New Fredericton courthouse to close door on 'perp walks' for accused
Building on King Street to be constructed with new system that restricts view of those being escorted inside
The controversial practice of perp walks are an opportunity for news media to capture images of a suspect in a system where cameras often aren't allowed in court.
The term appears to come from the U.S, where law enforcement officers are known to intentionally march a handcuffed suspect through a crowd of photographers and reporters.
In New Brunswick, the practice is more a by-product of the need to move suspects from the sheriff's van into the courthouse for hearings or trial.
In
high-profile cases, such as the trial of Matthew Raymond, who was found
not criminally responsible for killing two police constables and two
civilians in Fredericton in 2018, photos taken at his court appearances
were the only opportunity for the public to match a face to the name. (CBC)
But with the construction of a new justice building in Fredericton, the ability to photograph a suspect being walked into court will become a thing of the past.
Instead, suspects will be transported into the facility through what's known as a "sally port," said Judy Désalliers, spokesperson for the Department of Justice and Public Safety.
"These secure, controlled points of entry and exit are a means to keep corrections staff, sheriffs and inmates safe," Désalliers said, in an email.
It functions like a secure garage, she said, with the sheriff's vehicle driving into the space before an overhead door closes.
"They reduce opportunity for escape and mitigate risk of introduction of contraband as well as other security breaches."
Désalliers said the newer Miramichi, Saint John and Moncton courthouses already have sally ports, which she described as "a standard security feature in modern courthouses."
New courthouse in 2025
The province announced in 2021 that a new justice building would be built on King Street in Fredericton, replacing the courthouse in the Justice building on Queen Street, which was originally built as a school in 1876 before being converted to a courthouse in the 1970s.
The new courthouse is set to be finished in 2025 and will result in the closure of the Queen Street courthouse and the Burton courthouse, where Fredericton Court of King's Bench matters are currently heard.
In high-profile criminal cases, such as the trial of Matthew Raymond, who was found not criminally responsible for killing two police constables and two civilians in Fredericton in 2018, photos taken at his court appearances were the only opportunity for the public to match a face to the name.
Potential harm
Véronique Chadillon-Farinacci, an assistant professor of sociology and criminology at the University of Moncton, sees a problem with the so-called perp walk.
She said it can elicit shame and embarrassment from the accused, which can be problematic in instances where they're later found not guilty.
"If the person is declared innocent and there's a picture out there of that same person with handcuffs, maybe it would [generate] prejudice when you're looking for a job, when you meet a partner, where you want to volunteer in your community or when you have a business," she said.
Perp
walks, even those done due to logistical reasons, can be harmful to
someone's reputation if they're later found not guilty, said Véronique
Chadillon-Farinacci, a University of Moncton assistant professor of
sociology. (Zoom/CBC)
With the new Fredericton courthouse being built with a sally port, Chadillon-Farinacci said she doesn't see much value lost in no longer being able to photograph suspects being led in and out.
"I'm just wondering what is the plus value? The courthouse is public, so if the public wants to see what's going on, wants to see the person, can go already.
"The perp walk doesn't have a plus value for the reparation process with the victim."
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Yea Right. Anyone tried visiting the courts lately?
No comments:
Post a Comment