Sunday 14 April 2024

Blaine Higgs pitches exporting LNG as alternative to carbon tax

 
When Methane reacts with oxygen, it results in the formation of carbon dioxide, water along with heat and light.
 
EXOTHERMIC – Reactions that release or give off Energy are Exothermic. Most reactions give off
heat. Burning fuels gives off heat. Here is the reaction for burning Natural Gas as in your kitchen
stove.
CH4+ 2O2 → CO2 + 2H2O + 890 kJ 

 
 
 

Blaine Higgs pitches exporting LNG as alternative to carbon tax

Premier testified at House of Commons hearing

New Brunswick Premier Blaine Higgs appeared virtually at a parliamentary committee on Thursday. He and Conservative premiers across the country are arguing against the carbon tax, which is set to rise on April 1.

Prime Minister Trudeau has challenged premiers who are opposed to the carbon tax to offer alternatives. Higgs says exporting natural gas from a New Brunswick energy company is a better solution.

"I'm offering the prime minister a solution that's real," he said after the hearing, in an interview with As It Happens.

By supplying liquefied natural gas to global markets, Higgs said Canada can have a major impact on shutting down coal plants around the world.

He specifically mentioned converting a Saint John LNG plant, owned by Repsol, into a natural gas exporter. The plant itself ruled against this possibility last year.

Higgs told the committee the carbon tax is only a solution "within the bubble" of Canada and will have little impact on worldwide emissions.

He complained that "80 to 100" coal plants were being built annually in China, and with continued use of coal plants in Europe and four in Atlantic Canada, a carbon tax is only burdening citizens, instead of having a global impact.

shale gas protestors Higgs proposed shale gas extraction, an idea that has been opposed by First Nations and others in New Brunswick. (Jennifer Choi/CBC)

"The situation in Canada is we're too isolated in our bubble, we're not reaching our potential to help the world," Higgs said.

While some industry analysts have said shale gas extraction has major potential for New Brunswick, the province has faced major pushback from First Nations, environmentalists and others in the past.

In his opening statement, Higgs claimed that his appearance before the committee wasn't political.

"I don't want to make this a political discussion, we all don't like the carbon tax. I think we can all agree in part we don't like the carbon tax," he said.

"I want to continue to argue we just need to let the science let us help the world reduce emissions," Higg said, without elaborating on what science he was referring to.

NDP, Liberal MPs question Higgs

Higgs was questioned by Fredericton Liberal MP Jenica Atwin in an exchange that was feisty, at times.

She read a quote from Higgs from when the provincial carbon tax was scrapped in favour of the Trudeau government's federal system. Higgs cited the rebate cheques as a way for New Brunswickers to get money back.

"Is it the case that you're more interested in playing politics than looking after the affordability of New Brunswickers and tackling climate change?" Atwin asked him.

Higgs replied by saying the rebate cheques aren't offsetting what people are losing to the carbon tax. 

Jenica Atwin Fredericton Liberal MP Jenica Atwin questioned Higgs about his party cancelling a debate over taxes on the N.B. Power rate increase while he was appearing at this Ottawa committee instead. (House of Commons Livestream)

Citing a study by the Canadian Climate Institute, Atwin said carbon taxes reduce emissions over time and asked the premier if he had a better plan.

"Worldwide? Absolutely," Higgs said.

Richard Bragdon, Conservative MP for Tobique-Mactaquac, thanked Higgs for testifying and agreed that New Brunswick has "such amazing potential." He, like Higgs, said the carbon tax is putting a strain on local industry and harming his constituents.

"It's punitive, it's prohibitive, it disproportionately affects those of us who live in small towns and rural communities," Bragdon said.

Liberals tried to block Higgs, other premiers from testifying

Higgs's appearance was held up by Liberal committee members raising points of order with committee chair Kelly McCauley, a Conservative MP from Alberta.

McCauley was under fire for inviting several premiers to speak against the carbon tax without consent of committee members.   

Following an appearance by Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe yesterday, committee members passed a resolution that requires their consent for witnesses to be called.

After a back and forth that was at times heated, and went on for about half an hour, McCauley ruled that Higgs would be allowed to speak because he had been booked to testify before the ruling, and it did not apply retroactively.

Alberta Premier Danielle Smith went on to testify following Higgs.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR


Sam Farley

Journalist

Sam Farley is a Fredericton-based reporter at CBC New Brunswick. Originally from Boston, he is a journalism graduate of the University of King's College in Halifax. He can be reached at sam.farley@cbc.ca

CBC's Journalistic Standards and Practices
 
 
110  Comments
 
 
 
Margie Anderson
G'night Lou.
 
 
 
 
Lou Bell   

Koffi Babone  
Reply to Lou Bell
Sorry buddy, but Higgs and Smith do not represent my views at all.. Quite the contrary, and probably on most topics they bring up.
 
 
 
 
Lou Bell    
Margie Anderson
Reply to Lou Bell
Why are you bringing any other country into the conversation? This is about Canada and what Canada can do. Stop worrying about countries which any Canadian government has zero control over.  
Oscar Biasinni 
Reply to Lou Bell 
So the premier of Alberta complains that Trudeau not helping, built them a 38billion pipeline, former Alberta premier Jason Kenney waste 7.5 billion on a pipeline to nowhere. Maybe, these premiers should step up and act responsible.
Robert Tangence 
Reply to Lou Bell 
Also I'd like to know how New Brunswick is supposed to supply India and China with LNG from ships. I question you're Canadian considering you don't even know that New Brunswick is an Atlantic province, and not on the Pacific.
David Wilson
Reply to Lou Bell
Also... when exactly did China and India jump on board with Higgs plan 
Don Corey 

Reply to David Wilson
David Wilson 
Reply to Don Corey  
China's emissions under current policies are projected to peak by 2025, five years ahead of its 2030 target, 
Don Corey 

Reply to David Wilson
Don Corey 

Reply to David Wilson 
David Wilson 
Reply to Don Corey   
China, which did not have to undertake any commitments under the Kyoto Protocol, has marginally more solar and wind capacity per capita than Canada. 
Don Corey 

Reply to David Wilson 
David Wilson 
Reply to Don Corey  
China has a population of 1.412 billion citizens and there are only 38.25 million Canadians as of 2021. If we calculate these numbers under a per-capita basis, each Canadian emitted 75 per cent more carbon than each Chinese.
David Wilson 
Reply to Don Corey  
I just did. 
 
 
 
 
John Pokiok  
Carbon tax is just that a tax and its not reducing emissions nor is doing any benefit to the planet. We are polluting more than ever but all we are doing is paying more for it. I'm unable to reduce my usage of gas any further and I can't afford to buy an unreliable overpriced electric car.
Frank Loomer 
Reply to John Pokiok  
That's about the size of it for me too. I pay the tax, get a cheque back, i ran the calculator but it wasn't helpful. It suggested i'm a net loser, maybe $32/month.
Koffi Babone 
Reply to John Pokiok
You should have a read at the article below:
https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/carbon-pricing-climate-report-1.7151139   
Don Corey 
Reply to Koffi Babone  
The article confirms that industrial carbon pricing works, but consumer carbon pricing doesn't. It also helps explain why very few countries have taken the radical approach of applying a consumer carbon tax on transportation and home heating.  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

 

No comments:

Post a Comment