Tuesday 16 April 2024

Province's education action plan short on clear targets

Province's education action plan short on clear targets

Officials say measurable goals will ‘come quickly’ once project teams get to work

The Higgs government has released an "action plan" for improving the province's anglophone school system, but specific actions and measurable targets are still to come.

The plan unveiled Tuesday includes timelines for tackling thorny issues, including classroom composition and students who frequently miss school, but it doesn't set out precisely how progress will be assessed.

For example, it says success will be measured by improved literacy and numeracy scores — but doesn't set out a target for how much they'll improve.

Project teams in each area will establish measurable goals, said Tiffany Bastin, the assistant deputy minister for education services in the anglophone school sector. 

"Once the work is underway, that's where the evolution of the [measurements] will come," said Bastin, who co-chaired a steering committee that developed the ideas. "It will come quickly."

Nor does the plan set out how the system will change.

The report says a model "will be developed" on how to intervene with students who miss school often, and that the existing classroom composition model will be "reviewed."

The action plan builds on a report by the steering committee that examined how to improve anglophone schools after the cancellation of the government's plan last year to replace French immersion with a new French-second-language program.

Public consultations on that plan revealed widespread concern among parents and teachers on a range of issues, including classroom composition — how a large number of students with special learning needs can affect or disrupt classrooms.

WATCH | Education Minister Bill Hogan says 'exact' timelines still being developed:
 

Education ‘action plan’ short on specifics

Duration 2:20
Anglophone system continues to struggle with classroom composition, attendance

The steering committee report last November urged a rethinking of social promotion, the practice of "moving students forward" to the next grade level "without the necessary foundational skills."

Bastin acknowledged that a lack of resources in the system can make it difficult to intervene to help those students.

"That would be our first aim, to intervene immediately and urgently to get those students caught up, and at times that isn't always possible where there's a lack of resources," she said.

"So part of this improvement is looking at how do we get those resources working right away with those learners that are behind."

A woman with brown hair wears a leather jacket and sits at a podium. Ardith Shirley, the executive director of the New Brunswick Teachers’ Association, says the government has released a solid plan. (Ed Hunter/CBC)

Ardith Shirley, the executive director of the New Brunswick Teachers' Association and the other co-chair, agreed that resources — including staffing — will be key.

"The plan is in place. It's a solid plan. The trick will be actualizing it." 

Last fall's report called for the province to balance class sizes so that schools can support students with extra learning needs, while minimizing the potential disruptions for other students.

But the action plan doesn't set out how the province will overcome a potentially major obstacle: maximum class sizes set out in the labour contract with the New Brunswick Teachers' Federation, an agreement renegotiated last year that runs to 2026.

Education Minister Bill Hogan said the government will talk to the union to look at what flexibility is possible within the existing agreement and "to see what we can embed in the contract, if anything" the next time it is renegotiated. 

Minister promises 'specificity'

Last December, Premier Blaine Higgs said in a year-end interview with CBC News that the school system was "a mess."

He complained again about French immersion not producing enough bilingual graduates and implied the steering committee's recommendations were not enough.

"It needs to be more than that," he said.

Hogan did not say Tuesday whether he agreed with Higgs, instead describing again the report's proposals for French-second-language education and echoing Mastin by saying "implementation teams" would develop "more specificity" about the plan. 

ABOUT THE AUTHOR


Jacques Poitras

Provincial Affairs reporter

Jacques Poitras has been CBC's provincial affairs reporter in New Brunswick since 2000. He grew up in Moncton and covered Parliament in Ottawa for the New Brunswick Telegraph-Journal. He has reported on every New Brunswick election since 1995 and won awards from the Radio Television Digital News Association, the National Newspaper Awards and Amnesty International. He is also the author of five non-fiction books about New Brunswick politics and history.

 
 
 
80 Comments
 
 
 
David Amos 
Hogan did not say Tuesday whether he agreed with Higgs 
 
  
Al Clark  
Reply to David Amos
Is there a night shift premium?



David Amos 
 
Well well well! Surprise surprise surprise! 
 
 
 
Lou Bell 
 
Appears JP " confused " once again , as expected . Prmier Higgs is 100 % correct , the education system is a mess and has been for years.
 
 
David Amos   
 
Reply to Lou Bell
If anyone understands being confused its you
 
 
 
 
Wilbur Ross   
Everyday Higgs asks himself: "What would Ted Cruz do?" 
 
 
B Johnny Kalibanos 
Reply to Wilbur Ross 
And then what happened. ?
 
 
David Amos    
Reply to Wilbur Ross   
What do you ask Trump? 
 
 
Wilbur Ross
Reply to B Johnny Kalibanos  
? 
 
 
 
Wilbur Ross 
Higgs couldn't care less about education in this Province. He's too busy campaigning in Ottawa. 
 
 
David Amos    
Reply to Wilbur Ross   
True
 
 
 
Greg Miller 
Government -- safe your breath and our ears -- when you have a plan let us know! 


David Amos    
Reply to Greg Miller 
Well put 
 
 
 
 
Brian Robertson
The only education plan that would get Jacque's approval would be one from a Liberal government.
 
 
Graham McCormack
Reply to Brian Robertson
A plan without resources and measurables is not a plan, it is an outline.
 
 
MR Cain
Reply to Graham McCormack  
The plan needs to have a goal, a purpose, a target, and how to get there.
 
 
Graham McCormack
Reply to MR Cain
And this "plan" has none of that. 
 
 
David Amos    
Reply to Brian Robertson 
Interesting that you meet with his approval 
 
 
 
 
Frank Wentworth  
Step 1: Make an announcement

Step 2: Figure out how we are going to make it work

page 13, PC Playbook

 
David Amos    
Reply to Frank Wentworth
You forgot something  
 
 
 
Al Clark 
A great way to avoid constant disappointment with higgy's bright ideas is to manage expectations like I do ;-)  
 
 
David Amos    
Reply to Al Clark 
Yea Right 
 
 
 
Lou Bell
" Status Quo " is the order of the day from the Liberals it appears . Why are they so against improvements to the Anglophone system here in NB ? 
 
 
David Amos    
Reply to Lou Bell
What about "Quid Pro Quo" ??? 
 
 
Stephen Campbell  
Reply to Lou Bell
I believe that is their way of saying 'we don't have any viable alternatives to offer until after the next election because we don't want to upset the electorate heading into a campaign'.
 
 
Frank Wentworth  
Reply to Lou Bell
Liberals aren't in power and haven't been for 6 years. But they must have really rattled you in those 4 years because there isn't a day that goes by that you don't talk about them. 
 
 
 
 
Lou Bell
Once again , the left is " confused " . Was " confusion a course in school ? Semms to be a lot of it going around amongsty the greens and Liberals these days .  
 
 
David Amos   
Reply to Lou Bell
I thought we already dealt with the "confused" issue??? 
 
 
 
 
Frank Wentworth
The report says a model "will be developed"

"Once the work is underway, that's where the evolution of the [measurements] will come," said Bastin.

Doesn't seem like a very detailed plan to me.

 
Robert Tangence
Reply to Frank Wentworth
Evolution? Glad to hear that's still allowed to be taught in New Brunswick school classrooms.  
 
 
David Amos   
Reply to Robert Tangence 
Now thats funny   
 
 
David Wilson   
Reply to Robert Tangence 
Not for long lLOL  
 
 
Al Clark 
Reply to Robert Tangence 
Education minister in waiting fayteen has plans fo that, don't worry ;-) 
 
 
David Amos   
Reply to Al Clark
She has to defeat your buddy a former turncoat MP first correct?  
 
 
Al Clark  
Reply to David Amos
?





Le Wier  
Interesting. Tiffany Bastin the assistant deputy minister for education services is the daughter of Emil Olsen the Quispamsis PC Association President. 
 
 
David Amos   
Reply to Le Wier  
Very interesting 


Le Wier  
Reply to David Amos
Emil Olsen was employed in the petro chemical industry in NB as a mechanical technologist. The biggest petro chemical employer in NB is Irving. 
 
 
David Amos   
Reply to Le Wier 
I have talked to this dude

Emil Olsen has been a member of Quispamsis Town Council since 2004. He served as deputy mayor from 2008-2012

 
Le Wier  
Reply to David Amos
That is him. 
 
 
David Amos   
Reply to Le Wier
I have a question for you 
 
 
Al Clark  
Reply to Le Wier   
Emil's large developments don't fit Blaine's predictably anti-fed promotion. 
 
 
Le Wier  
Reply to Al Clark
We know from the past if you don’t agree with Higgs he fires you. 
 
 
Al Clark  
Reply to Le Wier  
Yes he firmly believes there is an I in team ;-) 


David Amos   
  
Reply to Al Clark 
You should know  
 
 
 

Le Wier  
Sounds vague. Reminds me of the plot from Seinfeld.
 
 
Lou Bell  
Reply to Le Wier  
Not quite as vague as the undisclosed Phonie games .


David Amos     
Reply to Lou Bell 
Not quite as vague as our first comments  
 
 
Graham McCormack 
Reply to Lou Bell  
You should watch the movie Frozen. 
 
 
Wilbur Ross
Reply to Le Wier   
Arrested Development ...
 
 
David Amos     
Reply to Graham McCormack  
Or Obama's movie "Leave the World Behind"
 
 
 
 
 
Marc LeBlanc  
No problem

In Higg's world all parents are good parents. They'll know what to do

While we're at it, get rid of lunch programs as all parents send their kids to school with healthy lunches. Guidance staff eliminations will save alot as well because all parents know what career path is best for their children and don't worry about an 85% vacancy rate among school psycologists as all parents can handle the intricate balance of dealing with todays massive pressures the digital world imposes on their children.

The possibilities are endless

 
Lou Bell  
Reply to Marc LeBlanc 
Actually , in Higgs world , the school lunch program has been expanded to include all who need it Your false speculations sound more like what the liberals will have in their platform . Right along with the dropped voting age , and the " vote by sticker " they had at their planning meeting . One just need bring their own stickers . 
 
 
Lou Bell  
Reply to Marc LeBlanc 
Appears they got their idea from " pin the tail on the donkey " . May have been how they chose their candidates , or maybe even leader . 
 
 
David Amos   
 
Reply to Lou Bell
Pin the tail on the donkey in order to boot a jackass out of office??? 
 
 
David Amos     
Reply to Lou Bell 
Too Too Funny 
 
 
Al Clark  
Reply to Lou Bell
probably correct. I thought you were a fan of higgy btw..........


David Amos   
 
Reply to Al Clark 
Colour me flabbergasted, like a chinese mill owner finding a shredded panhead at the bottom of the boat ;-)"   
 
 
 
 
Alex Butt 
"New Brunswick's education action plan short on clear targets". Just like pretty much everything else as well. While the government is only good at raising taxes, helping the irvings, fighting over pronouns and billingualism and allowing nb power to run amuck, the healthcare, schools, roads and infrastructure are worse than a third world country and that is being passed on as acceptable?!?!?!  
 
 
Lou Bell  
Reply to Alex Butt 
Anyone who understands at all would see Educators are involved in this . And Higgs pays our bills , something the Liberals know nothing about . Just take a look at our National debt . More than doubled and now in the trillions of dollars . All in 4 years !!  
 
 
David Amos     
Reply to Lou Bell  
Higgy played his part in that debt 
 
 
 
 
Alison Jackson 
This Bill Hogan guy looks angry all the time, like he's ready to bite someones head off.  
 
 
Le Wier  
Reply to Alison Jackson  
That’s his resting principal face. 
 
 
David Amos     
Reply to Alison Jackson
Could it be that he is? 
 
 
Dan Lee 
Reply to Alison Jackson 
hmmm.....i think he is using head lice powder........he is scratching his head every time higgs speaks
 
 
David Amos     
Reply to Dan Lee 
Naw he is pissed because I keep reminding him of many things like my Harley you like tease me about 
 
 
 
 
MR Cain 
The do-nothing government continues to do nothing. Lots of studies, lots of reports, lots of committees, lots of distractions.  
 
 
Alex Butt 
Reply to MR Cain
And lots of waste of money as well!  
 
 
David Amos     
Reply to Alex Butt 
Yup 
 
 
Lou Bell  
Reply to MR Cain 
Anyone understanding the story at all would realize this is the start of cleaning up a decades old mess , that the liberals had no interst at all in addressing , mostly because they had no idea how to do it . 
 
 
Lou Bell  
Reply to Alex Butt 
Really ? Look at ther billions plus the liberals added to the NB debt , just i the last 4 years they were in office . And we got nothing from them . 
 
 
 
 
 
Kyle Woodman  
The Education system, like Health Care, has been broken for some time. But I think it is wiser for us to complain about the existing system than the government actually making changes, it is just good common sense. After all, those of us who post on here are experts in all the fields the articles detail. Let's not wait and let the steering committee implement changes and adapt as needed as most good plans encompass and instead just say this is another failure of the Higgs government. Bring on Holt, our province was in such good shape while she was advising Gallant on what to do, debt, taxes, and scandals are good things. 
 
 
Kyle Woodman
Reply to Kyle Woodman  
Good one Ronald  
 
 
David Amos     
Reply to Kyle Woodman
Surely you jest





 

No comments:

Post a Comment