetation are harmed and no dens are in the area, Morais said in an interview.
Concerns about birds are valid, Morais added.
Brighton Mountain is already the site of active forestry, Morais said. (Shane Fowler/CBC)
"I think if a bird were to encounter a wind turbine blade, I'm not going to lie, it may not end well for that bird," she said.
JDI has been conducting bird flight pattern studies on Brighton Mountain for a year and a half, she said.
"What we are seeing based on some of the preliminary information is that we're thankful that we're not on a major migratory path," she said.
An adaptive bird and bat management plan would also be approved by government regulators and followed for the project, she said.
"Now the land that they live in and love so much is going to be changed unalterably without them having any say," Noel Butler said.
"So I think the accusation of NIMBYism is a little unfair, considering they don't use any of the resources that Irving is seeking to harvest from their world."
She also expressed concern about JDI clear cutting, which she said has already caused negative effects in the region.
Perhaps the lady and I should talk
David Amos
I know the feeling
They say "only" so easily EH?
“ Several residents posted protest signs outside the community hall with messages like, "Stop the war on nature" and referred to the wind turbines as the "58 monsters."
J.D. Irving wind farm worries some, company promises more consultation
Woodstock First Nation chief says he's concerned about impact on migratory birds, wildlife
As plans for a J.D. Irving wind farm loom in western New Brunswick, some residents and a nearby First Nation are speaking out against the project.
The Brighton Mountain Wind Farm, with 58 turbines, will break ground in 2025 near the small community of Juniper and within the boundaries of Hartland and Carleton North municipalities.
J.D. Irving spokesperson Anne McInerney said in an email statement that the company is planning a public meeting for area residents in August, something local mayors support.
"I want people to have answers, I want their questions to be answered and I think information is important," said Hartland Mayor Tracey DeMerchant.
She said J.D. Irving held a meeting recently for the Western Valley Regional Service Commission so local government officials and mayors could inform their residents.
When asked if she supports the project, DeMerchant said, "Like everyone else, I want to make sure that it's done properly, no one wants to see things disturbed in a way that's not healthy."
Carleton North Mayor Andrew Harvey said he's also been hearing concerns from residents.
Carleton North Mayor Andrew Harvey said he supports the project as long as consultation takes place and environmental requirements are met. (Mike Heenan/CBC)
"We suggested they needed to talk directly to the proponent to get those questions answered. We don't have any of the information about any of that," Harvey said.
"We do agree that there needs to be public engagement on this, and the proponent has agreed to have these meetings, and we've conveyed that to that group."
Harvey said he personally supports the project, noting the company's history as an employer in the area.
"But everybody needs to be held accountable in terms of protecting the environment, so that's what that process will do, and then the [environmental impact assessment] will have a good, robust discussion about all these issues that may come up," Harvey said.
Clarissa Andersen, a spokesperson for the provincial Department of Environment and Local Government, said in an email that public engagement is required as part of the project's ongoing environmental impact assessment (EIA).
"Public engagement is still underway for this project and the proponent has not yet submitted their summary report," Andersen said.
"No decision will be made regarding the EIA until all relevant issues identified by the TRC, First Nations and the public during the determination review have been addressed."
First Nation against project
Woodstock First Nation Chief Tim Paul said J.D. Irving has not done proper consultation in his view, and he wishes that his community and the Wolastoqey Nation had been involved in the ongoing environmental impact assessment.
"At this stage of the game, I can tell you that Woodstock would be opposed to it, opposed to the project," Paul said.
He said he has concerns about migratory birds and wildlife on the project site, along with the possibility of Indigenous archeological sites or traditional medicine on the property.
A map showing the location of Brighton Mountain in western New Brunswick. (Submitted by J.D. Irving)
"There's all kinds of impacts that have to be looked at through the full process, and we have to be part of that process. When you're left out of that process, how do you meaningfully consult when you're not even involved?" Paul asked.
McInerney said First Nations were notified of the project in August 2023, and directed questions about Indigenous consultation to the province.
David Kelly, the provincial spokesperson for Indigenous Affairs, added that the environmental impact assessment, "provides all First Nations with the opportunity to make submissions on the potential impact to their rights.
"The province did notify all First Nations directly about the project and provided them with information," Kelly said.
McInerney said J. D. Irving has visited 250 residences in the area to discuss the project and share pamphlets, and has set up a website outlining the project. There's also an email people can use to submit questions.
Nearby resident concerned about project
Juniper resident Stephanie Thornton sent an email to provincial and municipal government officials urging them to stop the project.
Thornton said she's an animal-rights activist who is concerned about deforestation and wildlife losing their home.
A map showing where each of the 58 turbines will be spaced out on the project site, marked by numbers. A resident in the area says she's concerned about land being cleared for the turbines to be built. (Submitted by J.D. Irving)
The website J.D. Irving set up for the project estimates that just 0.3 per cent of the property will have to be cleared for the project, or about 227 hectares. The company also said existing forest roads will be used as much as possible for construction.
"Why choose a site that's heavily forested when you could use something that maybe doesn't have so much impact on animals and the woods?" Thornton asked.
A Facebook group for residents to discuss the project and share concerns has attracted just under 500 members.
Friday 3 May 2024
J.D. Irving gets into wind farm business with $550M project in western N.B.
J.D. Irving gets into wind farm business with $550M project in western N.B.
Project aims to sell energy to N.B. Power, but no agreement yet
J.D. Irving Ltd. is taking a leap into the green energy business with plans for a 58-turbine wind farm.
The Brighton Mountain wind farm, near the hamlet of Juniper in Carleton County, will break ground in 2025, pending regulatory approval, the company has announced.
"The power will be sold to N.B. Power which will contribute to decarbonizing the province," says a website created to promote the project.
But there are still some loose ends, as the project needs regulatory approvals and an agreement with N.B. Power to purchase power.
N.B. Power spokesperson D'Arcy Walsh said in an email that N.B. Power does not currently have any power-purchasing agreements with J.D. Irving for the project, "and therefore it would be too early to comment on any aspects of the project at this time."
J.D. Irving estimates the wind farm will reduce New Brunswick's reliance on fossil fuels by about nine per cent. (Submitted by J.D. Irving)
In 2023, the utility invited proposals for green energy projects in the province with an expectation to be live by 2027, the same timeline Brighton Mountain now gives.
With 58 turbines and a capacity for 350 megawatts, it would decrease the New Brunswick energy grid's reliance on fossil fuels by roughly nine per cent, according to the project website.
But the launch has also been somewhat lowkey. There has been no news release from the province, which normally highlights major business investments and projects of all kinds.
Information session planned
The area for the turbines falls into the municipalities of both Hartland and Carleton North, but neither mayor knew enough about the project to grant an interview.
When reached by phone, Hartland Mayor Tracey DeMerchant said this was the first she was hearing of the project. Carleton North Mayor Andrew Harvey said he's waiting for an information session later this month where he expects to learn more.
Government spokesperson Nick Brown said Natural Resources and Energy Development Minister Mike Holland was unavailable for an interview Thursday but provided an email statement from him.
"As outlined in our Clean Energy Strategy, we intend to significantly grow our wind power generation over the next 12 years," Holland said in the statement, adding the province established goals for N.B. Power to acquire new cost-effective wind power deals.
Holland went on to say "there is a process in place for developing wind farms," and Brighton Mountain still needs to complete a environmental impact assessment and reach a power-purchasing agreement with N.B. Power.
A map showing where each of the 58 turbines will be spaced out on the project site, marked by numbers. (Submitted by J.D. Irving)
The Brighton Mountain website touts the project as helping reach an agreement between the federal government, New Brunswick and Nova Scotia in October 2023 to phase out coal-fired generation in the electricity sector by 2030, net-zero electricity, or no greenhouse gas emissions, by 2035 and a net-zero economy by 2050.
"Securing clean energy sources to support traditional industries within N.B., such as pulp and paper, will help to maintain the longevity and viability of current JDI operations throughout the province," the environmental impact assessment says.
The project is described as the company's "first wind development project as a proponent," but the assessment says J.D. Irving affiliate companies have experience building and maintaining turbines.
Green leader supports project
Green Party Leader David Coon said the JDI project would be a "big deal" for the province, given wind farm's large size and the fact it's owned by a New Brunswick-based company.
The province only has one wind farm of similar size, the Kent Hills operation near Moncton.
"N.B. Power needs to have a considerable amount of renewable energy come onto the grid this decade in order to meet their requirements with the phase-out of the coal plant in Belledune," Coon said.
Green Leader David Coon calls the project a big deal for New Brunswick but says an agreement with N.B. Power is crucial. (Sam Farley/CBC)
"So this fits right into their plan."
Coon said he is worried there is no agreement with N.B. Power yet.
"My only concern is that we hear from N.B. Power that there is a power-purchase agreement, they've agreed on a price, so that this will go forward without a hitch."
Project not intended for federal carbon credit
JDI spokesperson Anne McInerney said no one was available for an interview because the project is in the early application phase, but she offered to answer questions over email.
Asked if JDI would use the project to apply for the federal greenhouse gas offset credit system, designed to motivate corporations to invest in green energy, McInerney said in an email "that's not the intention."
She said the company's "focus is on our application and approval process," when asked if the project represented a new direction for J.D. Irving.
200 jobs, only 20 permanent
The website says more than 200 jobs will be created during construction, but the 475-page assessment reveals the number of full-time jobs, once the project is operating, will be 20.
The first phase of construction will be complete by 2027, at a cost of about $550 million, the website says. A frequently asked questions section addresses concerns residents may raise, saying that the project will not decrease property values, be loud when operating, or disrupt wildlife.
The turbines are just over 200 metres tall and have an estimated service life of 25 years. After that timeline is reached, the assessment says, the structures could either be taken down or J.D. Irving can consult with government to "extend the life of the project."
A map showing the location of Brighton Mountain in western New Brunswick. (Submitted by J.D. Irving)
The project will also see construction of two substations and a terminal station to tie into the existing energy grid, but an existing network of company logging roads in the area already provides access, the website says.
Nineteen environmental studies were done for the project in 2023 and another 16 are planned this year. These studies look at species in the area, wetlands and vegetation.
The location is very rural, and there is only one full-time residence, just under a kilometre from a planned turbine. Some remote cabins and shacks are also nearby, the report says.
Round One
I trust that all the lawyers who intervene in the EUB hearings know why I shook my head as I read that
"As outlined in our Clean Energy Strategy, we intend to significantly grow our wind power generation over the next 12 years," Holland said in the statement, adding the province established goals for N.B. Power to acquire new cost-effective wind power deals.
Holland went on to say "there is a process in place for developing wind farms," and Brighton Mountain still needs to complete a environmental impact assessment and reach a power-purchasing agreement with N.B. Power."
Yea Right
https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/newfoundland-labrador/massive-wind-farm-pitched-for-labrador-1.620146
Now fast forward to today
https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/newfoundland-labrador/world-energy-gh2-wind-farm-environmental-impact-1.6944733"extend the life of the project." = Rust In Place
Round Two
I trust that all the lawyers who intervene in the EUB hearings know why I shook my head as I read that
"As outlined in our Clean Energy Strategy, we intend to significantly grow our wind power generation over the next 12 years," Holland said in the statement, adding the province established goals for N.B. Power to acquire new cost-effective wind power deals.
Holland went on to say "there is a process in place for developing wind farms," and Brighton Mountain still needs to complete a environmental impact assessment and reach a power-purchasing agreement with N.B. Power."
Yea Right
Costs to the public...
Works for one group!
Search “Sinopec forecasts China's coal consumption to peak around 2025”
Reply to Bill Gardiner
Wind is the second least expensive way to generate electricity next to solar...
NB Power has been banned from owning such facilities and is only allowed to purchase such generation from private companies...
Weird...
Not really Ask yourself a simple question
Cui Bono?
"According to the NB Power 2023 Integrated Resource Plan, all current and future wind farms will be owned by private companies. That means the benefits from generating cheap wind power will accrue to private shareholders rather than the public. NB Power should own the wind turbines so the savings can be used to reduce the cost of our electricity."
Reply to Danny Sterns
It is, except for those who would rather not transition.
Reply to Bill Gardiner
Doesn't matter whether want it or not. "the world is already transitioning " lol
Reply to Gerry Roberts
It doesn't matter, but the point is that some people still don't like it.
Reply to Bill Gardiner
and that is an issue because .............?
Reply to Gerry Roberts
Ask the OP, he brought it up.
Reply to Bill Gardiner
No you brought it up.........."except for those who would rather not transition."
Reply to Gerry Roberts
In response to the OP.
Reply to Danny Sterns
Depends on how much taxpayers will be on the hook for
Reply to Bill Gardiner
you choose to respond thus bringing up people who would rather not transition
Reply to Dennis Woodman
There's no government money even being considered.
Reply to Gerry Roberts
Yes, I did. :)
Reply to Bill Gardiner
then You, raised the issue regarding people who allegedly don;t want to transition knowing full well it's not an issue
Reply to Gerry Roberts
"Knowing full well"? How do you know I know what you think I know.
Reply to Gerry Roberts
You don't know that. Why are you making things up?
Reply to Bill Gardiner
I've been studying your skill at knowing what you think other posters and politicians know. It took me a while but I've mastered it, just like you
Reply to Bill Gardiner
"we" all know that bill. No one is making things up!
Reply to Dennis Woodman
If indeed tax payer money is involved, rather this than $1 billion for soccer games.
Reply to Bill Gardiner
That you know of. I believe there has at least been some discussion. Time will tell
Reply to Dennis Woodman
You have absolutely zero evidence of that, so why even mention it? That's how damaging rumors start.
Reply to Danny Sterns
Hard telling not knowing for sure
Reply to Dennis Woodman
Why be happy to be on the hook at all?
Reply to Bill Gardiner
"How do you know I know what you think I know. "
Methinks the EUB knows I know a lot you don't know N'esy Pas?
I doubt it
all major projects do require environmental analysis.
Irving knows best the places where the natural environment has already been destroyed; they destroyed it.
Would those subsidies exceed those given to the O&G industries?
Oh, and Doug Ford estimates that with primary and secondary jobs, there'll be about 30,000 total jobs created.
Environmental Education Programs
(506) 246-1114
admin@fallsbrookcentre.ca
www.fallsbrookcentre.ca
No comments:
Post a Comment